Juice file comparison
-
I got hold of a Juice XE6 just after Christmas for a good price (£59=$98). It wasn't at the top of my list, but the price was too good to pass up. I'm glad I didn't pay full price because overall I'm a little disappointed. After examining the new tool I can safely say that it is not up to the same standard as my discontinued KF4, which was obviously manufactured quite a bit earlier.
I can't open the flat drivers without using another tool (eg. Brewzer) to prise them open, and also the file is inferior to the previous design. It seems to me as though Leatherman have taken a step backwards in evolution in order to save some money on manufacturing costs. In fairness, I will say that the diamond file still seems to work perfectly well, and this is the part of the file that I use the most by far.
I tried to take some photos to illustrate the difference, but it wasn't too easy to capture. The KF4 is the one with the yellow scales; the XE6 has the purple scales.




In this next one I have tried to show the difference between the teeth of the saw. The KF4 is at the top and the XE6 underneath:

The teeth on the XE6 look more like molars than canines. I'm going to test them head to head later on. I have some brass rod that needs sawing up.
Has anyone else found that the older Juices are better made?
-
I have the KF4 (dated 2001), and used to have the XE6, but never compared the files. My KF4's wood/metal file side looks like yours, as does the actual metal saw edge. I don't remember what my XE6's looked like as I didn't end up carrying it much, and sold it off. One thing I did notice about the KF4 though, is that the wood/metal file side was quite shiny and metallic looking, and I don't remember that impression from the XE6.
I do believe though, that LM quality was a bit better in the past. I've only been into MTs for a couple years now, so my introduction to LM was with their newer quality stuff, which seemed great to me at the time. However, once I became interested in some retired models, and actually obtained a couple, I noticed a difference in the quality in favor of the older MTs. Good comparison btw

-
@Monrogue said:
I have the KF4 (dated 2001), and used to have the XE6, but never compared the files. My KF4's wood/metal file side looks like yours, as does the actual metal saw edge. I don't remember what my XE6's looked like as I didn't end up carrying it much, and sold it off. One thing I did notice about the KF4 though, is that the wood/metal file side was quite shiny and metallic looking, and I don't remember that impression from the XE6.I do believe though, that LM quality was a bit better in the past. I've only been into MTs for a couple years now, so my introduction to LM was with their newer quality stuff, which seemed great to me at the time. However, once I became interested in some retired models, and actually obtained a couple, I noticed a difference in the quality in favor of the older MTs. Good comparison btw

That's exactly right. You see the same change in appearance between the old and new files on Victorinox SAKs. The difference is that Vic improved their file, while Leatherman replaced it with an inferior version.I've just tested the saws head to head by using them to cut through some 2.2mm brass rod. Nothing too taxing. I also used a junior hacksaw with an Eclipse blade as a control and the old style Vic metal file/saw on my Astronaut as another comparison.
Here are the results (subjective, and not completely scientific):
1st: The hacksaw obviously made very quick work of cutting through the rod.
2nd: KF4 was at least twice as efficient as the next two.
3rd: Old Vic file (Astronaut).
4th: XE6 was hard work, but it got there in the end.The Juice line is not cheap, so we should not be seeing these inferior tools on them.

-
I'm not certain the file issue on yours is endemic of the whole line. It might be a single example. The teeth just don't look correctly formed on your metal saw.
You might consider sending it in. It might just be a manufacturing error on that single tool.
Are there other folks with newer XE6s that are also seeing this?
I'm not saying this IS the case, but it might be.
-
Just took a look at mine... Doh never noticed that until now.
-
I also like the wavy appearance of the KF4's metal saw on the side edge of it. I thought that was rather neat
I wish I'd noticed the XE6's file and compared them while I had the chance.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login