TSA Confiscations
-
I don't know if this topic has been aired before here.
But I'm curious as to what members make of it. I don't mean the act of confiscation, its law so it must be handed over.
But to then sell these on eBay....it seems so wrong.
Who gets the money, the airport or the staff? Either way I think there is something seriously disturbing when one is allowed to make money by using the weight of the law in the process. Wouldn't it be much fairer to all if there were options to have it mailed back home? Admittedly there would be a hefty price on this, otherwise people would just carry until the gate!!What started this off was my usual eBay.com browsing. I see TSA bundles all the time, but a few days ago a really nice original LM Wave popped up with its original brown leather sheath.it didn't look mistreated, in fact the total opposite it looked like it had been worn and loved for years - suddenly seized and put up on eBay!! Such dignity!!
What's other peoples views on this?
EDIT
I just remembered an incident here in the UK. My partner had a very small pocket knife / can opener that came in a little leather pouch. It was actually mine, I got it when I bought a new car just before we met. (Typically she used my car and I got hers, plus of course I got to keep the monthly repayment plan for mine too!!)
Anyway we were late,, bad motorway accident, plane was ready to leave, staff waiting at the doors to rush us through......down to the gate, passport control.. Then BANG!! Sorry you can't board with this!! It was the knife on her house keys. "Bin It" I said my patner wanted it so the staff wrote down our address on an envelope we paid for the stamp (actually it was a £5 note!! No change) when we returned home it was on the doormat!! -
Some places just destroy them. That seems much more of a waste.
-
</post/895031>
-
The whole TSA checking is ridiculous in my opinion... so many people working on it, time lost, items lost... but I never heard them actually catching a terrorist still planes are dropping like flies this year. Also if I had a terrorist in my plane he would probably be able to smuggle a weapon in anyway so I'd rather have SkeleTool or something to defend myself than stay and watch myself get hijacked and killed like a slaughtered lamb...
Regarding the resell, I'd wish this was available here. They just toss everything confiscated in the trash bin... I saw a huge crate of shiny Vics and Leathermans thrown away under my very eyes (and that's in a country with 250 Euros average wage)... I could almost cry. If these tools would have had a second life being resold or cherished would have been more dignified.
On a personal note.. I have about 30 knives coming from TSA seizes and some are absolute jewels bought for close to nothing (blue S16 Swiss Border Patrol, Mini Climber, Modeler etc. ) but these were bought unofficially... probably nicked by some employee or other and saved from the trashbin...
-
@zoidberg said:
Price of parking just tripled out there, smurfing thieves.Yeah I got stung $50 for two days' parking a couple of weekends ago. I didn't have time to do my ususal - park on Memorial Ave and walk. Although cars are being broken into in that area - I park further down outside the houses.
Ooops another thread derail, sorry!
-
Parking here in St. Louis is in a variety of lots, with shuttle buses to them. The farther away you park, the less you pay. I think it ends up being around $40 for a week when we park in 'D' lot, which i think it as far away as it gets.
As for the confiscation... I think the entire process is absurd. However, if it's going to happen, and there's nothing I can do to change it, I am absolutely not above buying lots of them from ebay. At least I feel that as an MT enthusiast, I will try to get those tools into the hands of people who'd appreciate them. I guess I'd feel worse about it if I were profiteering from it somehow.
-
I agree with most said here, also, I remember (several?) threads about TSA-confiscated knives being sold for funds for the airport chapel or something like that? That seems like a fairly honourable goal, I'd say.
-
It's complete larceny IMO, passengers are being fleeced of their belongings.
It's no fault of the buyers of this merchandise as buyers didn't create the market.
-
I'd rather they sold them officially than throw them in the rubbish or let employees "take" them. At least the tools & knives etc are getting recycled, it is all above board and the revenue is going somewhere. Plus it gives me much more chance to buy good stuff, and it also creates a bigger market for the manufacturers as people buy new replacements, thus stimulating several countries' economies :)
It's not as if most regular travellers don't know they aren't allowed to take them into airports, in fact a cynic could regard it as a "stupidity tax" (or should that be a "forgetful tax" ? ) ;)

-
Several years ago, I lost a LM Juice XE6. It disappeared. Forward a couple of years, and I get a panicked call from my sister :ahhh, at the airport in Melbourne, asking if I'd lost a Leatherman. Somehow it had ended up at the bottom of an outside pocket in her backpack, and was picked up at security. Nevermind it had been through 3 or four security screenings prior to this...
She was able to check her bag and kept the tool for reimbursement of her emotional ordeal
-
Their used to be the option to mail it to yourself or your destination, but most of those services are long gone.
I would say they should sell them off like they do. Take a small percentage for time and effort of paying someone to sell them. Then donate the rest to charities.
I remember reading a story about airports in the USA and change left behind in the security check bins. Last year alone was over $500,000. I believe they donate it all.
-
In the state of Vermont, they are sold through the state surplus store, right next to other police seized items that are no longer needed as evidence and aren't firearms. Every few months, there is an email sent out, and the knife junkies gather there at 7am with their hats or buckets and bundles of cash. My former roommate picked up a bow at one of those, I just buy knives by the pint. Some if it is kinda sad, like a brand new knife with initials (if a name, I'd try to find the person), but by and large it's just people being stupid. I picked up a nice butcher knife there once, still have it.
You can also buy surplussed out office equipment and furniture, old power tools, taxidermist albino beavers, and sometimes even a fire truck. For real. :P It's Mont-peculiar holding a lawn sale
-
Its what happens when you privatize absolutely everything in a country, its gets full of shark style practices - ths TSA is in business to make money, and the sales of seizures from poor hurried or overwhelmed passengers go to them.
The decent thing to do would be to have a padded post bag for sale at the terminal to have the item posted back. But instead, they opt to capitalize on the hurry someone is in and confiscate and resell.
I know the answer is "well if you dont want it taken, dont be absent minded". But I hate that pervasive attitude. Its creeping into everything. People should be given a little leeway for error here and there.
It must make the nutter terrorists so happy to see what they caused to happen to air travel. People getting looked at naked and molested just to get on a flight. When does it end?
-
I would certainly vote for them to loosen the restrictions on knives, thus severely curtailing the confiscations. But barring that, it's not like the confiscations wouldn't happen if no one bought the confiscated items, so I don't see any issue with buying the confiscated items when a good deal can be had.
-
@nate j said:
I would certainly vote for them to loosen the restrictions on knives, thus severely curtailing the confiscations. But barring that, it's not like the confiscations wouldn't happen if no one bought the confiscated items, so I don't see any issue with buying the confiscated items when a good deal can be had.You probably already know this, bu they recently tried that and the flight attendants threw a hissy fit and got it shot down.

-
90% of what I have I bought from our Airports Chapel sale, so I'm 100% fine with buying confiscated items. The whole confiscation process sucks, but being able to buy the items for dirt cheap is better than them getting destroyed.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
@captain spaulding said:
@nate j said:
I would certainly vote for them to loosen the restrictions on knives, thus severely curtailing the confiscations. But barring that, it's not like the confiscations wouldn't happen if no one bought the confiscated items, so I don't see any issue with buying the confiscated items when a good deal can be had.
You probably already know this, bu they recently tried that and the flight attendants threw a hissy fit and got it shot down.

Yes, I do recall that. According to the TSA, the planned change was "part of an overall Risk-Based Security approach, which allows Transportation Security Officers to better focus their efforts on finding higher threat items such as explosives. This decision aligns TSA more closely with International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) standards."
This all made perfect sense, but was scuttled by fear-mongering whiners with a poor understanding of the dynamics of close range violence. Now, I'm not suggesting they start allowing knives in prisons, but anyone who is dangerous with a 6 cm non-locking folder can't be less dangerous without one by anything but the very slimmest of margins. While I don't claim to be an expert on the subject, if I had the choice between trying to use my 91 mm SAK as a weapon and using my bare hands, I would generally choose bare hands.

-
@cedricada said:
Its what happens when you privatize absolutely everything in a country, its gets full of shark style practices - ths TSA is in business to make money, and the sales of seizures from poor hurried or overwhelmed passengers go to them.The decent thing to do would be to have a padded post bag for sale at the terminal to have the item posted back. But instead, they opt to capitalize on the hurry someone is in and confiscate and resell.
I know the answer is "well if you dont want it taken, dont be absent minded". But I hate that pervasive attitude. Its creeping into everything. People should be given a little leeway for error here and there.
It must make the nutter terrorists so happy to see what they caused to happen to air travel. People getting looked at naked and molested just to get on a flight. When does it end?
I do agree with the idea of setting up a small segment somewhere close to the TSA screening, and people could just post their precious back to themselves. I mean they could even sell those padded envelop at much higher price(for example, $5-10 each), and in addition, a machine that sell postage label. That'd be triple win to airport, post office and traveller.
-
@comis said:
I do agree with the idea of setting up a small segment somewhere close to the TSA screening, and people could just post their precious back to themselves. I mean they could even sell those padded envelop at much higher price(for example, $5-10 each), and in addition, a machine that sell postage label. That'd be triple win to airport, post office and traveller.That would make perfect sense, so I guess it's unlikely to happen :(
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login