Battery advice
-
Hello everyone. I am trying to determain if I should buy primary or rechargeable batteries for the way I use a flashlight. I need to purchase batteries. I have AAA and CR123 lights. I am not a hardcore user. I do not use my Quark 123 regular or Preon 2 for an hour a day. I use my lights to spot check mainly so they run a few minites at a time or for a few seconds. For this application would i simply be better off with primary batteries? Which brands do you think are best suited for me? I see CR123's for $1 each and some for more, so is it worth paying more for xyz brand, or just get the cheapies? Should I use alkaline or lithium AAA"s? In my case do you think rechargeables are worth the investment?
-
I'd go with AAA Eneloops for the Preon 2. Regular Alkalines in a high-draw light like that are just something I don't trust. That and the fact that the Eneloops will last through years of charging, have extremely low self-discharge and can recharged whenever you want makes them a worthwhile investment. At least in my opinion. ;)
For CR123 lights I'd stick with the Lithium Primaries since I don't care for Li-Ion rechargeables. I prefer Surefire or Streamlight cells.
-
Another vote for the eneloop AAAs. Since I found out about them I never used any primary AA or AAA cells and replaced them all with eneloops.
-
Yep, eneloops ftw

-
The CR123 cells come in a broad range of prices that many times does not reflect a proportional increase in performance.
I would recommend the Titanium Innovations CR123 Primaries.
They can be purchased for little over a dollar and perform comparably to the more expensive Duracell and Surefire cells.
Under certain high drain applications sometimes they perform a little better.*(High drain = Flashlight on Max)*
Here's what I mean:

**BATTERIES TESTED
OUTPUT OVER TIME ON THE SAME FLASHLIGHT
OUTPUT OVER TIME ON THE SAME FLASHLIGHT***Graphs made by SelfbuiltOn the graphs it shows that the output is neck and neck for almost the entire duration of the burn.
The 4Sevens cells also perform very well but cost a bit more at close to $2 each.
The more expensive brands do have a measurable performance advantage, especially in the medium drain area and shelf life.
Still we are talking years of shelf life for all of these cells and medium drain performance differences of approximately 10%.Hope this helps.
As for the AA & AAA's I agree with everybody...ENELOOPS.
-
Thank you for this clear and helpful info. I am interested in performance and not name brand, so if the model you mentioned is the best value then that is fine with me. Thank you for the time and research. :)
-
Update to my last post, I was talking with someone locally where I live who is a flashaholic and he let me borrow and use a rechargeable RCR123 setup with 10 cells, two of each brand and the charger. He is letting me try it out to see if they will work for me, if not then I can use primaries. There are Battery Station, Ultrafire, AW, and AW IMR cells, a pair each. We will see what happens and how it works for me. :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login