Anyone suicidal enough? :D
-
Sorry, not remembering any point where I needed a grappling hook in my life......

"Needed" might be to much, but i remember situations (outdoors, not attacking medieval castles) where they would have been handy.
I just don´t do such stuff anymore.
Grappling hooks were used to pull DOWN stuff, not to climb up. Too dangerous to climb. Defenders can simply cut the rope and attackers have both hands occupied and are vulnerable. Slap up a ladder and the attacker can have one hand free or even both hands free in some situations . Plus, it's much harder for defenders to dislodge the ladder.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Sorry, not remembering any point where I needed a grappling hook in my life......

"Needed" might be to much, but i remember situations (outdoors, not attacking medieval castles) where they would have been handy.
I just don´t do such stuff anymore.
Grappling hooks were used to pull DOWN stuff, not to climb up. Too dangerous to climb. Defenders can simply cut the rope and attackers have both hands occupied and are vulnerable. Slap up a ladder and the attacker can have one hand free or even both hands free in some situations . Plus, it's much harder for defenders to dislodge the ladder.
Hmmm, we were trained with them for urban combat.
Group gives covering fire to a buildings windows, one man (usually one of the lighter ones in the group) sneaks to the building. Throwing a handgrenade into the choosen window in a upper storage, then the grappling hook. Climbing up just under the window, auto fire into the room, going in. Securing the hook to ensure it´s fit for the more heavy comrades while securing the door. Second man climbs up, then the third ..... then searching and cleaning the building.
Off course that throwing the grenade and hook plus climbing and securing the room has to be done fast, too. No time for putting on any kind of climbing rig, just go up the doubleline ropes with knots every 30-40cm.
Ladders of different types were also trained, you use whats available and suits the situation best.
I would have loved to use them in situations like crossing a fast flowing river. As a securing thing. It´s one thing to have a rope on you that is hold by friends to pull you back if needed, but its nicer to have a second line already on the other side, to help you keep a little bit safe(r) stand, or pull yourself over while swimming.
It could help the first one crossing, then he can secure the rope on the other side to help the others. -
@Mr. Whippy said:
Sorry, not remembering any point where I needed a grappling hook in my life......

"Needed" might be to much, but i remember situations (outdoors, not attacking medieval castles) where they would have been handy.
I just don´t do such stuff anymore.
Grappling hooks were used to pull DOWN stuff, not to climb up. Too dangerous to climb. Defenders can simply cut the rope and attackers have both hands occupied and are vulnerable. Slap up a ladder and the attacker can have one hand free or even both hands free in some situations . Plus, it's much harder for defenders to dislodge the ladder.
Absolutely! I would never scale a castle wall with a grappling hook except in the dead of night with no guards at the top. In every other event I would use my seige engine backed up by trebuchet bombardment. Any other way is suicide.
-
Grappling hooks were used a lot in the age of sail in ship to ship engagements, and for more practical day-to-day ship operations. Solid ones, though... not folding ones.
Also, I feel a strong need to append the character list to Batman, Rorshach, and Luke Skywalker. Just sayin'.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Grappling hooks were used a lot in the age of sail in ship to ship engagements, and for more practical day-to-day ship operations. Solid ones, though... not folding ones.Also, I feel a strong need to append the character list to Batman, Rorshach, and Luke Skywalker. Just sayin'.
And Boba Fett
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Grappling hooks were used a lot in the age of sail in ship to ship engagements, and for more practical day-to-day ship operations. Solid ones, though... not folding ones.Also, I feel a strong need to append the character list to Batman, Rorshach, and Luke Skywalker. Just sayin'.
Yes, this too. I don't know, folding and security seem almost mutually exclusive.
@Lichtbote said:
Hmmm, we were trained with them for urban combat.Group gives covering fire to a buildings windows, one man (usually one of the lighter ones in the group) sneaks to the building. Throwing a handgrenade into the choosen window in a upper storage, then the grappling hook. Climbing up just under the window, auto fire into the room, going in. Securing the hook to ensure it´s fit for the more heavy comrades while securing the door. Second man climbs up, then the third ..... then searching and cleaning the building.
Off course that throwing the grenade and hook plus climbing and securing the room has to be done fast, too. No time for putting on any kind of climbing rig, just go up the doubleline ropes with knots every 30-40cm.
Ladders of different types were also trained, you use whats available and suits the situation best.
I would have loved to use them in situations like crossing a fast flowing river. As a securing thing. It´s one thing to have a rope on you that is hold by friends to pull you back if needed, but its nicer to have a second line already on the other side, to help you keep a little bit safe(r) stand, or pull yourself over while swimming.
It could help the first one crossing, then he can secure the rope on the other side to help the others.Interesting. Never would have believed that was a preferred method of scaling a wall. At least for me, you couldn't pay me enough to take that risk. :o
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
At least for me, you couldn't pay me enough to take that risk. :oGiven a low enough window, and a high enough payday, I'd do it.
Second story window.
Would you do it for a thousand?
Lynn: Are you crazy?
Would you do it for two hundred million?
Lynn: Up I go!!!!Unlike many other people, I CAN be bought. Heck, for two hundred million, I'd sing the praises of the Engage MT! :D
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
@Mr. Whippy said:
At least for me, you couldn't pay me enough to take that risk. :oGiven a low enough window, and a high enough payday, I'd do it.
Second story window.
Would you do it for a thousand?
Lynn: Are you crazy?
Would you do it for two hundred million?
Lynn: Up I go!!!!Unlike many other people, I CAN be bought. Heck, for two hundred million, I'd sing the praises of the Engage MT! :D
Fair enough. :D
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
@Lynn LeFey said:
@Mr. Whippy said:
At least for me, you couldn't pay me enough to take that risk. :oGiven a low enough window, and a high enough payday, I'd do it.
Second story window.
Would you do it for a thousand?
Lynn: Are you crazy?
Would you do it for two hundred million?
Lynn: Up I go!!!!Unlike many other people, I CAN be bought. Heck, for two hundred million, I'd sing the praises of the Engage MT! :D
Fair enough. :D
Hell, for 200 million, I would scale the wall without a rope and hook.
-
@ducttapetech said:
Hell, for 200 million, I would scale the wall without a rope and hook.Oh, no! For 2 hundred million, you have to do it USING the Engage MT. >:D
Now, THAT's suicidal!

-
@Lynn LeFey said:
@ducttapetech said:
Hell, for 200 million, I would scale the wall without a rope and hook.Oh, no! For 2 hundred million, you have to do it USING the Engage MT. >:D
Now, THAT's suicidal!

Hmmmmm, 200 million for scaling a wall using a Engage......here, hold mah beer...........
-
Can't hold your beer. I'm holding my own. And my other hand is holding my backup beer.

-
Alright, I just drink mine and my backup beer real quick......
-
Lmao! This made me remember a Bud commercial, "would you do it for a 12 pack of Bud?"
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Interesting. Never would have believed that was a preferred method of scaling a wall. At least for me, you couldn't pay me enough to take that risk. :o"Preferred" is the wrong word, it´s not easy, is dangerous, it hurts, ..... i believe everyone loves to use the stairs. ;)
But when it´s the best chance to not being shot and to fulfill the order .... you would do it that way, and that for the small payment, too.

-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Given a low enough window, and a high enough payday, I'd do it.Second story window.
Would you do it for a thousand?Usually it was for the story above the ground level story, do you call that the second story? Here it is "ground level story" , "first upper story" , "second upper story" , ...... - i would guess 4-6m, depending on the building. In reality not that high, but enough to be dangerous.
For a story above that we had a sort of corded/jacobs-ladder - assembled it looked like a big hook on top of a really long aluminium stick, with some steelropes on its sides sticking out. You placed the hook somewhere you thought i will hold the weight, then pulled on the end and the alu stick disassembled itself to the single ladder runs. Then pray that it´s hook is safe and climb.
Far away from thousand. More around 200 dollar per month.

At that time Germany had no profession army, every male and healthy man had to do his military service (or in exchange something for the community, rescue service or so) for such a small basic pay, a little bit more if you volunteerd for a longer timeframe.
Today they pay better. :D But you do not volunteer to be paratrooper/airborne for the money. And it helps to be a little bit nuts. ;)
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Given a low enough window, and a high enough payday, I'd do it.
Second story window.
Would you do it for a thousand?Usually it was for the story above the ground level story, do you call that the second story? Here it is "ground level story" , "first upper story" , "second upper story" , ...... - i would guess 4-6m, depending on the building. In reality not that high, but enough to be dangerous.
Yes, what most of Western Europe calls the 1st floor, Americans call the 2nd floor. (ie in the US, you enter on the 1st floor and walk up one flight to the second floor)
-
U. S. Rangers used rocket-propelled grappling hooks in their attack on Pointe du Hoc on D-Day.

-
I've wanted one of these for awhile now.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
