Folder and OH multitool philosophy
-
For general use, I don't need a seperate folder. When I used to work backstage at a theatre, which involved lots of cutting, I preferred to have a seperate knife (Spyderco). It was just nicer to use. When I carried both, weight was not an issue. The Spyderco was clipped in my pocket, the multi was a Charge Ti which was on my belt, along with 2 flashlights.
A similar question was asked over at Bladeforums, and the general consensus was most folk who carry a seperate folder and multi are knife enthusiasts. For cutting duties, they preferred to use their favourite folder and that was their primary cutting tool. The multi was secondary.
-
For me, the need for a dedicated cutting tool is convenience. I have a perfectly good knife on my multitools, but the time it takes to unsheath and unfold etc, I could have a pocket knife out and job done. I'm currently considering a Benchmade Griptilian as my dedicated folder, but if I were carrying a Skeletool, I would not also carry the folder at the same time. The Skeletool has a very decent and capable OHO blade and is a pocket carry tool.
-
At least one angle is that a dedicated cutting tool usually has a better blade than a multi. What "better" means is usually found in the user's taste. Maybe the blade steel is stronger, or takes a better edge or keeps it longer. Maybe the size of the blade is better than that on the multi...longer or shorter, thinner or thicker. Like Sawman, maybe it's a matter of convenience. Maybe the blade shape does something specific that the user needs, like a serrated edge, curved blade, or a chisel end. Perhaps the folding knife simply complements the blades on the multi, or vice versa.
One thing a dedicated folder is going to have over a multi with a knife is ergonomics, in almost every case. For extended cutting, or with a need for fine control, having a well centered blade with a comfortable, easy to grip handle could easily overwhelm any weight concerns.
I carry a Wave most of the time, usually with a Victorinox SAK in my pocket. I don't carry a dedicated non-tool-bearing folder very often. However, if I know I'm going to be doing a lot of cutting I'll still stick in a dedicated knife (usually a folding utility knife or a three-bladed Case.) Simply put, they're a lot more comfortable.
-
Donald, I think they were a cable-guy (with all the tools on the belt) in a past life! :P :D
-
I ask myself the same thing.
Personally, I hate any tool duplication and I get all irritable when people post EDC set-ups with something like 11 blades in it. :ahhh Carrying a MT that isn't OH and a OH folder I do understand though as although there is duplication, you are gaining OH ability with the folder.
-
For heavy-duty, or even light duty cutting that I need to do a lot of, dedicated folders are generally much more comfortable than multi-tools. Not always the case, of course, but there are a lot more choices in ergonomics for folders.
It's also easier to get specific blade types in folders than MTs - good luck, for example, getting a hawkbill or leaf-shape flat ground blade in a multi-tool.
-
I got a Skeletool CX today so that should take care of my EDC for awhile. I think I'll even pass on a dedicated folder for now, as I like the blade on the CX and it's OHO so what more could I want. Then of course I have good pliers and screwdrivers plus a carabiner, things couldnt be better 8)
-
MT are usually not comfortable in hand, and blade size is smaller than my preference (3.2"~3.5").
-
Thanks, got some very interesting insights, I have to agree on some points but I don't agree on others, but I respect everyones opinion. I think blade size preference is a good point most multi blade does not go beyond 3.5 inches and if you have no OH blade on your multi it would take time to deploy. Agree on the skeletool too its the best compromise I think for a multitool an analogy of the multi is its a flying fish, not better than a fish in swimming and not better than a bird in flying but its the best flying fish you can find for now. And WD you crack me up :D
-
Multi's have generalist blade shapes and sizes , dedicated folders offer a broader range of choices .
All that said , of late my New Wave is doing 99% of my cutting , the remaining 1% being handled by mt Vic. Electrician Plus ( short cable blade and awl ) .
I have even got to like the butt heavy ergo's of the Wave .
Chris
-
@Styerman said:
Multi's have generalist blade shapes and sizes , dedicated folders offer a broader range of choices .All that said , of late my New Wave is doing 99% of my cutting , the remaining 1% being handled by mt Vic. Electrician Plus ( short cable blade and awl ) .
I have even got to like the butt heavy ergo's of the Wave .
Chris
If you think the wave is heavy wait till you handle the SURGE :D
I think it might be a good idea giving the full size LM another smaller blade comparable to Vics smaller blade for delicate cutting. -
That reminds me of another point, MTs are heavy. My heaviest folder weights 5 oz and that thing is built like a tank, whereas even the lightest MT is close to 6 oz.
-
Going by that then, why not carry a non-OH MT?
-
The Skeletool is not all that heavy even compared to a PST or Pulse. Great for pocket carry, but then, your knife needs to go in either the other pocket or a sheath

-
For many years I have carried an MT only. That was my only blade.
For most of that time, the blade on the multi was not OH. This didn't bother me much.. until I got hold of an OH MT... the SURGE. That changed everything.
For quite a while, that was still my only EDC blade. But I could never dream of going back to a non-OH MT after that. I did pick up a Gerber EAB eventually, and it became EDC as well, but this is because my job requires me to cut things that will trash a standard blade, and I needed a utility blade that was replaceable. The EAB replaced my truck based utility knife, and was so handy, it found it's way into my non-work EDC as a money clip.
So now I was at two blades.
And then you f*ckers managed to get me into the Swiss forum. And all bets were now off.
I picked up an Explorer and loved it so much that it became EDC. The small blade is most handy, and the long Phil driver compliments the short SURGE bit adapter. I began to see a SAK as a perfect compliment to a MT, and it was now an EDC must to have both.
So now I was at four blades.
And then those dammed 111 Vics started calling me at all hours of the night. "You know you want us. Just come and get us. All you need is some money."
111 SAKs are such whores.
I found an OH Sentinel with a clip. My usual EDC is bag based, so the Explorer and the MT live there. That Sentinel was just sooo nice... and it was great to have it right there on my pocket.. even though I didn't really need it. Once I started using it for daily cutting tasks though, I grew to like it more and more.
So now I was at five blades.
Right now I am hoping that Leatherman will quit f*cking off and get a new SURGE model out into the world. I have decided to not buy another Leatherman until they do this. DO YOU HEAR ME LEATHERMAN?!? GET OFF YOUR SS AND QUIT FCKING AROUND WITH GUN TOOLS! I DO NOT EDC A BLOODY M16!
But when they do introduce an updated SURGE, I am going to pair it with a custom SAK. I will have to keep the EAB for work, and it makes a fine money clip anyway. But my goal is to get down to 3 or 4 blades again.
As opposed to going up to six.
:ahhh
-
I hope LM doesn't forget about us useless civilians after they make it big selling gun tools to the armed forces. :(
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login