Survival Knives
-
Bob and I discussed this at SHOT after looking at the Les Stroud knives and I kept meaning to get everyone else's thoughts on it. The recent Opinel survival knife thread has reminded me about it, so here goes.
When we looked at the Les Stroud knives at the show we saw that basically the knives weren't anything special (as expected) but they did have lots of gadgets attached to the sheaths like sharpeners, reflectors and places to wrap lots of paracord. In a survival situation, all of these would be handy, but then so would a Howard Johnson's. ::)
Survival, in my mind falls into two categories- lost in the woods and SHTF situations. If you are lost in the woods, I can't help but feel that your cell phone or a SPOT type GPS transmitter is your best friend, and probably a lot more useful than a knife. If you are lost in the woods, you probably want to be found, and you could use your knife to chop up some wood and build a signal fire and perhaps be rescued when a passing aircraft notices you, or you can press the panic button or dial 911 on your cell phone and help comes right to you. There are good reasons to have a knife, but if I had to choose one, I'd choose the phone or GPS emergency transmitter.
In a SHTF (Smurf Hits The Fan) type situation where you are on your own and there's no help in sight a knife could certainly be handy as well, but I think I would be more inclined to try and scrounge whatever I could. While I would appreciate a knife, it would be one of several dozen items I would want to secure, and perhaps not the highest priority item on the list- firearms, ammunition, food and clean water would top my list, although a knife would be a very close second tier need to the above items. Naturally a good knife would be important, and could perhaps aid in getting some of the above items, but they are also a lot easier to find, whether it be a kitchen knife or a decent sharp rock. Despite what Captain Kirk managed to do while being chased by a giant lizard man, it's somewhat difficult to build a gun from nothing.
In short, much like the survival knife craze of the 80's, the knife is a handy tool but is simply not what survival is about, no matter who's name is on it or how much paracord it has wrapped around it, the survival is in the person, not the tool. Because of this, I really don't care for so called survival knives simply because people will buy them and think they are prepared- they are not. The knife is a valuable part of survival, no matter the situation, but it it only a part.
Personally I think it's going to be easy to locate a knife in a SHTF type situation as there are going to be a lot of yuppie corpses clutching some really neat knives lying around.
Def
-
Wise words boss. While I don't expect much from Mr. Grylls I was very disappointed to see the Les Stroud line of "survival" knives. I was really hoping he would maybe design a blade shape or something and let a high quality manufacturer produce a Surviver Man edition fixed blade or something. I'll be watching his show to see if he actually uses his own product. I will go ahead and disagree with you a little bit though. Yes a GPS would be the ideal item for the lost in the woods scenario but things can go wrong with electronics. If I could have only one item it would be a medium sized fixed blade only because there are so many uses. Help build shelter, dig a hole for water or start a fire are pretty hard things to do with a dead GPS or a rifle without ammo. This being said I'd like to know the statistics on civilians lost in the woods for any length of time. If your smart enough to be prepared your probably smart enough to prevent situations in the first place. Yeah a knife would be great if your lost in the woods but if you brought your GPS then what the heck are you doing getting lost in the first place?! I'm hoping people going to remote and isolated areas are not relying on their Bear Grylls survival knife to get them out.
Stay multi my friends
-
You are always free to disagree with me, even if you insist on being wrong! :P
I was approaching the "lost in the woods" scenario as being in a situation like a plane crash, or having gotten lost in a storm or other natural disaster. For whatever reason, the person is in the woods with no support. The GPS transmitters I was referring to are these types:
They are basically a transmitter with no screen or navigational aids, just a satellite transmitter that sends your coordinates to an emergency service. Yes, they can break, but they are built pretty solidly, and more so than many so called survival knives. And, with one of these I'll be in a helicopter on my way back to the hotel while you are digging a hole! :P
As for the Les Stroud knives, well I wasn't expecting much, but they actually seem like decent quality knives. They are going to be better than I expected they would be, but the reality is, if I decide that I am going somewhere where I may need to "survive" I am going to bring a hell of a lot more than my Bear Grylls or Les Stroud survival knife with me.
To me, a survival knife needs to have more EDC features, like a SAK or multitool, since a "survival situation" is not the kind of thing you can always prepare for- basically it revolves around what you have on you. For example, there's rarely time to stop at Wal Mart to stick up on camping gear when the small plane you are in is headed for a very hard landing. You have to make do with what you have with you, and you are more likely to have a Leatherman Wingman with you than any so called survival knives.
Def
-
Yea but...
-

How many of these guys met their end when the saws broke, the compasses were dry, the fishing line broke and the matches got wet thanks to those awesome survival knives?
I had three of those survival knives- who else is sad enough to admit having one?

Def
-
You forgot about the plastic handles breaking off of the blade too...
-
Just to be sure, we are talking about the Helle knife here, right? Or was there some other Les knife released this year?
-
On the subject of survival knives, the only one which really seemed seemed to me to take a neat twist was the Ka-Bar Warthog. I missed getting one, but my dealer showed me one a few years ago. It had a very beefy blade, and the blade was wide enough to use as a small trowel. Now the ones that aren't imported (the originals with the old-style hammer butt) are too expensive to risk using! :(
I've had one of those Camillus USAF "survival" knives a bit. It's got a wonderful personality and cool vibe, but I just know the first time I tried to open a can of beans that sharp thin tip would snap.
Sorry if off topic! Bill
-
I would generally agree with def on the survival knife topic, with the exception of gps over a knife. I think that most "survival" knives are more about marketing than real usefulness. I think that what def said about being a survivor is independent of survival tools is quite accurate. Its more important to develop skills than to hoard gear. Having skills and gear is just a winning combination.
-
On a serious note, I agree with Def. Whether it's a night or two in the woods, or a night on the library steps of a city that has temporarily lost mass transport, I would be much better off with a MT or SAK.
-
A survival knife doesn't have to be used in a survival situation, it also comes in handy when cutting down a few dead branches, peeling the bark and making a few hiking sticks. But then again, none of my knives are actually marketed as survival knife so...
I wish CT would put that knife on sale for $5 again, I'd buy one just to have one. :D
-
Mobile phones rock as long as you have network coverage. (and if you do you are fool not to use it)
One thing i want to build is a hand crank cb radio
i've been really impressed with my camillus 1983 pilot knife of late, whilst the tip isn't there anymore the now sharpened nub works, partically with a rock or small log driving it.
Survival is not about mindset, life and everything you do is about mind set (in which survival as a concept has no distinction)
-
-
Phones are nice, but if I had to get a "come save my butt" signal out, I'd rather have a PLB. And I like GPS. But... I guess I'm old school enough that if I have to choose between a map of my area with a compass OR a GPS, I'm not going to be wearing about spare batteries for it.
I don't like the term "survival knife"- it makes it sound like you stick in the package of holy stuff just in case. Now, when I'm hiking or hunting, yes, I have a fixed blade on me or on my pack, usually my Ka-Bar or a Schrade H-15 (or increasingly, a Buck 143), it's backed up by a SAK and/or a multi. In the "survival kit" that I keep in my truck, mostly stuff that I have in a pouch so if suddenly find myself needing to take a hike before I melt down, I keep a Marble Trout and Bird knife- does that count?
-
A brain is the best survival tool you can have, everything else is icing on the cake.
Mike
-
@turnsouth said:
Yea but...Survival Knife! 1980s TV Commercial

I gotta admit, 420 molecular steel sounds a lot better than steel without molecules...
"They are the best-selling knives of its kind ever sold by us..."
Grant nailed it. In a "smurf" attack situation, I want a really heavy sturdy blade that will put up with a lot of abuse. I can't imagine a situation where my "survival" was in question, that my first priority is taking out a hook and 20ft of 10 pound test out of a chinese plastic handle and going trout fishing. Even as hungry as I always seem to be. I'd be better served dumping out the useless crap in the handle, putting an silicone o-ring on the cap, and filling it to the brim with Jack Daniels.
YMMV. Thanks for the retro laugh.
best-
-steve
-
To me the whole idea of a big knife for chopping wood is like getting a big car with a huge trunk to haul lots of stuff home from the hardware store. It works if you're into big cars but a truck is even better. Even a small truck works better than a big car and an ax works better than any knife. I spend a lot of time in the woods and have never found any knife bigger than a SAK to be necessary except for dressing large game and even then it's always an H1 or other short hunting knife just for the simple fact that it's a fixed blade.
I have a few Fiskars and Estwing hatchets and a large Estwing axe. The Fiskars goes with me for chopping and the big ax stays at camp for firewood duty. I noticed early on that the older experienced guys carried a pocket knife and a hatchet in the woods and the young guys all fawned over the big knives.
As far as what's needed to survive? There was a time when we got by with half a brain, a worn set of teeth and a sharp rock.
-
Also I recall you need a expensive subscription with SPOT for it to work, and your request for assistance is sent to the company, who then try to pass it to your country's emergency service.
For Canuks there is this, which while more expensive doesn't need yearly subscription, has something like ten times the transmission power than SPOT, and is directly monitored by the canadian rescue service. I'm sure other countries have something similar.
-
In the right hands any knife is a survival knife, but it only becomes a survival knife when you actually need it for survival ... even if you just improvised it from a tin can lid. If all went wrong I'd still want a knife over and above a primary urban survival kit (phone and wallet). If I was cold and wet I'd still want to get a fire going to get warm and dry till help came, or cut my clothing so I could dress a wound or improvise a bandage, or harvest a stick to get to a better location close by (nearby shelter), or .....
You can be pretty sure the knife I'd have on me wouldn't have been marketed as a survival knife though. It would be a SAK or a multitool, or maybe even a 4" puuko. If I had a small axe or folding saw, all the better.
I'm hoping to get a Chris Caine Survival Tool before too long. Simple reason is it looks like a damn good tool which I could make good use of ... not to lug around with me waiting for the world to end
-
I also lean toward the Smurfs hitting the Fan mentality. In the coming smurf apocalipse, I can think of plenty of smurf swatting, and splttering tools , I want on my belt.
Ever wandered into a smurf village? Those little varmits, draw blood, and when theres like a million of em crawing up your legs, they manage to get itno everything evan when you think your'e secure and have blocked outside acess to "creatures of the forest.
They like to swarm up on you too. They may be small but they can be vicious little buggers, in a pack .So don't get Lazy. Be on the alert no matter how Sleepy , you may get.
Sure you can stomp em into smurf soup, but a pair of steel toe boots is only gonna stomp, or boot so many smurfs , before your swimmin up smurf creek, and we all know how impossible that stuff is to get out.
Above all be prepared, or else your smurfed.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




