'Totally Worth It' tools
-
I was just thinking about chevym14's thread about retiring his 14-year EDCed Wave, and started to consider how many of us have had a tool so long, so used, and so loved that instead of turning it in for refurb/replacement, we sent it out to pasture.
I'm not a highly sentimental creature. When the scissors on my most-loved SOG Crosscut started to loosen at the pivot, I didn't hesitate to do something about it. But I REALLY felt like I'd gotten my money's worth out of the tool. So, instead of sending it in, I bought a new one. However... I passed the old one on to a friend (right handed friend, where the slight play in the pivot didn't mess with the scissor cutting action as much).
How many here have retired a tool, and bought a new one, feeling like you got your money's worth?
-
I've never retired a tool, and to be honest I don't stick with any particular ones day in day out so none of them are going to see 14 years continual duty. If I had got one that served me that well and I could get another the same, then yes I'd probably do a like for like replacement.
As for putting tools out to pasture or frame mounting them ... well let's just say I've never felt the need to do that with shoes, cars, toasters, coats, lightbulbs, razors, keys for now irrelevant locks ... and I see no need whatsoever for me to do that with knives or tools
Keep for spares, maybe - but if a tool is past it's use by date and can't be fixed, it pretty much goes in the bin -
@50ft-trad said:
I've never retired a tool, and to be honest I don't stick with any particular ones day in day out so none of them are going to see 14 years continual duty. If I had got one that served me that well and I could get another the same, then yes I'd probably do a like for like replacement.I'm the same way. I haven't been collecting/using long enough to be in that situation anyway, but I have too many that I like to carry to allow me to carry only one of them exclusively for years. If I was smart, I would have done so to save a bunch of money, but I got sucked into the addiction >:D
-
I retired my PST in 2008, after having received it in 1992. I did, however send it back to Leatherman a few times. Once for a knife blade that broke off at the tang, once for a broken off screwdriver tip (No not the little one) and once for worn out pliers.
So, I guess it wasn't my original PST, but sorta like "My Grandfather's Hammer". ;)
-
Trigger: And that's what I've done. Maintained it for 20 years. This old brooms had 17 new heads and 14 new handles in its time.
Sid: How the hell can it be the same bloody broom then?
Trigger: Theres the picture. What more proof do you need? -
I didn't retire it, but my snap-on 3/8" flex head ratchet was totally worth the money. It's been rebuilt more times than I care to count, but damn does it take abuse.
Eta: my electric impact gun was 'totally worth it' too. And of course, my few leatherman tools.
-
Leatherman Supertool- it had a lot of companions for 18+ years, mostly SAKS, and it's a little loose and the wire cutters have notch from some tempered wire in an anti-tamper seal and the file might not cut as well as it did and it's got some scratches. But I carried it every day, it wasn't in a rotation of EDC, it was on my belt or in my bag or in my vest every day wasn't flying (and pre-9/11 it got to fly), had business in the courthouse, or I needed to wear a tux (but the PST fits in a cumberbund very nicely). The number of people who could touch it was very low. Got me out of trouble more than a few times, in to trouble once or twice, and fixed a lot of problems.
It was retired with honor with my Rebar being purchased. But it is where I can see it, and if need be grab it in an instant, every day.
And they spent a month together in my bag, both of them. New kid should have had plenty of time to hear the stories.
-
I was given my first SAK when I was 12 (that is a few decades ago). I don't know how many I went through over the years, but after abusing and breaking or damaging them, I switched to multi's. I bought Gerber's, because they were cheaper and had the cool "flick to open" thing going on. And they broke real easy. Broken blades, snapped or twisted drivers, and I even broke the pliers on the last pair - I have a 180lb grip strength which was apparently too much for a Gerber MT. I never submitted any of the SAK's or Gerber's for warranty as I assumed that they broke from abuse rather than flaws.
After my third or 4th Gerber, I got tired of the breakage (and the numerous redundant flat blade drivers), so I bought a Leatherman Surge. After almost a decade, I still have this Surge, and it was subjected to 3 years of use and abuse in commercial home renovations. While it shows the wear and tear of hard use, it never let me down.
Now that I'm wiser, and know how not to abuse the limits of tools, I have switched back to SAK's for EDC. I doubt I'll ever buy another Gerber multi, but my Surge is in my "Go bag" (it goes everywhere with me) and is used for the jobs that are too much for the SAK in my pocket.
Dave
Sent from my iPad2
-
Some of you will have heard the story before, but I retired my late 1960's vintage Wenger Tool-Chest after 40 years of faithful service and then gave it a full strip and rebuild refurbishment.. well more of a makeover to be honest. I made all new brass liners because the original ones were so badly corroded and re-polished the metal scales I made for it 20 years ago when the originals fell off and got lost.
I got that old Wenger for my 10th birthday and it was 2nd hand even then, but I thought it was the best thing in the world. Over the years we've had a lot of adventures together and I decided it deserved a dignified retirement.
I did manage to pick up a later vintage model with the same tool set, 6 layers is a bit thick for EDC pocket duty now, but the new one will be riding in my car's glove-box ready for anything.however, tools that I've worn out in ten years of so... in the bin and replaced.
-
I've a odd history with my old wave,i got it in 98 for my 28th birthday from my dad,now it's a long story but my dad left my mum back in 1980 for another woman and moved overseas with her,I didn't see him for 16 years,too cut this short he is a twonk,so although I carried my wave for many years I decided too sell it around 3 years ago,but then discovered mto and luckily the guy sold it back too me,oddly if I remember right it's a friend of Dunc's :D well I got it back but decided too send it too lm as floppy and had a broken driver,well they couldn't repair it as no parts as retired,they offered a new wave but I declined,but after looking at the new model on here I decided too take up there offer,I had no sentimental value for it due too my dad getting it for me,well I sold the new wave at the beginning of last year so I could try new Mt's ,well I was lucky as my mum gave me some money in November so I bought a charge ti on this forum for a great price from millhouse
and now I have a great mt with sentimental value as my mum payed for it, 
-
My mum bought my Swiss Champ for my 18th... totally get the sentimental thing :D
It was an outrageous price for the time though, and I thought it was utter magic.
-
@nuphoria said:
My mum bought my Swiss Champ for my 18th... totally get the sentimental thing :DIt was an outrageous price for the time though, and I thought it was utter magic.
I think gifts do transcend the equation. I'm very reluctant to part with a gift whether it was a good item or not, and irrespective of how much service it has given.
Gifts to me kind of have an expiry system though, where I can't get rid of a gift for ages - even if it's utter crap ... but eventually that can wear off and I put it out of my misery :P Sometimes though it will stop with me for decades (literally). Obviously there are great gifts (like my old lambsfoot folder) which are too good to ever part with, unless they actually break in which case they have run their course and I can let them go with a clear conscience
-
I retired my Vic Tinker (2nd one) after I cut into a live wire and melted a big chunk out of the main blade. It is still usable, and that missing chunk would probably make a decent wire stripper. However, it is too embarassing to explain that story every time someone sees me with it. ;)
I keep it as a reminder to myself to be careful.
My first Tinker was the small model, from the 80s, with the can key in the phillips and the phillips curved to match the handle shape. Lost that one somehow. (as kids do)
I always felt 91mm was too big for this knife model, so when I saw Victorinox was offering the (84mm) Small Tinker again, I snapped one up. Just a perfect little pocket carry.
Now that I'm here, I tend to buy them faster than I can wear them out... :-[
-
Totally agree on the small tinker, I love those little things. I just ordered another. They are darn cheap for the 'value' IMO.
-
I've retired my '94 Supertool and replaced it with a ST300 (the '94 ST still gets a lot of attention, but not for real use anymore, only for "thinking about the old days" purposes ...).

-
Today I carry a Rambler, but for years I carried a Classic and can relate to that feeling of 'got my money's worth'. These tools are so useful they really do kinda pay for themselves.
-
@sawman said:
Today I carry a Rambler, but for years I carried a Classic and can relate to that feeling of 'got my money's worth'. These tools are so useful they really do kinda pay for themselves.I think I'm gonna have to second this. Ounce for ounce, dollar for dollar... they can hardly be beat. I have a Rambler on my keys right now.
-
I agree with several other posters that the original Leatherman Supertool was totally worth it. I belt carried and used it for many years. It is still fully functional and I now keep it in my home office instead of carrying it.
The only reason I bought newer tools was to find a multitool which had faster, easier to deploy blade access and unlocking.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


