A Warning
-
Okay this is a very long shot, but contact Doug Ritter and Kniferights, see what their opinion is and if they can help you out.
-
sigh I have nothing of substance to offer, but you do have my sympathy. Totalitarian mindsets at work are always an ugly sight. I am often reminded of a passage in Nineteen-eighty-four where it is noted that fewer things than one might imagine were illegal, but the laws were ambiguious and obviously the police had wide authority, so people stopped doing everything they perceived might be illegal all by themselves... Focault noted that nobody is as oppressed as the citizen who oppresses himself while insisting he has perfect freedom.
-
"There once was a man from Hong Kong.
Who didn't do anything wrong.
He just laid on his back,
with his head in a sack.
And said not a word
all day long."

-
-
I just wanna say smurf THE NYC POLICE!!!

-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Okay this is a very long shot, but contact Doug Ritter and Kniferights, see what their opinion is and if they can help you out.
I'll second that. Doug is a good guy and whether he can do anything or not I'm sure he'll want to hear about this.
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
I'll also say this a good idea, just to see what he says.
However, I'm going to play Devil's Advocate here just for a moment:
You entered another legal jurisdiction without fully understanding the legal ramifications of carrying your knife with you. Yes, the consequences are way, way out of line with the offense but the fact that NYC is cracking down on knife carry isn't exactly news.
-
Laws like NYC has scare me.
I want to live in a free country.
Nobody is as oppressed as the citizen who oppresses himself while insisting he has perfect freedom.
Freedom. It wasn't free don't let them take what or fathers fought so hard to get us.
-
@JAfromMn said:
Laws like NYC has scare me.I want to live in a free country.
Nobody is as oppressed as the citizen who oppresses himself while insisting he has perfect freedom.
Freedom. It wasn't free don't let them take what or fathers fought so hard to get us.
You're exactly right. I pitty all those poor soldiers who died rolling around in their graves so some hot shot donut stuffing PIG trying to make a name for himself can arrest a perfectly innocent citizen. This just makes me sick...
-
I got to add one more thought.
The NYC police are not to blame. It's there job to enforce the law no matter how stupid it is. The ones who right the Laws are the ones to blame.
Who says your vote don't count. We had to vote the idiot who wrote this law in.
-
I don't care who signed what into some lawbook. It don't make it right and the cops are just as wrong for enforcing an immoral law.
-
Well I did some research about the penal code they charged me with NY 265.01 which mentions switchblades and gravity knifes which the kershaw is not. Than I looked up the federal defintion of a switchblade which states it has the opening device in the handle which the Leek does not have, I emailed the attorney this info and will call him tomorrow, I'm hoping this will help get the case dismissed. :_c:
NYC DA Vance decided a while ago any knife that you can shake open counts as gravity knife, even claim they will do sting operation and charge any dealer that ships "qualified" knife to NYC, so quite a few dealers don't even ship knives to NY state now.
You cant shake the Kershaw Leek open as I recall >:(
-
Thanks guys I sent an email to kniferights.org, hopefully they have some helpful info
-
@Syph007 said:
This stop and frisk thing is just confusing. Whats the goalThey've already made it nearly impossible to legally own a firearm in NYC. And we all know that while a knife isn't as bad as a gun, no one really needs to carry a knife with them as they go about their daily business. At best such people are maladjusted and paranoid, but a great many of them are violent criminals even if they don't know it yet. The people must be protected, and even if the tiny number of people who actually do have a demonstrable need are inconvenienced, well, it's only a tiny number of people who could also be using scissors. A tiny number of people who should get clean, white collar jobs that reflect the future of our great nation and not it's past.
It's just another stain of a politician playing games with the assistance of one of the most corrupt law enforcement agencies in the industrialized world and a hoplophobic media that has the moral backbone and mental acumen of a sponge. Intimidation and power, that's all it is. At the very best, it's security bukkakke*, just like the BS at the airports.
*and scarily enough, Firefox's spellchecker fixed my spelling on this....
-
I don't know if anyone is interested, but having worked at a police dept for some time I can tell you why he was arrested. And why there were six cops involved.
First, you don't need to be breaking a law. The cops merely need probable cause. This is what allows them to search or even break into you house if they necessary.
Please don't misunderstand I am not saying what they did was right. I think it was reprehensible.
They just arrest people and let the court sort it out. The majority of cases they send to court are thrown out. So, basically they try to arrest everyone that they can. This is why so many of the jails are overcrowded. "DragNet"
This is why there were so many cops there. They were doing a little CYA. That way no single officer can get in trouble if they did the wrong thing.
-
@radiotecha1234 said:
I don't know if anyone is interested, but having worked at a police dept for some time I can tell you why he was arrested. And why there were six cops involved.First, you don't need to be breaking a law. The cops merely need probable cause. This is what allows them to search or even break into you house if they necessary.
Please don't misunderstand I am not saying what they did was right. I think it was reprehensible.
They just arrest people and let the court sort it out. The majority of cases they send to court are thrown out. So, basically they try to arrest everyone that they can. This is why so many of the jails are overcrowded. "DragNet"
This is why there were so many cops there. They were doing a little CYA. That way no single officer can get in trouble if they did the wrong thing.
Well, I wasted some of my life getting a BA in criminal Justice at the university of Miami, mind you this was over 20 years ago, and I did not pursue this field after graduation, I went into my fathers HVAC business in NYC, which was eventually disolved, I moved to NJ and got various other HVAC jobs until I tore my rotator cuff in my shoulder and the miniscus in my knee, after I was all recovered my company no longer needed me. now I'm unemployed, my unemployment just ran out and I have this BS hanging over me.
But I mentioned the criminal justice degree because I was taught that the police have discretion to make an arrest or not, unfortunately I ran into a guy who was fresh from the academy and with no brain of his own to make such a decision. I was also taught about search and seizures which require probable cause, and of course there's the 4th and 2nd ammendments which were just stomped on so they can make their quotas
I wonder how many out of towners who get locked up never get a chance to claim the money taken from them, like I have to go back and do; and it winds up filling the city's coiffers as well as the fines and and fees everyone has to pony up, to me this is just a big scam for them to pry even more money from our pockets, while the bankers and brokers rob the country blind and get away with it, its all so very wrong to me.
-
@Blackbeard said:
I just wanted to get this story out there for anybody who plans on visiting NYC in the future or if you live/work there now. I live in New Jersey and took a bus into Manhatten to see a concert/show with my brother(Albert Lee, a great guitarist).I came out of the port authority bus terminal and went up 8th avenue, crossed 42nd st while wearing earphones and was tapped on the shoulder by a cop who asked me what was in my jeans pocket, since he saw a clip under my shirt fold. So I showed him , it was a Kershaw Leek, which I like to carry since its so slim. Well this guy and his partner were rookies and had to call numerous other cops to get instructions, after standing around for 20 minutes about 5 more show up, and I'm repeatedly grilled,tried telling them that the knife is not a switchblade but they were oblivious, eventually frisked(I also had 1 xanax pill and no presciption bottle, whose gonna carry this around in their jeans anyway) and believe it or not arrested for pretty much just crossing the street.
So I spent the night and better part of the next day in a small, stinky, boiling hot holding cell with a filthy toilet 3 feet from me and a hard wooden bench which you could get no sleep on. Bored out of my mind, I was repeatedly lied to by the cops about when I would be taken to the courthouse to see a judge so I could go home from this nightmare. they would tell me soon, a few hours, multiple times to shut me and the other guys up I guess, all in all was there for over 15 hours till they transferred me to another facility downtown where I had to wait in another cell with 20+ guys most of then there for petty things like walking through a subway car, having an open container etc.
Was at this next place for almost 7 hours finally saw a judge, and was released but I have to go back to finish it up in october, the attorney said he should be able to get it reduced to a non criminal offense since I have no convictions, which I really need cause I'm still trying to find a new job.
Basically NYC has this controversial stop and frisk policy which I was unaware of where they can stop and question and search ANYBODY without any reason, which has many civil rights groups protesting(mostly for racial profiling, and for quotas they must keep up but still you've got to be kidding me) Mayor Bloomberg is the head Nazi(yes a jewish guy) in charge of these gestapo like policies, and other inane bullsmurf you may have read about recently.
Well I left a lot of details out cause I don't want to bore everybody, but I don't want any of you guys to have to go through this, they even shot and killed a guy which you can see on you tube who was smoking weed and didn't want to be frisked, pulled a knife and that was that.
Bottom line either stay away from that garbage hole of a city like I plan to do, AFTER I have to go back in next week to get the money they took out of my wallet transferred it to a downtown facility, and they issue you a check after that which you get in 3 WEEKS??!! so my money is basically jailed for 3 weeks as well and I have to waste my time and more $$ going to get it. Or if you go please dont take a knife or if you do dont let the pocket clip show, I would be cautious with carrying a multi as well, since these guys can do whatever they want.
I do not want banned for saying this but... People get the government that they deserve. For years, politicians and bureaucrats have tried to legislate safety. Politicians mostly for self serving reasons have removed freedom from the people of NYC and this is where the whole county is headed. I honestly hope that the smurfhole known as NYC is one day swallowed up by the earth hopefully on a day when the good people are on vacation and safely away.
-
Sorry to disappoint you man but we don't ban people for having opinions here. We do strongly discourage political discussions though and this thread has been borderline a few times, so let's try and stay on the correct side.

Def
-
As a law enforcement officer myself, I am saddened to hear of your predicament. Assuming all the facts you provided are accurate, as no doubt they are, you were dragged over the coals with no concrete legal justification. Granting police the discretion to act as they see fit in a wide variety of situations is essential, but that discretion needs to be based on a totality of facts and circumstances, as well as, in this case, some basic understanding of the nature of the items and objects against which they are enforcing. While I don't entirely disagree with stop and frisk policies, given their success in removing many handguns from the streets, I recognize that any policy that requires a level of discretion, restraint and consistancy far above the average officer's capabilities will erode the spirit and legitimacy of the law faster and more completely than open resistance.
Best of luck with your case, Blackbeard (and I hope that, for the sake of your adjudication, that is not your ACTUAL surname) -
No I'm just your average 40 something year old white guy who has a beard, which is sadly getting so grey I might have to change my nickname to whitebeard soon. I appreciate your statement and wish you had stopped me. I also have full respect for the police and the arresting officer commented multiple times to me and my mother (who wouldnt stop calling the precinct for status updates)that I was acting like a gentleman and would do his best to get me out of there in a few hours(which turned out to be a lie and ended up just under 24 hours)
I've always been respectful of police, whether in a traffic stop or a few conversations with the guys who patrol around my apt complex about my great flashlights and their junky maglites. My issue is with the policies they are forced to undertake as I mentioned in first post about Mr. Mayor, but again I only posted this to help out my fellow members to avoid this happening to them.
-
And I'm so glad you did. If any good comes out of your situation I hope that it is to save others from a similar fate. And I wish it had been me that stopped you. I could have tried to persuade you to switch to a CRKT Titanium M16.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login