Edge types
-
Can some one post a picture of forward serrations? I am not familiar with these.
Never mind I Google it and found some pics. -
I much prefer PE. Easier to sharpen and I much prefer the tactile sensation of cutting with a PE to a SE. CE seems like the worst of both worlds.
-
For general use and everyday carry - plain edge. Easier to maintain and more versatile.
Serrations have their place and when working with ropes or when I might need particularly aggressive cutting I do like to have the option available -
I prefer plain edge and convex grind.
-
Plain edge here as well. It just works better for the sort of cutting tasks I do every day. Easier to maintain an edge at the store or in the field as well.

-
Only masochists try to whittle with a serrated edge. A plain edge is able to do anything a serrated edge can do, but not the other way around. (Though in some special cases a serrated edge can be more convenient, I guess. Usually it just boils down to keeping a keen edge, though, and that's so much easier with a PE.)
-
I voted PE too. Really, it depends on the size of the blade and what its intended use is. On pocketable folding blades with a combo edge, you really don't end up with enough of either type of edge for it to be useful on anything but the smallest tasks. On a larger fixed blade, I'd say at least 6" long, you'd have enough to have 4" of plain edge and 2" of serrated, which would somewhat useable. However, even then, whittling/carving with the blade would be a major pain because of the serrations.
My solution to this problem was to buy a Byrd Wings, and it's a nifty little knife, but I hardly ever use it.
-
Well, what can I say.. Seems like we have a clear winner in the PE.
I think my Gerber Gator will be serration free when and if I get around to buying one (already have a knife on the way). :)
Thanks for your thoughts guys!
-
SE to rip through most anything, plus they need less maintenance.
CE shouldn't exist
PE for whittling, precise cuts
I voted SE -
I use to prefer a CE blade, but now I prefer a PE for most daily cutting tasks. I do prefer a SE for cutting cardboard though, just find it cuts faster.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login