Saw vs. Scissors
-
We've all wrestled with the Eternal Question -- Corkscrew vs. T-mount Phillips -- and come to our own conclusions. (I know where I stand... Corkscrew: the can opener works fine on Phillips screws, and the corkscrew has a ton of uses.)
But what about the other question? Saw vs. Scissors?
Camper vs. Climber
Hiker vs. Super Tinker
Rucksack vs. ForesterHere's my take: The whole point of carrying a SAK is to have one tool you can have on you no matter what you're wearing (everything from jeans to suit pants to a bathing suit with a pocket)... one tool which will do at least 95% of what you could want, and will save your bacon when it counts.
I carried a Climber for 30 years, and I used the scissors more than any other tool. I loved my Climber. Still love it.
But, when I started experimenting with other SAK models, I figured out some things (for me, at least):
Three layers is my max for true EDC carry. I've tried the Huntsman and Explorer... they're just too big. They're fine when I'm wearing jeans or heavy khakis, but 10% of the time I'm wearing something lighter... That 10% of the time is when I'm out of my element... and it's when I'm out of my element that I most value having my SAK on me.
I love the scissors, but I don't have to have them: I can pretty much always make do with a sharp knife blade, and if I can't, then it's probably something that can wait until I get home.
The saw works great, and there are lots of times when it's handy, and I can envision scenarios where it would be a life saver.
The saw layer is thinner than the scissors layer. A Camper is noticeaby thinner than a Climber. For me, the Camper makes the cut for true EDC... the Climber is kinda pushing it.
I like the hook... if you go with scissors, you get one more tool (or two more if you carry the Compact: hook + file).
I'm all about the one-SAK solution, the one knife to rule them all idea... but in point of fact, I cheat: I keep a Rambler (with little bitty scissors) on my keychain. (Maybe for you it's a Classic.)
I get the "urban vs. rural" thing... about how the scissors are more handy around town and the saw in the woods... but after using both, I think it's a false choice. They're both useful in both environments.
Factoring all that in... I have to go with the saw. I'd say that even if I didn't have the Rambler as a backup/complement.
So... saw vs. scissors?
-
Rock, Paper, Scissors, Saw -
Poll, make a poll!

To me, saws belong on multitools with pliers and heavy duty stuff. Saw on a knife?? About like having a fish scale, why? You cannot flip the handle to an L shape for more grip, or extend it out. Guess if you never had a multitool, why not put a fishing pole on a knife too?
Scissors makes sense. Coupons, bandages, paper, trimming loose threads, cord/thread. Makes sense to have them on multitools too, but BIGGER & BEEFIER.

-
Why choose? Get a Ranger, and get the Wood Saw, the Scissors, AND as an added bonus the Metal File (plus all those back tools too).
-
I like to have all tools, even for EDC (especially for EDC I should say. One can never be sure about what he will encounter and you might need something just once a year and only an EDC item will keep you ready.
But for pants carry one needs something lighter. A Ranger might be too fat and heavy. I don’t know which tool is better. For the time being I am inclined to wood saw for the countryside and scissors (and metal saw) for the urban environments. For me it is Harvester for my country house and excursions and perhaps Mountaineer for the city and work setting. -
Scissors, always. Second most used tool for me whereas a saw has limited "summer" application for me!
-
Always scissors for me without a doubt. I simply don't use the saw at all.
-
Scissors for sure. I havent needed a saw ever. Most of the small branches those short saws are good for, you can cut with a sharp blade in short order.
Now that being said, I wouldnt let an extra layer in a SAK stop me from having all the tools I want. I EDC a cybertool 34 in my pocket and never notice it there. Dangled on a small lanyard attached to a belt loop. I think I could EDC a thicker one if I needed more tools, but it has all I need on a dailly basis.
-
-
Yeah, I'd have to say scissors for me also. I've never "had" to use a saw, but have had a ton of use out of scissors.
-
Much as I do like, and use, the saw it's scissors that I "have" to have on me.
-
I'm with the majority here-scissors all the way
As others have mentioned, I prefer the saw on my full size multitool. I don't see the need for a saw on anything other than a full size or heavy duty MT as I view SAKs as something to have on you to cover the basics (and any "gimmicks" you may enjoy, like the mag glass in my case ;)).I also agree with the fact that the 4+ layer SAKs are too bulky for pocket carry, which is unfortunate as I have the Explorer and love it (mag glass), but it's harder to pocket carry. There is no smaller SAK available (Yeoman) with a mag glass unless I pay a considerable amount of money, have one built or learn to do so myself (none of which is likely to happen anytime soon >:(). The Compact is nearly perfect for an all arounder EDC, but has no phillips of any kind. I've found that you can use the combo opener tool's edge to some degree, but it's a tricky job.
Sorry for rambling on there :-[
-
@Monrogue said:
I'm with the majority here-scissors all the way
As others have mentioned, I prefer the saw on my full size multitool. I don't see the need for a saw on anything other than a full size or heavy duty MT as I view SAKs as something to have on you to cover the basics (and any "gimmicks" you may enjoy, like the mag glass in my case ;)).I also agree with the fact that the 4+ layer SAKs are too bulky for pocket carry, which is unfortunate as I have the Explorer and love it (mag glass), but it's harder to pocket carry. There is no smaller SAK available (Yeoman) with a mag glass unless I pay a considerable amount of money, have one built or learn to do so myself (none of which is likely to happen anytime soon >:(). The Compact is nearly perfect for an all arounder EDC, but has no phillips of any kind. I've found that you can use the combo opener tool's edge to some degree, but it's a tricky job.
Sorry for rambling on there :-[
If you don't mind loosing the corkscrew you could go with a DofE?
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Victorinox-Swiss-Army-Pocket-Tool/dp/B00243T2KU
-
Not just to be contrary, but I prefer the saw. The saw increases possible uses more than the scissors do. Both scissors and a saw can usually be replaced by a sharp knife, using a knife instead of a saw is far more cumbersome than a knife instead of scissors. Cutting some types of plastic pipe with a knife, for instance, is no fun at all. My wife has a SwissChamp in her office drawers, and she uses the saw for cutting zip ties. You can't reach with the multipurpose pliers on a typical multitool, so she says the saw is the best option when you don't have a proper wire cutter handy.
I carry a Harvester today, and the excellent pruning blade reduces the need for scissors even more. The main role of the third layer is making the knife nicer in the hand anyway, having something useful there is just a bonus. ;)
-
Scissors!
-
This really needs a poll.. :D
-
Poll added. :D
-
I still say have both if you find both useful. Work on other ways to carry. A huntsman really isnt that much thicker than a climber.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
