Smith Electric Sharpener
-
I would not use an electric sharpener, they just take off more metal than is necessary to touch up a knife, or even major sharpening for that matter. It's just my humble opinion.
What method are you using now?
Mike
-
Sometimes lansky hone diamond system, sometimes lansky 4 rod turnbox, and other times a spyderco sharpmaker.
Sent from Ash forum mobile
-
Ok, against my better judgement I will say this about electric sharpeners. If you have to get one, get one with ceramic wheels and try to make sure to get the one with the slowest rpm, and an adjustable angle.
Mike
-
I probably won't get one due to not wanting the major steel lose but I'm still open on ideas.

Sent from Ash forum mobile
-
Seems many folks have several different sharpeners. Take you for instance, you have a Lansky and Sharpmaker. Both a good designs. The problem comes in when people bounce between the two of them. It plays havoc with a consistent angle. Then if people try freehand, then things can really get frustrating to get a nice sharp edge.
Sometimes folks let their edges go too long without touching them up and it takes longer to bring them back. I am guilty of this myself, but I don't mind bringing an edge back.
So the questions are, what exactly are you having problems with and what's causing them? Anything mentioned above?
Mike
-
I would avoid it like the Clap , the only electric sharpener I have heard good things about is the top of the line "Chef's Choice " - even that has lots of caveats .
Chris
-
I have never tried an electric sharpener but the local gun store by me highley recommends the chef's choice 120 or 130. The person I have talked to has a benchmade gript. and it was very sharp. I use rod's myself but have thought of trying one of these.
-
@Styerman said:
I would avoid it like the Clap , the only electric sharpener I have heard good things about is the top of the line "Chef's Choice " - even that has lots of caveats .Chris
I hear you. I know a guy around us who uses (tries) to use a Tru-Hone professional system, which has ceramic wheels. It does not do a very good job for a $1,000.00 system. So, if a $1,000.00 system can't do the job I have no hope for the costing ten times less.
Mike
-
I've tried several Smith products (though not the electric sharpener), and they seem to be reasonably well thought-out. I've ruined my Buck General over the years with my lousy sharpening techniques. I use the Smith pocket sharpener and it works. It doesn't get the blade shaving sharp, but the General's blade is so blasted hard and long that even my Lansky rod sharpening system is difficult to use.
Just saying. Good Luck.
-
@Mike said:
Seems many folks have several different sharpeners. Take you for instance, you have a Lansky and Sharpmaker. Both a good designs. The problem comes in when people bounce between the two of them. It plays havoc with a consistent angle. Then if people try freehand, then things can really get frustrating to get a nice sharp edge.Sometimes folks let their edges go too long without touching them up and it takes longer to bring them back. I am guilty of this myself, but I don't mind bringing an edge back.
So the questions are, what exactly are you having problems with and what's causing them? Anything mentioned above?
Mike
I'm having trouble getting that pop hair sharpness. I can shave hair from my arm if I push but I want that popping hair sharp. I normally use lansky hones for reprofiling and the turnbox for touch ups. Sharpmaker is my least favorite of the 3. I personally feel the 4 rod turnbox does WAY better then the sharpmaker.
Sent from Ash forum mobile
-
Seems many folks have several different sharpeners. Take you for instance, you have a Lansky and Sharpmaker. Both a good designs. The problem comes in when people bounce between the two of them. It plays havoc with a consistent angle. Then if people try freehand, then things can really get frustrating to get a nice sharp edge.
Sometimes folks let their edges go too long without touching them up and it takes longer to bring them back. I am guilty of this myself, but I don't mind bringing an edge back.
So the questions are, what exactly are you having problems with and what's causing them? Anything mentioned above?
Mike
I'm having trouble getting that pop hair sharpness. I can shave hair from my arm if I push but I want that popping hair sharp. I normally use lansky hones for reprofiling and the turnbox for touch ups. Sharpmaker is my least favorite of the 3. I personally feel the 4 rod turnbox does WAY better then the sharpmaker.
Sent from Ash forum mobile
The round rods from the turnbox are the same as using the corners on the Sharpmaker. It concentrates the cutting surface on the edge. Some say this makes the edge slightly more brittle by work hardening it, but I have not had any problems with that.
For that hair popping edge, you need to go finer grit. You might be able to get finer grit rods for the turnbox from somewhere like Congresstools.com. Spyderco also has finer rods for the Sharpmaker, though Congress Tools has I believe less expensive alternatives which some people has used to varying degrees of success. Apparently, sometimes they fit into the Sharpmaker guides properly and sometimes they don't fit too well at all.
Also, you may need to thin down the edge a bit in addition to using finer grit rods.
Mike
-
I also have trouble with burrs and getting a decent edge forsay. At times when slicing paper it catches like I have a burr sometimes I don't and sometimes I do. I tried stropping and all I did was dull my edge horribly. My main problem is with Case tru sharp. I can't get an edge on it for nothing. Swiss steel is no problem for me.
Sent from Ash forum mobile
-
@Ashley said:
I also have trouble with burrs and getting a decent edge forsay. At times when slicing paper it catches like I have a burr sometimes I don't and sometimes I do. I tried stropping and all I did was dull my edge horribly. My main problem is with Case tru sharp. I can't get an edge on it for nothing. Swiss steel is no problem for me.Sent from Ash forum mobile
What happens with burrs is they can seem to be gone, but are still there. Consequently, they flop from side to side and eventually break off leaving you with an edge that is not quite sharp. What you can try is, increase the angle a little bit and without applying much pressure, sharpen the edge alternating sides until the burr eventually wears away. After each stroke feel for the burr, once you no longer feel it .... well obviously it's gone. This is with your fine rod/stone using the same technique as sharpening it originally. Just a slightly steeper angle and a very gentle touch between the blade and the stone. This basically cuts the burr off.
Strops can be a little trickier at removing burrs. Why? Well, strops are very good at aligning an edge and polishing an edge. But because they do not really remove hardly any material, you can just be flopping the burr from side to side. Even if you load a strop up with coarser chromium oxide and use the rough side of the leather it can be tricky.
I have heard mixed reviews on Case Tru-Sharp. There are many who have expressed opinions that if you want a collectors knife and not use it very much, get a Case in Tru-Sharp. But if you want a user, get a Case in Chrome Vanadium (carbon steel).
Mike
-
I think the real answer is to buy a couple of medium quality paring knives , and a reasonable , + a sharpie marker and just learn to sharpen .
Chris
-
Try using the extra fine rods for the sharpmaker and stropping afterwards,that makes mine scary sharp!

-
There's this thing called work sharp that's basically a miniature belt sander with guide built in, people who has them seems to love them.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login