Knife point patterns
-
The "spear point" moniker comes from early (at the very latest) 1900s knife advertisements and is the correct descriptor for most SAK blade styles.
The numbered chart is interesting and appears to show the spear point correctly but the actual picture and text in the Wikipedia article is an incorrect interpretation that is actually a dagger blade and not a spear point since it is sharpened on both sides.


But then again, since we're dealing with something that is old, poorly documented and non-standard we could pick nits all day and not reach any solid conclusion. ;)
-
@Spoonrobot said:
But then again, since we're dealing with something that is old, poorly documented and non-standard we could pick nits all day and not reach any solid conclusion. ;)Well now I think that goes without saying for pretty much any thread on this forum doesn't it :D

-
@markn951 said:
while I heed that warning, I myself edit wikipedia, know many people that edit wikipedia, know the policies there, and can tell you pretty definitively that Wikipedia is probably one of the most reliable sources you'll find on the internet. All the facts have to check out, it's not like anyone can write anything on there. If they do, it's reverted, especially if it's vandalism. Remember that just anyone can make a website, too!Anyways, you may very well be right, I'm no knife historian, but it makes sense that the spearpoint came first, as it is symmetrical.
Ouch.....
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
while I heed that warning, I myself edit wikipedia, know many people that edit wikipedia, know the policies there, and can tell you pretty definitively that Wikipedia is probably one of the most reliable sources you'll find on the internet. All the facts have to check out, it's not like anyone can write anything on there. If they do, it's reverted, especially if it's vandalism. Remember that just anyone can make a website, too!
Anyways, you may very well be right, I'm no knife historian, but it makes sense that the spearpoint came first, as it is symmetrical.
Ouch.....
Def
but not anyone can make them as good as yours :D
-
@WhichDawg said:
understand wikipedia is not gospel or always correct, anybody can put stuff there.I believe a "drop-point" is a modified spear-point come up with later in history ;)
I think!Also it was always my understanding that the "drop-point" had a point closer to the spine side where as the SAK blade the point has been moved in the other direction if that makes sense
-
since you are so big on Wilki then fix this http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victorinox
Swiss Army knives are widely used outside the army. They are useful, multi functional instruments, and are available in a wide variety of sizes and functional combinations. Even NASA astronauts have a Victorinox knife as standard equipment.[4] Victorinox knives have also been taken to Mt. Everest and the Arctic. The flagship model of Victorinox, the SwissChamp, is in the New York Museum of Modern Art's Permanent Design Collection. There is also an active Swiss Army Knife modding community, producing new models from cannibalised parts.
The model is in fact a Champion
-
@yud said:
since you are so big on Wilki then fix this http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VictorinoxSwiss Army knives are widely used outside the army. They are useful, multi functional instruments, and are available in a wide variety of sizes and functional combinations. Even NASA astronauts have a Victorinox knife as standard equipment.[4] Victorinox knives have also been taken to Mt. Everest and the Arctic. The flagship model of Victorinox, the SwissChamp, is in the New York Museum of Modern Art's Permanent Design Collection. There is also an active Swiss Army Knife modding community, producing new models from cannibalised parts.
The model is in fact a Champion
Do you mean that their flagship is the champion or the model in the museum is a champion?
-
@markn951 said:
while I heed that warning, I myself edit wikipedia, know many people that edit wikipedia, know the policies there, and can tell you pretty definitively that Wikipedia is probably one of the most reliable sources you'll find on the internet. All the facts have to check out, it's not like anyone can write anything on there. If they do, it's reverted, especially if it's vandalism. Remember that just anyone can make a website, too!Anyways, you may very well be right, I'm no knife historian, but it makes sense that the spearpoint came first, as it is symmetrical.
I know lots of people who deliberately sabotage Wikipedia - they have a name for the sport but I can't recall what it is
Obviously such vandalism is beneath me and I wouldn't do something so childish 
There is some right old dollop on there. Errors and vandalism are only reverted if someone spots / challenges that it isn't right, and that can take a while sometimes ;)
-
while I heed that warning, I myself edit wikipedia, know many people that edit wikipedia, know the policies there, and can tell you pretty definitively that Wikipedia is probably one of the most reliable sources you'll find on the internet. All the facts have to check out, it's not like anyone can write anything on there. If they do, it's reverted, especially if it's vandalism. Remember that just anyone can make a website, too!
Anyways, you may very well be right, I'm no knife historian, but it makes sense that the spearpoint came first, as it is symmetrical.
I know lots of people who deliberately sabotage Wikipedia - they have a name for the sport but I can't recall what it is
Obviously such vandalism is beneath me and I wouldn't do something so childish 
There is some right old dollop on there. Errors and vandalism are only reverted if someone spots / challenges that it isn't right, and that can take a while sometimes ;)
I'm not sure about straight-up incorrect information, but I know that the average revert time for vandalism is around 15 minutes.
-
It depends on the popularity of the page, and how closely people watch it. Also, sometimes vandalism can be quite subtle and it takes a trained eye to realise that it isn't actually a legitimate change that's been made. A classic example are the pages on English football clubs. Just read the edit history on some of them, they amuse me for hours.
If you are clever, you can make something read well enough to the layman, but actually insult people who know about the subject by demeaning something.
Allegedly.
-
since you are so big on Wilki then fix this http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victorinox
Swiss Army knives are widely used outside the army. They are useful, multi functional instruments, and are available in a wide variety of sizes and functional combinations. Even NASA astronauts have a Victorinox knife as standard equipment.[4] Victorinox knives have also been taken to Mt. Everest and the Arctic. The flagship model of Victorinox, the SwissChamp, is in the New York Museum of Modern Art's Permanent Design Collection. There is also an active Swiss Army Knife modding community, producing new models from cannibalised parts.
The model is in fact a Champion
OK, done. Updated with references and everything.

-
since you are so big on Wilki then fix this http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victorinox
Swiss Army knives are widely used outside the army. They are useful, multi functional instruments, and are available in a wide variety of sizes and functional combinations. Even NASA astronauts have a Victorinox knife as standard equipment.[4] Victorinox knives have also been taken to Mt. Everest and the Arctic. The flagship model of Victorinox, the SwissChamp, is in the New York Museum of Modern Art's Permanent Design Collection. There is also an active Swiss Army Knife modding community, producing new models from cannibalised parts.
The model is in fact a Champion
Do you mean that their flagship is the champion or the model in the museum is a champion?
The model in the Museum is a Champion. MoMA Collection
The 24-tool "Champion" has been displayed in New York's Museum of Modern Art and the Staatliches Museum fur Angewandte Kunst in Munich as a pinnacle of product design. In the 1990s, it retailed for about $90;
yep, sorry went away for the weekend and did see this till now
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login