Another oldie
-
Got this recently. I think (?) a Worker's Knife (Pictured in the Vic 1903 catalog, page 7,
lower left). Dates I think between 1886-1909 ?? 100mm with fiber scales. "Swiss Made"
also on base of screw driver. (I've enhanced the tang marking as it is close to
unreadable on knife). Am I on the right track? Any and all help/comments welcome.Another question, assuming I'm correct in the above, to what degree should I clean
the knife? I'm tending to minimal cleaning; just enough to remove active rust. Not
trying to restore to mirror finish, etc.Rich S

-
Hi Rich,
A 1942 Elsener catalog shows the same knife as the model 200. That's basically the 1908 pattern Soldier's Knife, which was official issue up until 1951, and may have been offered commercially as late as the 1970s. Still a nice find.

-
Would that tang stamp have been used in the '50's or 70's? According to the Vic
tang stamp chart, it was discontinued in the early 1900's. Also, I thought the
soldier's knife always had a spear point blade.Rich
-
From 1908 - 1950 it had a clip point , are there any stamps on the fibre handles a + or a WK mark ?
-
No stampings on the handles. If the soldier had a clip point all those years, why do all the sites showing
the original soldier only show the spear point and not mention a clip point. Not arguing, just trying to learn.Rich
-
-
Here's a shot of a 1908 Soldier's knife with a clip blade. Actual year unknown, but with a WK stamp on the handle.
-
A 1954 pattern Soldier's knife (actually 1955) marked Elsener / Schwyz.
-
A shot from a 1970 catalog showing the model 200.
Victorinox was seldom imported into the US before WWII, which makes me suspect the English 'Swiss Made' is later than that.
Don't worry about it. The more you mess around with SAKs the more you'll find nothing is 100% certain. Part of the fun, and what gives me grey hairs.
-
-
OK, thanks muchly. I guess you can't believe anything you read even in Victorinox's
books (the Companion and the 100th Anniv books). The latest I could find in any
of them was the 1908 Model 2 soldier (with scale stamp). And, according to
Victorinox books the Elsener/Schwyz stamp was discontinued in 1909.It took me about 20 years to begin to be a bit fluent in Japanese swords (Nihonto).
It may take longer than that for SAKs :-) Of course at my age, I don't have that much time
left. I appreciate the help and am now totally confused, frustrated and bewildered
by what's actually in print, even by Victorinox itself. No wonder I don't have any
hair left :-) I guess the best I can do with this one is to call it an older model SAK.
Thanks again.Rich
-
This is a decent read
http://www.amazon.com/Swiss-Army-Knife-Owners-Manual/dp/0615503519/ref=pd_sim_sbs_b_3
the 1908 is a great knife I carry a modded one most days :)
Either a 1943 Vic
Or this wenger :)
-
Thanks for the link; I have that book also. At least I know the knife wasn't made yesterday (probably :-)
Rich
-
Here's a Victorinox Swiss Officer's Dagger, made in 1986 and also marked Elsener / Schwyz. It's also marked 'Victoria', which supposedly means carbon steel. However it may be stainless. Need confirmation on that.
-
Coloswiss and all -
Thanks for all your help. It's really confusing and frustrating when you can't rely on the info put out even by
the manufacturers themselves. While Sakwiki and other sites are a wealth of info, they also are apparently quite incomplete especially when it comes to tang stamps, dates, and even models. Seems this board is about the only good source of info. I do appreciate it and the folks who are willing to share their knowledge.Rich
-
Here is a line-up of the Soldier models :
Model 1890; 1908; 1951 Grilon, 1951 fiber; 3 1961's; today's Model 2008
-
Hi Rich,
Victorinox and Wenger are in the business of making knives. Historical information was, until recently, of minor consideration, with the result that much data was lost, and what remains is often contradictory. Fortunately there are a lot of people here with wide-ranging interests in SAKs, and they are glad to share their information.
-
@ColoSwiss said:
Hi Rich,Victorinox and Wenger are in the business of making knives. Historical information was, until recently, of minor consideration, with the result that much data was lost, and what remains is often contradictory. Fortunately there are a lot of people here with wide-ranging interests in SAKs, and they are glad to share their information.
I'm very glad for those folks. Without them, the SAK enthusiasts would be pretty
much in the dark IMHO. I guess I'm just use to dealing more with antique Japanese
swords. Their records are quite accurate (except for the WW II period when many
were destroyed. But even those have been pretty much reassembled thanks to
collectors.) and date back a thousand years. I've run into the same problem with
Finnish/Nordic knives (which I also collect). Again, it's mainly the collectors
who have provided much of the info on them. My sites, both non-commercial,
for those interested are:The Japanese Sword Guide
http://www.japaneseswordindex.com/nihonto.htmNordic Knives
http://home.earthlink.net/~rsblade/nordic.htmThanks again to everyone.
Rich
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login