Sharpening SAKs for Dummies?
-
Given a person with no workshop/tools/skills, what's the easiest, simplest, most fool-proof way to sharpen the blades on a Vic or Wenger? Do handheld sharpener gizmos like these actually work? I need to help out a relative who isn't a handyman but I'm not sure what to tell them.
-
Just read the reviews. This guy seems to know what he is talking about:
http://www.amazon.com/review/RNIYWGK0ZBZHR/ref=cm_cr_pr_viewpnt#RNIYWGK0ZBZHR
-
@xt60043f said:
Just read the reviews. This guy seems to know what he is talking about:If he really knew what he was talking about, he would have said something more. It depends very much on the qualitity of steel, if this sharpener is a good choice or not. Very hard but brittle steel is a very bad choice for the Vic sharpener. Soft and durable steel is better here. And for someone who doesn't know how to sharp something it's still the best idea to use such a sharpener over a sharpening steel.
However, I wouldn't use it.But judging sharpening quality of the Vic sharpener on a microscope is a little bit show off. (Look here, I have a microscope). I have a microscope too, but even for razor blades I found it more effective to use a simple magnifier.
The Spyderco triangular sharpening system (which I own) is ok, but not the most effective one. I mostly use the ceramic sticks without the system. They are good for small blades or isolated errors (like a dull blade tip).
-
While sharpening is a huge topic with lots of nuances; But you said Sharpening SAKs for Dummies ... "...easiest, simplest, most fool-proof way ...".
So I have to recommend the Spyderco Sharpmaker. You just have to remember the best way to keep a knife sharp is never let it get really dull. If you do this the sharpmaker will keep your blade sharp very easily, it's basically fool proof. It takes a vew seconds to set up, great if you have a place where you can leave it set up. It's main strengths are maintaining a sharp edge and that it's dead simple. It can also keep your kitchen knives sharp. although it only offers 2 angles it is actually quite flexible, because it offers the two most useful angles, and they are dead on accurate. it's a little big to be portable, but it does package up in a nice case for travel. Comes with training video. After you understand it a bit you can probably get a small sharpening card to keep in your wallet, will understand how to use that better, and will have a portable option for touch-ups.
-
A nice detail about the Sharpmaker and SAKs: As the factory grind is 30° inclusive on a SAK, it's not necessary to reprofile the edge much. Just set the Sharpmaker to 30° and sharpen away. :)
That's the one thing I don't like about the Sharpmaker, even though I got diamond sticks: Every new knife has to be reprofiled to fit either 30° or 40°.
-
I haven't used the Sharpmaker before, but I have and use my Lansky and love it! Super simple, and as long as you remember where you clamp it on the blade, and which degree setting you use, you'll get consistent results every time.
-
Portability isn't an issue I don't think. As long as it's small enough to store in an average closet shelf and easy enough to set up on the kitchen table in a few minutes it should be fine. The main thing is that it has to be very easy and straightforward to use without a lot of possibility to screw up. She doesn't really have any hand skills and is NOT going to want to mess around with a whetstone or whatever.
Also: a powered sharpening machine is an option too, if such a thing exists. A gizmo you plug onto the end of a Dremel would probably work.
-
The Sharpmaker is extremely easy to use, but requires patience the first time using it. Powered sharpening gizmos have a tendency to ruin blades, but there is at least one which members here like. (I don't remember the name, and it lacks an acute enough angle that I would feel comfortable recommending it for general use, which for me includes kitchen knives and SAKs.)
Carbide sharpeners do work, they just remove a lot of steel each time, so the knives will be short lived. I'd say go with something like the Sharpmaker or the Lansky. They give better results, are just as easy to use and the knives will last very much longer. I think the Sharpmaker is the better option for someone who might become interested in freehand sharpening, and the Lansky is better for people who just want to do a regular routine and get a sharp knife. I have a Sharpmaker myself, but bought a Lansky system for some friends who wanted something really straightforward.
I once spent six hours reprofiling a single blade on my Sharpmaker... :P
-
How does the Sharpmaker work exactly, and which Lansky are you talking about (I'm seeing a bunch of different ones on Amazon)?
-
I use the Sharpmaker. It's pretty quick and easy to use.
The only thing I don't like about it is cleaning the stones. :D
-
I don't have one of the systems, as I do all my sharpening by hand, as I learned how from someone who was a trained professional cutler when I was much younger.
That said, the Spyderco or Lansky system is the best way to go for simple and consistent results. You don't have to think about it any more than following the instructions, and you'll get very good results.
-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
That said, the Spyderco or Lansky system is the best way to go for simple and consistent results. You don't have to think about it any more than following the instructions, and you'll get very good results.
@Quartz said:
How does the Sharpmaker work exactly, and which Lansky are you talking about (I'm seeing a bunch of different ones on Amazon)?I use this one

-
Another vote for sharpmaker here. It's very easy to use and versatile. I use the rods to sharpen SAK scissors too.
-
@Quartz said:
How does the Sharpmaker work exactly, and which Lansky are you talking about (I'm seeing a bunch of different ones on Amazon)?An earlier post answered the Lansky question.
The Sharpmaker has no moving parts, the idea is that it is easy to "cut" straight down. That way the need for any guide to keep a consistent angle is eliminated. It really is as simple as a couple of hones sticking up at an angle from holes in a board. A neat idea, I think.
-
I use the same Lansky set that Sparky posted, and I love it. Pretty much foolproof.

-
@Quartz said:
Given a person with no workshop/tools/skills, what's the easiest, simplest, most fool-proof way to sharpen the blades on a Vic or Wenger? Do handheld sharpener gizmos like these actually work? I need to help out a relative who isn't a handyman but I'm not sure what to tell them.Okay, you don't have to buy a thing. You already have one of the best SAK sharpening tools in your kitchen. Go and find a large coffee mug with a nice unglazed ring on the bottom of it. If the ring is a little rough, smooth it out with a little bit of green scotch brite.
Then you strop the blade on the unglazed ring. To find the right angle. hold the knife blade on the mug like your gonna saw right down through it. Then Tilt the blade over one half way to horizontal. Now it's at 45 degrees. Tilt it again so it;s half that distance. You're there. Now just strop the edge on the rough unglazed ring on the mug. Back and forth, alternating sides. In a few minutes it will be very sharp. Finish by stropping on the back of an old belt. Don't worry about exact angle, micro bevels and all that other stuff people get bogged down with. With a little practice and a good coffee mug and an old belt, you will be able to get your SAK shaving sharp with very little gear. The less you think about it, the better you'll do.
Google Youtube; "Instinctive knife sharpening". Pay attention to the guy in the gray flat cap.
-
@Steinar said:
The Sharpmaker has no moving parts, the idea is that it is easy to "cut" straight down. That way the need for any guide to keep a consistent angle is eliminated. It really is as simple as a couple of hones sticking up at an angle from holes in a board. A neat idea, I think.That..... doesn't really answer my question though. Assuming it works like a sharpening rod, I guess you hold the knife vertically and slide it down? I tried to look up a video on youtube but I couldn't find any good ones. This might work I guess, you'd be surprised how many people can't hold something straight though.
-
Here is a link to the spyderco sharpmaker training video.
-
I am very interested in this thread, as I am new to knife sharpening. I have the Sharpmaker, and have had mixed results in my limited experiences so far. I have a Cadet that I was able to get sharp enough to shave hair, but then I struggled to sharpen a Soldier. I sometimes check the sharpness as I go by trying to cut a piece of paper. Sometimes it seems like I go backwards when I try to use the flat edges of the triangles. When I use the flat edges I have a hard time keeping the blade flush with the stone throughout the entire motion. This especially happens near the end of the motion as I get near the curve of the blade.
I am sure that I just need more practice and the key seems to be keeping your wrists locked and using a steady motion.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

