Most "Problematic" multitool brand
-
From what i have read, there seems to be more "problems" with Leathermans" purely because there are so many of them out there. Looked at in percentages they are all probably quite similar. :-\ In my own experience, non, never had a problem with any of them :)
-
@Roadie said:
From what i have read, there seems to be more "problems" with Leathermans" purely because there are so many of them out there. Looked at in percentages they are all probably quite similar. :-\ In my own experience, non, never had a problem with any of them :)im in the same boat, maybe i havent use them too hard......yet :)
-
@Roadie said:
From what i have read, there seems to be more "problems" with Leathermans" purely because there are so many of them out there. Looked at in percentages they are all probably quite similar. :-\ In my own experience, non, never had a problem with any of them :)Now come on Ryan, don't go spoiling a perfectly good thread with your common sense and reason - it complicates things ;)
It's funny sometimes when you read statements like "Leatherman tools rust" or "Gerbers are weak", when as you point out, these two brands probably sell more multitools than all of their competitors put together. Obviously therefore, you're going to see more "problems", just like you're going to find more people who are completely happy with them.
A point I seem to be making a lot lately is that you should make your own minds up on things, and don't believe the hype! It does bother me though that newcomers to the site might actually believe some of the crap that's spouted ::)
-
From what i have read, there seems to be more "problems" with Leathermans" purely because there are so many of them out there. Looked at in percentages they are all probably quite similar. :-\ In my own experience, non, never had a problem with any of them :)
Now come on Ryan, don't go spoiling a perfectly good thread with your common sense and reason - it complicates things ;)
It's funny sometimes when you read statements like "Leatherman tools rust" or "Gerbers are weak", when as you point out, these two brands probably sell more multitools than all of their competitors put together. Obviously therefore, you're going to see more "problems", just like you're going to find more people who are completely happy with them.
A point I seem to be making a lot lately is that you should make your own minds up on things, and don't believe the hype! It does bother me though that newcomers to the site might actually believe some of the crap that's spouted ::)
I think that don’t have much to say really. Sure Leatherman have sold more MT than Gerber and SOG, but the user of this forum have had experience with most of the companies.
-
I wonder if most problems were caused by abuse.
-
Maybe I'm just a sissy with my tools and don't use them hard, but other than the time the little spring that holds the bit in place on the LM Surge driver popped out. I have never had a problem.
-
What problems have you had with Gerbers Rockyman? Which ones do / did you have?
the suspension...the knife snapped with little force and the
tweezersjaws just crumble...Any others?
-
I was taught to use tools for appropriate tasks. Any device will break if abused beyond it's intended work load. As such, the only multitool that ever gave me a problem was a Stanley Automatic multitool (mini version of the SOG SwitchPlier) The plier handle broke off in my hand as I was clamping on some air.
That's right, air. ::)
-
In my limited experience , Gerber has made some real pieces of Poo . The only actual plier breakages I have experienced were Gerber and SOG . In niether case were excessive levels of force involved . I have pushed Leatherman tools quite hard , and got away with it .
Chris
-
@prime77 said:
Maybe I'm just a sissy with my tools and don't use them hard, but other than the time the little spring that holds the bit in place on the LM Surge driver popped out. I have never had a problem.same here
What problems have you had with Gerbers Rockyman? Which ones do / did you have?
the suspension...the knife snapped with little force and the
tweezersjaws just crumble...Any others?
nope...but out of MTs I've had...a knockoff held up better than a gerber
-
@J-sews said:
I was taught to use tools for appropriate tasks. Any device will break if abused beyond it's intended work load. As such, the only multitool that ever gave me a problem was a Stanley Automatic multitool (mini version of the SOG SwitchPlier) The plier handle broke off in my hand as I was clamping on some air.That's right, air. ::)
Must have been below sea level or something

-
I was taught to use tools for appropriate tasks. Any device will break if abused beyond it's intended work load. As such, the only multitool that ever gave me a problem was a Stanley Automatic multitool (mini version of the SOG SwitchPlier) The plier handle broke off in my hand as I was clamping on some air.
That's right, air. ::)
Must have been below sea level or something

::) :D
-
so far, gerber's out on top...who wouldda thought?
-
Bear aren't doing so well.
-
@rockyman500 said:
My vote is going towards Gerber on this one...I've never broken a multi, but I try not to overstress my multis - except during exigent circumstances.
I have been present at the demise of three different multis due to plier failure: 2 LM Juices and 1 LM Supertool.
The Juices failed on two different backpacking trips while their owners were trying to repair a whitegas stove and an aluminum packframe. A plier jaw snapped off just ahead of the pivot in both cases.
The Supertool failed when its owner tried to remove a lag bolt screwed into a wooden beam. One of its jaws snapped off about halfway between pivot and tip. (LM fixed that Supertool under warranty, although it did take quite a while for the owner to get it back as I recall.)
From seeing these three failures do I conclude that LM tools are weak? Not at all.
The failures all happened while the multis were being overstressed.
The Juice failures were due to exigent circumstances - their owners NEEDED to make repairs out in the field and those Juices were the only tools they had.
The Supertool failure was operator error. Other tools were available, so why overstress a multi by forcing it to do a job that calls for a wrench?
.
-
Ryan nailed my exact thoughts! LM is obviously going to have "more" duds so to speak. I haven't had any catastrophic LM failures, but they make so many- a tool that slips QC is inevitable. :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
