Grappler -versus- Crunch
-
With the demise of the Kershaw A100 and the Schrade ST6 (and cousins) the Leatherman Crunch has been the only game in town for a few years now when it comes to locking plier multitools. But not anymore, as this year Gerber has thrown down the gauntlet with their new Grappler.
I just got mine yesterday and so haven't had much time with it yet, but I've already formed a few impressions on how it stacks up against the Crunch:

The most obvious difference between the two is size; the Grappler is a fair amount larger than the Crunch. But is this an advantage, or a disadvantage? For me it comes down to capability -versus- carrying size.
For carrying size, the point goes to the Crunch, as it is both shorter and narrower than its new rival:


But how about capability? Despite being the bigger of the two, the Grappler's mechanism limits how far its jaws can be opened. Now this may or may not be an issue depending upon the individual user, but as can be seen in the picture below (with jaws fully open) the Crunch is able to clamp onto much larger objects.

As regards blades though, the Grappler's size advantage really begins to make itself felt. The 3" knife blade for instance is far more capable than the puny Crunch blade. Additional downsides to the Crunch blade include a triple whammy of being woefully slow to deploy, being on the "wrong" side of the handles, and having the plier adjustment knob located right smack dab in front of it.

The file blade comparison is almost no contest, with a clear advantage to the Grappler. The only "plus" for the Crunch is the teeth along the edge of its file, something the Grappler lacks. (why?) ::)

When it comes to phillips screwdrivers, the longer one is usually the preferred one. But after testing both on a variety of different screws around my house, I chose the Leatherman over the Gerber. Its three-dimensional shape just "fits" the screws better. The flat phillips works mind you, but it tends to "cam out" when the going gets tough. :-\

All in all though, the blade competition came out in favor of the Grappler. Longer reach, one hand opening, and all liner locking make its blades fast and easy to deploy, as compared with extremely short length and fiddly deployment with the Crunch.

One Grappler function that I'm particularly anxious to try out is this pry bar. It forks on the end. It thins out on the end. It bends upward ever so slightly on the end. :)

It looks perfectly shaped. Hopefully it is made strong enough.

Speaking of fast deployment, the Grappler uses a sliding jaw set up like the traditional Gerber multi-pliers have used for almost 20 years. It is very quick to get the jaws out, even one handed.....

.....but then one must reach in with thumb and forefinger to adjust the jaw opening via this little knob. Close jaws on object to test fit.....open jaws.....adjust knob.....check fit again......open jaws......adjust knob....etc etc until the correct size and desired jaw tension is achieved. Hmmm, maybe this isn't so quick after all. :-\


But the Crunch isn't exactly speedy either. Open the handles, get out the jaws, assemble the parts. :P After that it gets quicker though, as the Crunch jaws can be dialed in quickly with the outboard adjustment knob. (It does require two hands though) :-\


Perhaps I'm simply used to traditional Vise-Grip (Mole-Grip) pliers, but I didn't necessarily find the Grappler's fast slide-out plier head to be that much quicker given that is only the first step in getting the tool clamped up correctly.
Wire cutters on both models seemed to work equally well on some #12 copper stranded I had laying around:


An important consideration though: the Grappler - probably due to its more complex mechanism - has a fair amount of "give" in its plier head. I have no good way to measure clamping strength, but I'm certain the Crunch is able to exert far more force than is the Grappler. Case in point, the Grappler had to be adjusted up rather high in order to cut through the #12 copper. At lower levels of adjustment, it simply would stop short of cutting clear through.
Additional testing on the Grappler will need to be done to see if locked-jaw clamping force is truly an issue or not.
So in the end which one is better? I'll go with the usual cop-out answer and say, "That depends." ;) If you want mostly a set of locking pliers and don't feel you'll use the blades and drivers that much, go with the Crunch. If on the other hand you use a knife and a file and a prybar often enough that fast one hand access is important, and occasionally have the need for locking pliers, then the Grappler seems like the better choice.
:)
-
Excellent review!
Bob,
Shoes?
;)
-
The jaws seem to be thinner on gerber, wonder how it'll hold up ham fisted people.
-
good review

-
Thanks for the comparison. Bet either tool would hurt if dropped on your bare feet. :D
-
More on the Grappler:
It doesn't open and close in a "scissor" fashion like most pliers. Instead the one handle and one jaw (on the same side) remain stationary, while the two on the opposite side do all the moving.

It sort of reminds me of the SOG SwitchPlier. (which never seemed like it had much jaw force)

- Barefoot Bob :D
-
Thx for the great comparison review Bob

-
Back to seriousness for a second:
For me, locking pliers have the downside of being slow to reapply. The upside is you can put a tremendous amount of grip on a bolt/nut in situations where there isn't a good socket/wrench solution. I've been known to put a 4 foot piece of pipe on a visegrip to turn a frozen nut. Either the nut turns or the bolt breaks, but either way the parts are coming apart.
Now I wouldn't put a 4 foot pipe on a Crunch, but I might put a 2 foot cheater bar on it.
From the sounds of it, the Grappler may not be able to withstand that much torque. Is that the gist of the jaw strength comment Bob?
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Back to seriousness for a second:For me, locking pliers have the downside of being slow to reapply. The upside is you can put a tremendous amount of grip on a bolt/nut in situations where there isn't a good socket/wrench solution. I've been known to put a 4 foot piece of pipe on a visegrip to turn a frozen nut. Either the nut turns or the bolt breaks, but either way the parts are coming apart.
Now I wouldn't put a 4 foot pipe on a Crunch, but I might put a 2 foot cheater bar on it.
From the sounds of it, the Grappler may not be able to withstand that much torque. Is that the gist of the jaw strength comment Bob?
That's it exactly Mr. W

-
Great pics and review Barefoot Bob :D I may try an track a Grappler down just to take a gander at it but I don't believe it will replace my Crunch anytime soon ;)
-
Nice Review,
I didn't even know gerber had a contender...
What is the material for the file on the Grappler?
After some use the point might go to the Crunch if the Grappler goes blunt and gets gummed up.
-
Great job and pictures as always Bob

I'd be interested to know which "feels" better in your hands "in use" over time ;)
-
I think if i was going to get one for use while out on my bike etc i would go for the crunch as much smaller, very good review and great pics

paul
-
The biggest let down for me is the jaw opening width of the Grappler. Sigh.
-
Thank for that info and clear pictures

-
i gave up waiting for a review... and bought one.. should be here by mid this week. Then this happens!
i still have personal high hopes for the grappler. I am not to certain about the torque argument. Everytime i clamped down with either of the 2 crunches i had owned it had a chance of 'popping' off its handle. It was much more frequent when i tried to use them as conventional pliers :-\
Since i don't have a crunch atm i might do some field testing vs a china 4" vice grip i have that i more often not resorted to instead of the crunch.
Incase i am the first to state this you refered to the crunch as a charge on the last line above the second photo

PS is it just me or gerber should release a 'Mini grappler' based on the mp400 frame
-
Great pics of the Multi-Tools, and great review as well.
I noticed in pics #9 & 10 that you have a "toe ring" on your big toe, very cool. :D
-
Fantastic job as ever Bob mate

-
Good to hear your impressions Bob. And great shots as always.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
