LM Juice S2... red or dead?!
-
I just received a lovely RED Juice S2... yes RED!
I'm not really an orange kinda girl so when I saw the S2 was available in red I got a little bit overexcited
Some good buddies of mine in the US sent it over as a gift so it's even more special to me, however the little shiny is not a perfect entity... and here goes my first review for MTO.Let's talk packaging Leatherman, what's up with that?! Do we really need a ginormous blister pack in these ecologically sound times? I think not personally, and even given the size of the great big tin in the package, it was still utterly OTT. The tin however, is probably going to be useful so I forgive them this faux pas.
So, after hacking my way through the plastic to get to the tool my first impression was that it was a nice size and weight. It's 3.25"/8cm and 4.4oz/125g so much smaller and lighter than all the big plier based tools. Shown here compared to the chunky 6 layer SAK Craftsman, you can see it's a fair bit smaller. It is comfy in the hand and the anodised Alu is nice feeling and looking. Weight wise, it would probably compare to around a 4 layer SAK so depending on what your tool needs are, it may not have the most tools for it's size. It certainly doesn't have the most bang for your buck tool selection wise.

If however, your needs are a fairly decent plier then you would probably take the S2 over the cute but smaller SAK style pliers. The plier head has the needlenose/regular combo, with wire and hard-wire cutters. They feel sturdy and the grip is good except if you have wet hands - you will probably find your hand sliding down towards to head. Apart from that, they are quite comfortable for a small tool. Out of the box, the plier joint is quite stiff which is probably a good thing as it will loosen up with time I suspect. I wouldn't trust them for any serious heavy duty work.

Now to the screwdrivers: The phillips is pretty decent; nicely squared off at the end and clicks open with a very strong reassuring snap. Here it is next to a SAK phillips, slightly smaller but a chunky little tool. The slim nature of the tool body means you get a decent reach with it too.

The flatheads are of a similar quality - perhaps 3 is one too many but they are of a good size range and so will probably come in handy. I measured them at around 6mm, 3.5mm and 1.5mm, all with nicely squared heads. They are really difficult to get out though, breaking nails along the way! I hope this will loosen up eventually.

The scissors are not the best feature of this tool, in fact, they let it down IMO. The spring lever bit only opens to a small aperture so if you want a decent open cutting width you have to do it manually. The rivet has far too much play in it which may just be my model but makes them feel a bit flimsy. The cutting edges are actually good when you overcome these shortcomings but the pale in comparison to Charge or SAK scissors. You also have to open the bottle/can opener first to get at them which is a bit of a faff. They don't snap open or close very nicely either, needing to be pushed firmly all the way back in which is a let down.


As for the aforementioned opener, it seems capable of the jobs it's designed for. It doesn't have any sharp edges on it which might not make it the best can opener out there - an easy mod to sharpen the thing if necessary (or simply for devilment).
Finally we have the main blade. It's an odd looking clip point with a rounded back to match the outer profile of the tool but came out of the box pretty sharp. It's quoted as being 420HC steel so not the best out there but certainly not the worst. I have yet to see what kind of edge it holds after a bit of EDC abuse >:D
The cutting edge is about 58mm so well under legal carry length for us poor souls in the UK and it snaps open pretty nicely without any obvious play.
Just a mention on the closed up package now; it doesn't sit evenly as one side is thicker then the other. The scissors and opener side require more space then the blade side so the profile is not flush. This is a small but irritating niggle as this is how it will ride in my pocket. Why didn't they throw a saw or serrated blade on the other side to balance it out? I honestly can't see a reason why not. You may just about be able to see what I mean below:

The S2 also has one of those much debated lanyard rings tucked away next to the phillips - I actually like this feature as I often hang tools in my pocket but I know it's a contentious subject!
So that's the S2 from my viewpoint. Overall, it breaks down like this:
PROS:
Small handy EDC package
Good bit tools
Useful compact pliers
Mine is RED! (which matches my hair :D)CONS:
Lousy scissor set up
Stiff nailbreaking bits
Uneven width on handles
SpendyWould I recommend it? Yes if the tool compliment is exactly what you need. If you can live without the scissors then I think the old KF4 model would be a far superior purchase - sadly discontinued much to the lament of LM fans everywhere. Overall, I give the S2 a 7 out of 10.
-
Excellent review!
Good photos too.
-
-
Love that Red! I have the Storm Grey and love the compactness and weight of it. I was just commenting via another thread on mine the one end of it looks really sloppy the way it's been riveted together because of all the tools and metal they've crammed into it. How's does yours look nice and straight?
-
Great read Nu.
Having seen and played with various Juice models I think I agree with everything you've said. I'd be more tempted to get one if it wasn't for the fact they cost so much and I have no money. ::) 
-
@Sean said:
Love that Red! I have the Storm Grey and love the compactness and weight of it. I was just commenting via another thread on mine the one end of it looks really sloppy the way it's been riveted together because of all the tools and metal they've crammed into it. How's does yours look nice and straight?Not sure what you mean by straight but my rivets seem to look OK. Perhaps it's a QC issue, which may also account for my sloppy scissors!
-
-
Great review lassie, you've certainly got a talent for it

-
-
-
@Wetdog said:
The S2 is a solid little tool. I've often wondered if the sides would be even if they lost the bottle opener. Can/bottle openers are the least used tools on my MTs - I could do without them. The S2 minus the opener would be perfect.Yeah, I'm with you on that one. I could happily live without the opener on it and it would make it even. It seems like an afterthough on LMs part - quick, cram an opener in where it doesn't fit!
Thanks for the replies chaps... I can assure you that review writing is a lot more fun than a 10k word dissertation on ATM gene methylation in Hodgkins lymphoma. I think I stopped writing after that

-
The S2 is a solid little tool. I've often wondered if the sides would be even if they lost the bottle opener. Can/bottle openers are the least used tools on my MTs - I could do without them. The S2 minus the opener would be perfect.
Yeah, I'm with you on that one. I could happily live without the opener on it and it would make it even. It seems like an afterthough on LMs part - quick, cram an opener in where it doesn't fit!
Thanks for the replies chaps... I can assure you that review writing is a lot more fun than a 10k word dissertation on ATM gene methylation in Hodgkins lymphoma. I think I stopped writing after that

Hijack:
So, is Hodgkins Lymphoma a B cell tumor or not?
-
It's a very fair and accurate review, and while the Juice does have some flaws, I still like it.
-
[quote author=Mr. Whippy link=topic=11216.msg208082#msg208082 date=1242917210
Hijack:
So, is Hodgkins Lymphoma a B cell tumor or not?
[/quote]In all probability, yes. Although I finished researching this topic a couple of years ago so there may be newer papers available giving a definitive answer. The cells I was working with were almost definitely mutated B cells... and I had to laser cut 100's of the little bast*rds out of tissue samples locked in a small room going crazy :ahhh
-
Great writeup girl
I have been checking out the S2 lately and I may hold off on it for a while yet but someday I will have one
Great pics as well 
-
-
@nuphoria said:
Let's talk packaging Leatherman, what's up with that?! Do we really need a ginormous blister pack in these ecologically sound times? I think not personally, and even given the size of the great big tin in the package, it was still utterly OTT. The tin however, is probably going to be useful so I forgive them this faux pas.It's to prevent shoplifting, you can tuck a big blister pack in your pocket. Leatherman offer both blister pack and cardboard box packaging and retailers decide which to order. Big box store tend to buy blister, while the smaller stores that keep stuff behind locked counter tend to order box.
-
-
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


