Serrated vs. non-serrated
-
I know I've seen a little discussion on serrated blades. Wenger has some of their models with serrated blades. I'm kind of the sharpness weirdo and am interested in other's views. While I like to get an edge literally mirror polished razor sharp there is one case where that is not the best. The term "sharp" has different meanings depending on what a blade is sharp for. There is one case where you don't want a mirror polished razor edge and that is for cutting rope and cord. This is where a serrated edge has a clear advantage. It also doesn't need the same sharpening maintainence. For a knife to have a serrated blade I also like it to have an additional regular blade.
-
I like a "micro serrated" edge- basically a plain edge that has been sharpened down to a medium grit to leave a microscopic jagged edge which gives the blade some bite on anything.
Def
-
I prefer non serrated blades. That said, my Spirit S has both and my non-serrated blade is my user blade, along with the Wenger PTC. That way my serrated blade stays laser sharp in case I need it in an emergency, like cutting a seat belt in a burning car.
-
I have pretty much the same opinion as you, Fred. I like my plain edge knives to be as sharp as possible, but I appreciate a serrated blade for some tasks. If I carry a serrated blade, it is always in addition to a very sharp plain-edge blade.
Since I always have a SAK of some sort on me, I tend to carry a regular Swisstool Spirit (w/scissors). If I carry my Swisstool X, I usually pair it with an OHT.
-
On the whole I prefer plain blades as they tend to be more useful. I do see that the serrated blade is more useful in some specific areas. I'm one of the few that think the serrated butterknife on the Spirit is neat. :-[
-
I do cut rope/cord and other things where a PE blade might not cut it(pun intended). On <3" blades I think combos are almost useless and would go PE. My CRKT M2114's 4" blade is combo but there's enough of the PE and SE that either works very well.
-
I really like serrated blades... It cuts basically everything and it stays sharp for a long time and very easy to sharpen! Well, with the Smith sharpening stick I bought..
-
I just got a DMT sharpener for serrations. It looks pretty damn easy. OK, I haven't technically sharpened serrations yet but I can't understand why everyone says it's so hard to do. Maybe if you're doing a fully serrated 6" knife then that's a lot of serrations to do, but on a 3"-4" knife I can't see it being that much of a PITA. Guess I'm gonna find out soon. :D
-
I generally prefer PEs but as far as serrated blades go, Victorinox got it right. They are on the correct end of the blade and the cut of them is very good and I have not found them to bind like others do.
-
I like both serrated and plain edge blades, but not in half/half combination. The serrated blade cuts much faster when cutting fibrous material like plants or rope and I favor it when doing outdoor yard work.
The tip of the Spyderco Native shown on the right below is plain edge while the major portion of the blade is serrated. This proportion works well for me.

-
I like both types of blades, although depending on the situation one is better than the other. I would like to see a design like this with both types of blades instead of 2 PE's. Maybe it's already out there, anyone know?
Calvin
-
I'd just rather make my own serrated blades with a rough stone as Def was talking about above. I've done this for years on a tip from a knife-sharpening site. I think the whole serrated thing started with the tough-looking tactical knives or maybe the Ginsu knife craze.
One of my favorite "serrated" knives is the Boye knife Basic with what he calls Dendritic Cobalt. The crystals in the steel form micro serrations that really cut well without the need for visual serrations or special sharpeners. The blade looks normal, but it works like a serrated.


Check it out:
http://boyeknives.com/Index.cfm?CFID=2847918&CFTOKEN=32103813&jsessionid=a4302584741f4428783e
-
Look what I found in my box of toys.
Calvin

-
Another shot.
Calvin

-
I always liked the concept of dendritic cobalt blades, but they didn't last long and so I thought that while the theory was sound they must have been a gimmick. I remember reading about Paul's "new" blades when they first came out and they were part of this outdoors series with animal and nature scenes etched on the blades, similar to the Franklin Mint garbage. That may have hurt them as lots of other people probably saw them the way I did.
I wouldn't mind giving one a shot someday.
Def
-
@Defender said:
I always liked the concept of dendritic cobalt blades, but they didn't last long and so I thought that while the theory was sound they must have been a gimmick. I remember reading about Paul's "new" blades when they first came out and they were part of this outdoors series with animal and nature scenes etched on the blades, similar to the Franklin Mint garbage. That may have hurt them as lots of other people probably saw them the way I did.I wouldn't mind giving one a shot someday.
Def
I just like the way the knife looked, very minimalist. I don't know nuttin' bout birthin' no babies or dendritic cobalt!
Calvin
-
I have the Basic 1, 2, & 3 & like them a bunch, although I don't carry fixed blades very often.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



