Maximal Minimalism
-
I know this has been hashed out here in the past, but I haven't seen anything about it in awhile.
So, where do you stand on the minimalist spectrum with your SAKs? Do you go for maximum # of tools for every possible situation i.e., some thing like the Champ? Or, do you go for a basic tool set, but keep it small i.e., a Bantam or Cadet?
Personally, I try to keep it on the minimalist side. My EDC is either a Pioneer or Cadet.
The waters get muddied a bit when you consider the alox classic on my keys and the Spirit in each glove box and the OHT in the 72 hr bags. So, I like to think I'm a minimalist, but I like to have something extra close to hand if needed.
What say you?

-
Hmmm ...

For me a SAK is complimentary to whatever else I am carrying. I like to have all bases covered (within what I expect to encounter - I don't always carry a saw for example), but not necessarily all in one tool.
For me a Swisschamp would be too big, but if I have a Spirit on me for example, that reduces the number of tools I need on my knife and makes the knife more comfortable in use. It's extremely rare I would just carry a SAK on it's own
-
I keep it slim but functional. I edc a Cadet with scissors and an alox Rambler on my keychain. I feel nicely prepped. :D
-
I have a SwissChamp,which I like,a Champion which I love,and often eDC an Astronaut...but more and more I'm thinking that the SuperTinker/EVO16 is the perfect SAK(at least if I'm carrying a bigger MT).
The SuperT/EVO16,nothing spare,nothing missing!
-
old faithfull the Swisschamp ! feel naked without it :sak:
although i often have a my wave or trusty 'wingman' (it's good honest) i like a bigger set of pliers/cutters than on the 'champ' and a OHO blade is really nice to have (unless you're being patted down by a british bobby
)
oh and a squirt on my keys (just in case)
do i have a problem ? -
No more than the rest of us,mate!

-
So yeh,yeh TD you have a SERIOUS problem

-
I like both extremes. So I EDCed for 25 years a Swisschamp in my bag (I always carried a bag as a student and then a physician and a smaller one when not at work, currently a Victorinox sling bag) and an Alox Cadet in my pocket.
Now that I moved to the XLT the Swisschamp seems lightweight and minimalistic. I EDCed a Spartan in my pocket and an Executive when in formal suit for two weeks, but today I put the Cadet in my pocket once again.
I also have some other blades around. Opinel No8 outdoor is my favorite, lightweight, one hand opening, piercing clip-point, half serrated, locking and not aggressive looking. I EDC it as well, it is very convenient.
Cadet does most work and the Swisschamp comes out for the scissors or mini pliers or some other tool. I also use the lens a lot (I rarely used the old type grey lens). When eating or in need of a bigger blade the Opinel comes out.
After reading these forums I felt the need of a big Ranger or/ and a big Leatherman. But I still think about it because I'll not be able to resist EDCing them also. This is not a minimalist attitude and, when I die, I don't worry about what people will think about my underwear. No. I worry about them saying "what on earth did he carry around all these knives for?" -
@50ft-trad said:
Hmmm ...
For me a SAK is complimentary to whatever else I am carrying. I like to have all bases covered (within what I expect to encounter - I don't always carry a saw for example), but not necessarily all in one tool.
For me a Swisschamp would be too big, but if I have a Spirit on me for example, that reduces the number of tools I need on my knife and makes the knife more comfortable in use. It's extremely rare I would just carry a SAK on it's own
I always only carry a SAK as my main blade, meaning I don't carry a separate OHO knife, so I hadn't thought about that in terms of maximal minimalism.
This made me think of something else... These days, if I felt the need to have more tools on me than a pioneer or cadet, I would be more likely to grab a Spirit than a Swiss Champ or other knife based model. Although, I think this has more to do with my aversion to plastic in knives than needing a pliers-based tool.
-
These days I try to be a little minimalist by carrying a Pioneer/Climber along with a Rambler. Not much redundancy there. It's all my other gear that may qualify me as less than a minimalist...
-
I see that no one here just carries the Alox Soldier or the Poineer.

-
Here is an older thread.
/topic/7484 -
@Swiss Man said:
I see that no one here just carries the Alox Soldier or the Poineer.
i did EDC a wenger soldier for quite a time , before i moved up to a farmer (the lost farmer)
i worked in a workshop full of 'real tools' so i just needed the blade mostly for quick opening of boxes, and the screwdriver was a paint can opener. -
I have been carrying the evo 14 and the gerber crucial.
-
I'm a minimalist by nature. That goes for the general life style as well. Small compact car, .22 caliber forearms, and SAK's for pocket knife. My choice of SAK's has always been the one and two layer SAK's for general every day use. Bantam, recruit, spartan, Wenger SI, and Vic soldier. They go in the pocket being rotated as my mood is that day. There's also a clasic on my keyring. I love the little classic to augment the larger SAK's. I don't bother with other folding knives much at all. If my SAK can't handle it, then it's time for one of my fixed blades that go on my belt when I go hiking or camping. Swedish or Finish puuko with 4 inch blade.
-
@cbl51 said:
I'm a minimalist by nature. That goes for the general life style as well. Small compact car, .22 caliber forearms, and SAK's for pocket knife. My choice of SAK's has always been the one and two layer SAK's for general every day use. Bantam, recruit, spartan, Wenger SI, and Vic soldier. They go in the pocket being rotated as my mood is that day. There's also a clasic on my keyring. I love the little classic to augment the larger SAK's.** I don't bother with other folding knives much at all. If my SAK can't handle it, then it's time for one of my fixed blades that go on my belt when I go hiking or camping.** Swedish or Finish puuko with 4 inch blade.These are largely my thoughts as well. I do like the OHT, though, so that comes along camping. As for fixed blades, I'm really liking the Mora's I recently picked up.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

