Wingman > Juice
-
IMO
I have no idea why the wingman has so much hate around the net.
For these 4 reasons:
1)Wingman is 25 vs Juice line that is 40 to 70$
2) Stronger and spring loaded pliers
3)Comes with the pocketclip
4) Wingman is 7oz only .3 oz away from the xe6. So the weight is not a huge differenceI think the wingman is a far superior pocket tool. Neither are working tools and I am not trying to make that case.
Thoughts? Agree or think I am crazy
-
I like the Wingman and never cared for the Juice line.
I think the Wingman is cheaper to make than the Juice so it costs substantially less.
-
$25 for a Wingman is good...£40 isnt!
The Juices are overpriced,but feels a quality product(and KF4s just simply ROCK).my experiance of the Wingman/Sidekicj was that it felt cheap, had all the wrong tools locking,and all the drivers just felt the wrong size.Bring back the Kick!
-
The locking blade on the wingman makes it a less attractive carry for me owing to our laws over here
-
i like the wingman

-
The price is its best feature. Remember, like the gremlins from the awesome 80s movie... dont get the wingman wet...
-
I'm a fan of the Wingman. I can't think of any other multitool in that size class that's less than $25 that I would use, other than the odd Kick you may still find available from time to time. They've been selling Wingman/Style CS combo packs for $30 recently (@ Home Depot) and Wingman/Micra combo packs for $25 (@ True Value). That's fantastic value. I'm not too ashamed to say that I've purchased 3 of the combos in the last few weeks for Christmas gifts. For $85, that's six quality multitools with solid warranties.
I would say that the Juice S2 becomes more interesting in the weight comparison. At 4.4 oz. it is far more pocket friendly than the Wingman.
-
I agree too much hate

If the Wingman was a little more compact
:D -
@coastalchris said:
4) Wingman is 7oz only .3 oz away from the xe6. So the weight is not a huge differenceThe xe6 just so happens to be the heaviest of the Juice series, and by a wide margin (the CS4 and KF4 being the next nearest at almost a full ounce less in weight). The C2 and S2 are each 4.3 and 4.4oz, which are significantly lighter than the Wingman.
I know a lot of folks probably don't mind a few extra ounces but some, myself included, do. The weight and pocket carry comfort factors combined mean the Wingman won't ever find its way into my pocket for daily use.
Having said that, I think it's a terrific value and packs some excellent tools (including the beefed-up pliers as you mentioned).
-
I've never owned a Juice and just recently got the Wingman in the combo pack from Home Depot. The Wingman just feels cheaply made to me. I own numerous LM products and never had that feel until the Wingman. The scissors on the one I bought do not lock open unless forced. The flat head screw drivers are to odd for me to use. I guess the larger flat head could be used as a light pry bar if you cut a groove in it. I do like the package opener though. It has opened many clamshell type packages with no problems. I guess the Wingman may be a MT that would be good for someone who is new to the MT world or someone who has light MT work to do around the house. I read the thread about Grant's rust issues with it and I'm actually not surprised of these results in the climate and conditions he works in. This tool just doesn't cut it for me and my EDC IMHO. Like I said, light work around the house, yes. If I were still working and needed this tool in the muck and mud that Soldiers deal with, no. My Wingman will probably end up with my wife and she can use it.

-
Had a Wingman and I have a Juice S2. I'd still have the Wingman, except it's not very lefty-friendly. The Scissors were just as good on the Wingman as the ones on the Juice. One-hand open blade is handy on the Wingman. Moreso for right-handed users, though. Locking blade is nice to some folks. I had no problem with the drivers on the Wingman. I loved the springed pliers on the Wingman. I liked the pocket clip.
The size/weight of the Juice makes it VERY appealing to me. I don't pocket carry commonly, but do occasionally slip a tool in a pocket if I'm just puttering around in the yard. The Juice is nice for that. Very comfortable.
For the cost, and what you get... assuming a few ounces aren't a big thing, and you're right handed... and you're allowed to have a locking blade...I think the Wingman has it all over the Juice. But I'm left handed, and I DO care about weight/size.
I also have to say that I don't think the Juice would fare much better than the Wingman in highly corrosive environments.
I've carried non-locking blades for decades without problem. I just don't do anything with a blade that has ever required locking. So, locking is nice, but for me, doesn't matter either way.
-
@stealth007s said:
I've never owned a Juice and just recently got the Wingman in the combo pack from Home Depot. The Wingman just feels cheaply made to me. I own numerous LM products and never had that feel until the Wingman. The scissors on the one I bought do not lock open unless forced. The flat head screw drivers are to odd for me to use. I guess the larger flat head could be used as a light pry bar if you cut a groove in it. I do like the package opener though. It has opened many clamshell type packages with no problems. I guess the Wingman may be a MT that would be good for someone who is new to the MT world or someone who has light MT work to do around the house. I read the thread about Grant's rust issues with it and I'm actually not surprised of these results in the climate and conditions he works in. This tool just doesn't cut it for me and my EDC IMHO. Like I said, light work around the house, yes. If I were still working and needed this tool in the muck and mud that Soldiers deal with, no. My Wingman will probably end up with my wife and she can use it.
The scissors won't lock because you need to open them first to give the spring bar room to move
-
Thanks Chris. I would have never known that on my own.


Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login