skeletool knife blade
-
thought it best to create a separate thread for this to make it a more focussed discussion.
What do people think of the knife blade on the skeletool? They have chosen to go with 154CM steel on the CX version, maybe itll be 440C on the non-CX skeletool. I had hope it would be s30V on the CX version.
What about its shape? At first I didn't really like it but the curved design may work well for cutting. However I do think its going to have quite a fragile tip, which is a shame.
Also, I wonder why LM didn't go with the half plain, half serrated blade we see on some of their folding knives, I think I would have preferred that.
-
Good topic.Everybody's so interested in the tool itself,and the bit driver in particular,it's time to give some discussion to the blade.
Personally I think the tool is going to be aimed more at the lifestyle crowd that'll put it through lighter work than heavy duty users.If that's the case LM probably made the right choice in blade shape.Given what LM did with the Charge series,you may well see S30V in the next generation,and then again Nov. is still some time away,and we won't know what the final configuration will be until the official release.
If Leatherman would put out a model with a combo edge like Vic(serrations forward)I'd be one happy camper. -
hmm not that i have thought about this much, but I would have thought that serrations near the hilt of the knife would have been better, since when you wish to use them (e.g. in cutting some rope) you want very controlled movement, which you get a greater degree of with the back of the blade rather than the front / tip.
What are the advantages of having the serrations near the front?
Also, I wonder why has no multitool maker made a knife blade which has some sort of micro-serrations on it, which give the best of both worlds (i.e. very slight sawing motion). Would save space, with the way LM have made a combo can and bottle opener, I would have thought they might have done this also. I suppose an alternative is the half serrated - half plain blade config.
-
Actually proponents in either camp have valid points. Serrations hilt first are ideal when you need to work with something like rope;to me ,serrations forward work best when you do food preparation. If I had a spare Vic OHT.I'd send it to you and let you work with it and see what you think.
I guess it all boils down to your own past experience,and preference. -
I hate mixed blades. You end up with a compromise of 2 half size blades that only do half the job a full blade will do. Many manufacturers produce separate knives with the different full blades, why do the multi - tool manufacturers fob us off with these half blades? If they are going to produce just one option I would rather it be a straight edge because it is easier to sharpen and of more general use. I guess it would also sell better but with a few changes I would buy both tools if they offered each type of blade on separate tools.
Dave
-
I would happily sacrifice one of the numerous flatheads that have been showing up more and more for a dedicated serrated blade and a dedicated plain edge, but that's just me.
The blade shape really doesn't bother me too much. In fact, I think I like it more than the standard clipped point offered by many manufacturers including Leatherman. Clip points are weak tips, but the lighten the end of the blade for speed in combat, just like ol Jim Bowie's knife. Fantastic idea when you are dealing with rustlers, but I like every implement on a multi to be industrial grade strong. It's a trick of the manufacturer to include a point style that will subconsciously appeal to handyman folks who have likely seen many classic westerns.
The drop point that is pictured will be significantly sturdier than a clip and I like it because it allows more use of the edge. The upswept part of a clipped blade rarely sees any use, and is also a pain to sharpen.
Def
-
I agree with disliking mixed blades. I prefer a plain edge also.
I still think of the Freestyle/Skeletool as more of an outdoors tool. It's small, light, simple, and the caribiner would be perfect for clipping to a pack.
-
I like the idea of a carabiner on a tool. In fact, that was the thing I liked most about the Sheffield Mountaineer tool I reviewed:
http://multitool.org/content/view/101/68/
Def
-
@Raukodur said:
What about its shape? At first I didn't really like it but the curved design may work well for cutting. However I do think its going to have quite a fragile tip, which is a shame.Also, I wonder why LM didn't go with the half plain, half serrated blade we see on some of their folding knives, I think I would have preferred that.
It looks to me like the blade shares some DNA with the Benchmade Griptilian modified sheepsfoot blade.

I feel this is a good thing, the modified sheepsfoot blade on the Griptilian is an excellent general use cutter with a good tip.I am curious about the overall size of the tool if the blade is only 2.6".
-
The Griptillian is a pretty popular model- it only makes sense to make a similar blade.
Def
-
I personally wish Leatherman would offer each blade option (PE or half-and-half) on models such as the skeletool and the Wingman.
They already produce the PE blades for the skeletool CX and the Sidekick, but if you want a PE blade and an all stainless skeletool, or a PE blade and the Wingman tool load, you're stuck.
I know you can source some PE blades from various places, but it doesn't seem like it would be too difficult for Leatherman to cover this.
-
Necrothreading

-
I agree cause some of us like PE like me
and apparently sometime or another some of these peeps like the combo blade
:D -
-
Word of the day: necrothreading.

-
-
I wanted to join the trend and I thought this thread was still relevant.
Plain edge fan myself.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




:D