Kirks slip joint field test
-
This thread is a semi long term test of gentleman's folders. Its a direct result of this thread
http://forum.multitool.org/edged-tools/small-uk-legal-folder/
I was surprised at how little love the small Spydies recieved,ecpxvepting the cheap as chips Grasshopper.One result of the thread was that I realised I much prefer the more classically styled slipjoints over the more modern/tactical interpretations. The next result was that I ordered a Case Mini Trapper off Amazon

http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B000RZ7HYU/ref=oh_details_o05_s00_i00?ie=UTF8&psc=1Although the Case was a good price,some £20ish under the usual UK prices,I must confess to having wondered if the Case could justify the price. I've subsequently ordered a Rough Rider Peanut,a Rough Rider Gunstock Rifleman,and a Buck Deuce. What I'll do is carry each knife for a week,deputising for my SAK,and Alox Boxer. For fun,I'll add my Wenger Patriot,that played a supporting role in my Fit test,for a week as well.
Terms of reference
Each knife has two blades,generally,one long,one short. The short will be the dirty blade,doin fall the shop floor related cutting. The clean blade will take all the food related duties. I'll include kitchen duties too,just to keep things interesting .
Each knife will be carried for one week. Ratings will be given on Cost,Fit and Finish,Blades,Family and Friends reaction,and a Love rating.
As with the Fit test,shop floor photos ARE NOT possible. Other action photos will be supplied as and when. Unlike the Fit test,I'm not trying daily updates,but rather supplying comments and remarks as and when appropriate.
So far only the Rough Riders have showed up. Well done Heinnies,ordered 30/12/13, delivered 31/12/13! The Case was ordered 12/12/13,albeit from the States,and the Deuce,on the same day as the Rough Riders from OutdoorUK

The test will start tomorrow with the Rough rider Peanut

-
Looking forward to the result, this is the best kind of thread. -
Thanks gents. I have to admit I'm looking forward to this test. I've already fallen for the RR Peanut big time!
-
-
I'm looking forward to this too mate! :)
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
-
Looking forward to it. Will you use a benchmark? Will you do repeated runs of the same type of work, how will you judge the performance, will you measure the thickness behind the edge or the edge angle, will oyu make a relative comparison of ease of sharpening with specific values or eyeballing?
damn I've been spending too much time on one other forum... -
Ive had a few case knives and rr's and the fit n finnish was just as good on the rr,im looking forwards to your thoughts john

-
@styx said:
Looking forward to it. Will you use a benchmark? Will you do repeated runs of the same type of work, how will you judge the performance, will you measure the thickness behind the edge or the edge angle, will oyu make a relative comparison of ease of sharpening with specific values or eyeballing?
damn I've been spending too much time on one other forum...Er yes,yes you have...remember,even though this is a John thread rather than a Kirky thread,I'm still Kirk :fuggly:
To try give rational answers....
The basic benchmarks are 91 and 93mm SAKs. My usual work cutting knife is my TattooSteve99 custom Alox
http://forum.multitool.org/swiss-forum/the-boxer/msg642973/#msg642973It pretty much eats up any cardboard box,or lacking strap it meets.
If anything needs sharpening,I'll use my Lansky,and I'll detail the angles as and when,otherwise I carry one of these
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Victorinox-4-3323-Pocket-Knife-Sharpener/dp/B000AR7AKG/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1388951836&sr=8-1&keywords=victorinox+sharpenerAs to relative values in ease of sharpening or use,it's an eyeballing type thing

-
@Zed said:
Ive had a few case knives and rr's and the fit n finnish was just as good on the rr,im looking forwards to your thoughts john
Cheers Paul,JD said much the same. A lot of what this test is about is whether a high value slippie is any better than a cheaply China job.
Thanks to everybody else for the interest

-
Thread is bookmarked, and I am eagerly awaiting further posts

-
That is gonna be interesting. And might also show how well that pocket sharpener works
-
Week one: Rough Rider Peanut
Sooooo....things started a bit earlier than planed. On New Years Eve, I'd been using the Peanut for boxing duties at work,so sorry,I have been fibbing a bit.
So how did it you? Initially not that well. RR knives come reasonably sharp out of the box,but the small blade of the Peanut wasn't cutting it. Well,wasn't cutting cardboard over well. However a few swipes through the Vic sharper rectified that. Whilst the Peanut didn't slice the cardboard as well as the Boxer,that's more down to the smaller size of the Peanut,and the lack of hook in the blade.
Tonight,the Peanut ventured into the kitchen for food prep duties. Got to say I'm really impressed. The Peanut chopped its way through a small onion,two Baby sweet peppers,half a pack of sugar snap peas,chorizo and three chestnut mushrooms with great aploom. In fairness,if it had been regular sized onions and peppers,it would have struggled,only having a two inch blade.
So far,I am so impressed with this £8 knife!
-
Making this post just so I don't miss the updates. :D I'm a fan of the Rough Rider's I've had, and my Case, so I hope these work for you as well.

-
Thanks John, now I have the urge to carry a.... Wait...
This actually might be a bit my fault.... ::) :) I think that RR's are great knives for the money. As users I am very happy with them.
My slipjoints, though an everyday part of my carry, tend not to be my main working blade. I use them all the time if something needs to be opened or cut while on the sales floor or around customers though. The Peanut is a great little pattern, though lately I've been carrying a Case penknife more than the 'nut. Slightly longer main blade in a slimmer package. And like I've said, the Case medium Trapper is one of my absolute favorite traditionals to carry.
Looking forward to seeing how you get along with this experiment. -
@jerseydevil said:
...lately I've been carrying a Case penknife more than the 'nut. Slightly longer main blade in a slimmer package.My first knife ever was a Case pen knife. I still have it, and though I don't carry it much any more, it is still a great little knife. I also like how it feels a bit more balanced and symmetrical than the peanut.
Not to totally derail the thread; I'm looking forward to reading Kirky's results as well.
-
Not a very exciting day at Blamington Hall,in terms of sharp and shinies. Still no sign of the Buck or the Case
. If the Buck doesn't show up tomorrow,I think it'll be irate email time 
Anyway,for want of anything more interesting to say,let's have a closer look at the Rough Rider Peanut.
As said before,it was ordered from Heinnies,for £7.95 ex postage....you just couldn't complain at that price! If you'd never owned a Rough Rider before,you'd be wondering how good the quality is. The blades are 440 stainless,and are nicely polished. Unusually,I needed to run it through my Vic sharpener at work to get the blades up to fully useable sharpness,but given that they only needed three sweeps,they weren't that far off the mark. Snap is good. It lacks the satisfying clunk of a Victorinox,but is positive both opening and closing. It inspires confidence

The scales are listed as being jiggled bone,whether they're real or synthetic I don't know,but they feel good to the touch! As to the fit and finish? Well see for yourselves...

I love the little name badge. It's beautifully detailed,and just adds oddles of character to the knife. I know I've already said this,but the little Peanut has won my heart! Its performance in the kitchen last night impressed me no end! There's at least one more of these I'd like...I'll just have to see if there's a way to get it out of the States

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login







