Electricians - recommendations
-
Hi everyone. Done alot of reading of the site and forum and thought i would sign up and ask a question. I just started my electrical apprenticeship and my folks have said they want to get me a MT as a present.
At the moment i'm looking at the Leatherman Charge TTi. Its on amazon for $100 with a sheath and tin. Just thought i would see if any sparkies out there would recommend something different?
I'm in Australia if that makes any difference.
Cheers, Luke.
-
Hi Luke, welcome to the forum.
While the TTi is a nice tool in it's own right, it wouldn't be my first choice for a first tool. When a friend of mine finished his electrician apprenticeship I allowed him to play with a few of my tools to decide on which he liked best. He chose the Spirit.
Just about every one who responds to this will have different ideas and suggestions, but the bottom line is that when you choose a tool from Victorinox, Leatherman, SOG, Gerber, Wenger, CRKT, Bear or a few others, you are buying a good tool. The rest is just details- cost, functions, and who has the best scissors, saw etc.
Best of luck to you, and feel free to ask as many questions as you like- that's what we are here for!
Def
-
Thanks.
I understand what your saying. The range of good quality MT is amazing. I figured that's why i would ask if anyone in the electrical industry would recommend one over another. I'm not even sure how useful wire strippers would be. I imagine a better quality pliers would be more useful.
I think the most useful features for me would be the pliers, file and drivers.
-
Welcome Chillidc
Although I love my Multitools all my work tools are insulated

As you are working with the Electricians see what they have and use everyday ;)
-
I spent some time doing electrical work in my youth (yes they did have electricity then) and I found that these are most useful:
-
Lineman's pliers, probably did 90% of my work with these: Stripping, bending, twisting
-
Thick one inch bladed knife: offers the best control for cutting tasks (especially unsheathing romex)
-
Automatic screwdriver, but these have been replace by compact rechargeables nowadays
-
Needle nose pliers, for fine bending and pulling
And for all the MT's out there, I would have to agree with Grant, and say that the (OMG I can't believe that I'm actually saying this) Vic Spirit is the best all around MT for an electrician. Just for its wire handling tools alone, if for nothing else.
-
-
Well there you have it, a lifelong Leatherman fan just said you'd do best with a Victorinox Spirit. I'm a big Victrorinox fan myself, and would agree you've got to get one - they are an amazing multitool.
However, I would also suggest that you get your mitts on a Leatherman Wave as well. In fact I think for what you're doing you might find the Wave better for you at work. There's better facility for working tied tools (lanyard attachment on the Spirit sucks) when working at height, cleaning of corroded terminals would probably be better with the more delicate diamond file on the Wave rather than the feisty Spirit file. One hand opening tools and a pocket clip could also be very useful to you. Personally I find the drivers on the Spirit better in many roles, but no single multitool will ever be the best at everything. Another benefit with the Wave is that when it's full of plaster dust, loft insulation and all the other tiny little nasties that'll make any multitool creak and scrape, a Wave can be stripped down cleaned out and rebuilt
Bottom line - get your folks to get you the Spirit as a present - there's a good chance you'll not want to get it wrecked on the job site anyway, and it'll see you through all the other aspects of your life very well and the sentimental attachment will be appreciated more and more as time goes by - and save up to get yourself a Letherman Wave for beating up at work

Oh and a word of warning - if you hang around here, by this time next year you'll have dozens of the buggers!!!
Good luck with whatever you choose, and good luck with your apprenticeship

-
We have a word in portuguese that's missing on english: "desenrascar".
See #1 of this http://www.cracked.com/article_17251_the-10-coolest-foreign-words-english-language-needs_p2.html :)MTs and SAKs are, many times, tools to "desenrascar", not primary tools. In that sense, the best MT/SAK is the one you know best with the most versatile range of tools. For example, the swisschamp is still a reference to me: I know all its implements by heart and know how to use them, even for situations they were not meant to.
Well, having said that, go for the spirit :D
-
@50ft-trad said:
Well there you have it, a lifelong Leatherman fan just said you'd do best with a Victorinox Spirit. I'm a big Victrorinox fan myself, and would agree you've got to get one - they are an amazing multitool.Not an entirely true statement. While I do prefer Leatherman's as a plier based MT, I was a Vic user long before the MT was a twinkle in Tim's eye :D
However, I would also suggest that you get your mitts on a Leatherman Wave as well. In fact I think for what you're doing you might find the Wave better for you at work. There's better facility for working tied tools (lanyard attachment on the Spirit sucks) when working at height, cleaning of corroded terminals would probably be better with the more delicate diamond file on the Wave rather than the feisty Spirit file. One hand opening tools and a pocket clip could also be very useful to you. Personally I find the drivers on the Spirit better in many roles, but no single multitool will ever be the best at everything.
While the OHO is a plus, I think the longer blade on a Wave goes against the ergonomics of electrical work (at least with house wiring and the such), The Spirit's chisel has the edge here, in my opinion
Still think you are underrating the lanyard attachment on Vic's... ;)
Another benefit with the Wave is that when it's full of plaster dust, loft insulation and all the other tiny little nasties that'll make any multitool creak and scrape, a Wave can be stripped down cleaned out and rebuilt
True, but either of them can just be tossed in the dishwasher, with the advantage of the Vic not needing an immediate drying.
-
... which just shows Grant was right ...
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Just about every one who responds to this will have different ideas and suggestionsThere's also the Paladin line of tools manufactured by SOG which was built for electricians ... but again, that doesn't mean they'll be the best for you. In fact Gerber are bringing out a very specific tool called Groundbreaker soon (details are here in the Gerber forum) designed specifically for sparkies. There's no right and wrong - just what's right for you. Unfortunately you might not get it exactly right first time, but with a Spirit and a Wave you'll not go far wrong.
I'll still stick by my earlier suggestion though - get a Spirit from your folks. Maybe they'll even engrave it for you - but don't wreck it at work. If you end up arcing something out with it you'll never forgive yourself :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
Only real dilemma now ... is deciding which model of Spirit to get.
...
...
... until someone else comes along in a couple of minutes to say I'm talking out of the wrong orifice and suggest something different altogether :D :D :D
-
I've been a spark most of my life, always had LMs and I'd follow the trend here. I used to wire building management systems, thousands of connections, and found the OHO wave quick and easy for stripping and not too cumbersome, but I'm a recent convert to the spirit using it with the chisel/stripping blade and pliers open at the same time.
Out of the workshop I always use my insulated tools.... just in case.
-
I use a Victorinox Electrician Plus , and keep the Spirit in the briefcase . The short skinning blade suits me well , the saw can be very handy .
Another one to take a good look at when it comes out , the Leatherman Rebar .
Typically , a plier based multi would only be used rarely , ie : if you needed a spare pair of pliers to hold a nut , or needed the serrated blade to cut banding tape . It's more of a personal convinience item , than a primary tool .
Chris
-
Has anyone used the LM Squirt ES4 tool?
The pliers are not in my preferred form factor for wire stripping, but it might be handy to keep around for finer cable work.

-
Thanks for all the replies everyone. I know that a MT will not be a primary tool for me. I am fortunate enough to have an apprenticeship in the commercial sector with a very large company. This means that the majority of tools i will need are supplied to me for free (good quality/insulated).
Here in Australia over the course of the 4 year apprenticeship we are also given $5500 (in total) for Tools. With the guidance of the forum i will hopefully be able to put the money towards good quality tools (not just MTs :-p) that will serve me well over my life as tradesman.
I looked up on Spirit on Amazon for pricing reference. The first review there is great. A very comprehensive write up comparing - "the Spirit up against the Leatherman Charge Ti and the Gerber Legend 800 - what I consider the primary competitors for best multi-tool on the planet at the moment." The spirit came out on top.
I must admit that in my head i was wanting to purchase a Gerber/Leatherman for my first. I guess this just comes down to clever marketing from these companies as i have no other reason for my preference lol. Looks like Swiss Spirit may very well by my first serious MT. Thanks again.
-
I have some electrician friends and I have offered them different electrician's multitools on several occasions to try out and let me know what they liked. None of them bit on them. Maybe they thought they were gadgets, but after having watched them work (I rewired my house a couple of years ago- extensive work) they tended to use only a handful of cheap, easily replaced tools. Flathead screwdrivers were used for almost everything (including occasional use on flathead screws), hammers, a set of pliers and an old cheap folding knife for peeling insulation. It seems that they preferred these tools in case they got left behind, dropped inside a wall or broken, they were easily repaired. Stripping insulation was hell on an edge and didn't require a knife be super sharp so why waste a good knife on it.
All in all, a good multitool is well worth purchasing, but don't expect to need, use or even carry it every day at work. You'll feel very bad leaving an expensive and handy multitool inside the wall of some old lady's house!
Def
-
+1 on Grant's post above. I work in the electrical industry and I wouldn't think of carrying any of my multitools at work. To me, it doesn't make sense because I usually have my toolbelt strapped on with my linemans, sidecutters, 10 in 1 screwdriver, nutdrivers, hammer, utility knife, etc. If my belt isn't strapped on, I usually stuff the couple of tools that I'm using at the time in my pockets. I rely on my tools to do my job properly and need quality heavy duty stand alone tools. Multitools can't begin to compete with my 9" lineman's pliers or large flathead beater screwdriver. I would hate to damage any of my expensive multitools!
I do, however, carry a victorinox tinker knife in my pocket which is my EDC knife at work- it's slim in my pocket, has two sharp blades in addition to a few screwdrivers and tweezers, which are important to me (think metal slivers,etc) Sometimes I use the screwdrivers on the vic to remove a cover or something when I don't have my tools handy. It is also cheap to replace if I loose or break it. I've noticed that none of my coworkers carry multitools either. Some guys carry pocket knives however.
Now I sound like a multitool hater :P I love my multitools, but I save them for play on the weekends and use real tools during the week. ;)
-
Thanks for backing me up- I was starting to wonder whether I was making any sense! After all I am a multitool guy who owns a multitool site, telling a guy whose entire career will revolve around tools not to buy a tool for work. That just didn't seem right to me somehow!
Def
-
@Junkcollector said:
+1 on Grant's post above. I work in the electrical industry and I wouldn't think of carrying any of my multitools at work. To me, it doesn't make sense because I usually have my toolbelt strapped on with my linemans, sidecutters, 10 in 1 screwdriver, nutdrivers, hammer, utility knife, etc. If my belt isn't strapped on, I usually stuff the couple of tools that I'm using at the time in my pockets. I rely on my tools to do my job properly and need quality heavy duty stand alone tools. Multitools can't begin to compete with my 9" lineman's pliers or large flathead beater screwdriver. I would hate to damage any of my expensive multitools!I do, however, carry a victorinox tinker knife in my pocket which is my EDC knife at work- it's slim in my pocket, has two sharp blades in addition to a few screwdrivers and tweezers, which are important to me (think metal slivers,etc) Sometimes I use the screwdrivers on the vic to remove a cover or something when I don't have my tools handy. It is also cheap to replace if I loose or break it. I've noticed that none of my coworkers carry multitools either. Some guys carry pocket knives however.
Now I sound like a multitool hater :P I love my multitools, but I save them for play on the weekends and use real tools during the week. ;)
Actually ... this post reminded me. The multitool I've seen used most by a Sparky at work is a Victorinox Explorer ... using the magnifying glass to help read the tiny writing on electrical components, lamps, fuses etc
-
I'm going to recommend the ES4 and either a surge or ST300. More so the ST300 for its cutters and I like both of these for their useable crimpers. I'm also a huge fan of the Spirit but for work... meh.
Stay multi my friends
-

Sent from Ash forum mobile
-
Hi Luke! Good name for an electrician, by the way... I did residential electric for a few years.
First, I agree with some of the above in that I didn't use an MT as a primary tool (especially not a wire-stripper, in my experience those will get blown up). However, I did find carrying a MT plenty useful, and was saved many trips back to the truck or toolbox when I forgot a screwdriver, needle-nose, etc.
Of course there's lots of good MTs out there, but I think something that's worth thinking through is how you're going to carry it. For me, it didn't make any sense to use a sheath. If I put it on my regular belt, it was in the way of my tool belt. And if I put it on my tool belt, I didn't have it for the occasional time I didn't have the tool belt on me (which, by the way, is when I found it most useful). I also didn't want something bulky dropped in my pocket. So for me, the best option was a tool with a pocket clip.
-Luke
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login