Bike Lights
-
I've had a Fenix BC30 on my bike for about a week now, and it's been outstanding. I'm running it on a pair of AW 18650-3400's I have. I've run it consistently at medium (200L) and high (500L) for a good couple of hours nearly every night this week, and the battery indicator has yet to show anything but green.
I also have a Zebralight H600w on my helmet, mounted with twofish blocks. I've posted about that in the Outdoors forum.
I will heartily disagree with Etherealicer on the headlamp; by all means, if you have one you can use, then use it. The advantages far outweigh the disadvantages. Having a headlamp on your helmet lets you look into turns allowing you to better anticipate what is up ahead of you and plan accordingly. In combination with a handlebar mounted light you get much, MUCH better visibility in terms of what you can see. Also, two lights make you easier to see than one. I rarely have any issue with people flashing their high beams at me unless I'm running my H600w at max (1020L). When approaching other cyclists or pedestrians on the bike path, I simply turn my head just a slight bit so the beam isn't shining right at them, and it's not usually a problem.
Also, headlamps on bicycle helmets are hardly a problem. When people drive they stare pretty much straight into dozens of lights that are far brighter than even a high output light like my h600w... complaining about having a bike light coming at you with all the other car lights around, is a bit like complaining that it's raining when you're swimming; nit-picky nonsense.
-
I just duct tape an led light to my bike if I need a quick trip to Allsups at night for milk
-
That won't work here. It's dark most of the time.
-
I used to live over the road from a bike track in the forest. People would ride at night there wearing those really bright lights with battery packs on their backs (I think). When I drove past the entrance at night and they were congregating there they would look in my direction and blind the hell out of me.
-
Sorry, but I'm not a fan of cyclists using bright headlamps either. Car lights are pointed at THE ROAD, not straight into the eyes of oncomimg drivers; this makes all the difference. If folks don't believe this is true then turn on your headlamp at night walk 20 feet away, stare into it for a couple of seconds and then look away. If you can honestly say it's not affected your vision then feel free to wear it. :) If, however, you find you have spots in your eyes, then please don't wear it on the road.
-
@Gareth said:
Sorry, but I'm not a fan of cyclists using bright headlamps either. Car lights are pointed at THE ROAD, not straight into the eyes of oncomimg drivers; this makes all the difference. If folks don't believe this is true then turn on your headlamp at night walk 20 feet away, stare into it for a couple of seconds and then look away. If you can honestly say it's not affected your vision then feel free to wear it. :) If, however, you find you have spots in your eyes, then please don't wear it on the road.True enough, but roads aren't totally smooth; headlights move up and down, and you still get them in face. Different cars have lights at different heights; you still get them in the face. And besides, who's reaction is it to head toward a really bright light coming at them? Still a better safety feature than a hindrance, in my opinion, but at the same time, most people here don't not own a motor vehicle and rely on their bike for 98% of their transportation, as I do. I also doubt most members here ride both in extremely congested urban traffic while commuting (downtown San Francisco, Berkeley, and Oakland), AND on unlit rural roads miles in the hills. Here in the Bay Area we have both and a typical ride home for me is usually a minimum of 20 miles in both types of conditions. In downtown SF being seen means staying alive, and if I have to intentionally blind someone to keep them from running a red light so they don't mow me down, so be it.
-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
Sorry, but I'm not a fan of cyclists using bright headlamps either. Car lights are pointed at THE ROAD, not straight into the eyes of oncomimg drivers; this makes all the difference. If folks don't believe this is true then turn on your headlamp at night walk 20 feet away, stare into it for a couple of seconds and then look away. If you can honestly say it's not affected your vision then feel free to wear it. :) If, however, you find you have spots in your eyes, then please don't wear it on the road.
True enough, but roads aren't totally smooth; headlights move up and down, and you still get them in face. Different cars have lights at different heights; you still get them in the face. And besides, who's reaction is it to head toward a really bright light coming at them? Still a better safety feature than a hindrance, in my opinion, but at the same time, most people here don't not own a motor vehicle and rely on their bike for 98% of their transportation, as I do. I also doubt most members here ride both in extremely congested urban traffic while commuting (downtown San Francisco, Berkeley, and Oakland), AND on unlit rural roads miles in the hills. Here in the Bay Area we have both and a typical ride home for me is usually a minimum of 20 miles in both types of conditions. In downtown SF being seen means staying alive, and if I have to intentionally blind someone to keep them from running a red light so they don't mow me down, so be it.
Sorry Heinz, perhaps I'm reading you wrong, but are you saying that just because it might only be dangerous to the driver and not the cyclist, it's OK to distract the oncoming driver?
I take your point that in remote and unlit areas that a good headlamp is a boon, but using it to deliberately blind someone is a concept I just can't get behind.
Could you not mount a good air-horn to your bike if you feel you need to make your presence known? -
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
Sorry, but I'm not a fan of cyclists using bright headlamps either. Car lights are pointed at THE ROAD, not straight into the eyes of oncomimg drivers; this makes all the difference. If folks don't believe this is true then turn on your headlamp at night walk 20 feet away, stare into it for a couple of seconds and then look away. If you can honestly say it's not affected your vision then feel free to wear it. :) If, however, you find you have spots in your eyes, then please don't wear it on the road.
True enough, but roads aren't totally smooth; headlights move up and down, and you still get them in face. Different cars have lights at different heights; you still get them in the face. And besides, who's reaction is it to head toward a really bright light coming at them? Still a better safety feature than a hindrance, in my opinion, but at the same time, most people here don't not own a motor vehicle and rely on their bike for 98% of their transportation, as I do. I also doubt most members here ride both in extremely congested urban traffic while commuting (downtown San Francisco, Berkeley, and Oakland), AND on unlit rural roads miles in the hills. Here in the Bay Area we have both and a typical ride home for me is usually a minimum of 20 miles in both types of conditions. In downtown SF being seen means staying alive, and if I have to intentionally blind someone to keep them from running a red light so they don't mow me down, so be it.
Sorry Heinz, perhaps I'm reading you wrong, but are you saying that just because it might only be dangerous to the driver and not the cyclist, it's OK to distract the oncoming driver?
I take your point that in remote and unlit areas that a good headlamp is a boon, but using it to deliberately blind someone is a concept I just can't get behind.
Could you not mount a good air-horn to your bike if you feel you need to make your presence known?The phenomenon of "Target fixation". It's why skiiers ski into the only tree on the slope. Our unconcious tendency is to steer where we're looking. Major cause of motorcycle accidents and is often the reason runners get hit by a car when they run on the road.
-
Properly aimed car headlights will not blind oncoming drivers. A head lamp, even at half the power shining right at you will.
Do you really want a partially blinded driver driving towards you? The worst he'll feel is a bump, you on the other hand...
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
Sorry, but I'm not a fan of cyclists using bright headlamps either. Car lights are pointed at THE ROAD, not straight into the eyes of oncomimg drivers; this makes all the difference. If folks don't believe this is true then turn on your headlamp at night walk 20 feet away, stare into it for a couple of seconds and then look away. If you can honestly say it's not affected your vision then feel free to wear it. :) If, however, you find you have spots in your eyes, then please don't wear it on the road.
True enough, but roads aren't totally smooth; headlights move up and down, and you still get them in face. Different cars have lights at different heights; you still get them in the face. And besides, who's reaction is it to head toward a really bright light coming at them? Still a better safety feature than a hindrance, in my opinion, but at the same time, most people here don't not own a motor vehicle and rely on their bike for 98% of their transportation, as I do. I also doubt most members here ride both in extremely congested urban traffic while commuting (downtown San Francisco, Berkeley, and Oakland), AND on unlit rural roads miles in the hills. Here in the Bay Area we have both and a typical ride home for me is usually a minimum of 20 miles in both types of conditions. In downtown SF being seen means staying alive, and if I have to intentionally blind someone to keep them from running a red light so they don't mow me down, so be it.
Sorry Heinz, perhaps I'm reading you wrong, but are you saying that just because it might only be dangerous to the driver and not the cyclist, it's OK to distract the oncoming driver?
I take your point that in remote and unlit areas that a good headlamp is a boon, but using it to deliberately blind someone is a concept I just can't get behind.
Could you not mount a good air-horn to your bike if you feel you need to make your presence known?The phenomenon of "Target fixation". It's why skiiers ski into the only tree on the slope. Our unconcious tendency is to steer where we're looking. Major cause of motorcycle accidents and is often the reason runners get hit by a car when they run on the road.

If someone says think about something other than an elephant, you have to think about an elephant in order to find something different. If someone says think about cheesecake ... the chances you are going to think about an elephant is pretty slim. Focus on what you want to achieve rather than what you want to avoid.
If you want someone to notice you so they don't run into you, imparing both their vision and thinking ability so they still might run into you (or even into someone else) doesn't seem like the best option to me

-
I got to add
I keep my light pointed at the ground in front of my wheel.
I also don't run my headlight on hi when on the road with cars.
I ride mostly in on gravel or off road.
-
Mmmmm.... cheesecake...

-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
Sorry, but I'm not a fan of cyclists using bright headlamps either. Car lights are pointed at THE ROAD, not straight into the eyes of oncomimg drivers; this makes all the difference. If folks don't believe this is true then turn on your headlamp at night walk 20 feet away, stare into it for a couple of seconds and then look away. If you can honestly say it's not affected your vision then feel free to wear it. :) If, however, you find you have spots in your eyes, then please don't wear it on the road.
True enough, but roads aren't totally smooth; headlights move up and down, and you still get them in face. Different cars have lights at different heights; you still get them in the face. And besides, who's reaction is it to head toward a really bright light coming at them? Still a better safety feature than a hindrance, in my opinion, but at the same time, most people here don't not own a motor vehicle and rely on their bike for 98% of their transportation, as I do. I also doubt most members here ride both in extremely congested urban traffic while commuting (downtown San Francisco, Berkeley, and Oakland), AND on unlit rural roads miles in the hills. Here in the Bay Area we have both and a typical ride home for me is usually a minimum of 20 miles in both types of conditions. In downtown SF being seen means staying alive, and if I have to intentionally blind someone to keep them from running a red light so they don't mow me down, so be it.
Sorry Heinz, perhaps I'm reading you wrong, but are you saying that just because it might only be dangerous to the driver and not the cyclist, it's OK to distract the oncoming driver?
I take your point that in remote and unlit areas that a good headlamp is a boon, but using it to deliberately blind someone is a concept I just can't get behind.
Could you not mount a good air-horn to your bike if you feel you need to make your presence known?An air-horn doesn't do much good, particularly in a busy environment. With all the other traffic around, and especially in an urban canyon, the sound is directionless and a driver can't tell where it's coming from. If I flash someone, it tells them right where I am and what location to avoid.
That said, no, I don't just casually flash anyone I come across, and I don't run my headlamp on max all the time either. I will, however, if someone is about to hit me by running a light, etc. And believe me, in downtown San Francisco during rush hour, you learn to wait a second or two after the light turns green to allow those rushing a$$holes to run the light before you start into the intersection. Even then, at least once a day either going into the office or coming back home, I see someone blatantly run a light, even going through crossing traffic.
Even more common are the people who try to sneak through in heavy traffic and end up blocking the intersection; I see that several times each day, particularly in the evenings. In a situation like that, were I have no choice but to split through cars to get through the intersection, my headlamp lets them know I am coming and from where, and to let me pass. And I'm not too worried about pissing people off and having them come after me either... this last summer a guy in downtown SF ran a light and a cyclist yelled at him, and he hit the cyclist... the surrounding crowd of cyclists dragged the guy out of his car and beat the living $hit out of him... he was in a coma for several days afterward. I'm not one of those people though; I'm too old for that kind of stuff, and while I do ride aggressively, I'm not foolish. I know when to stop and when to go.
In short, I use a headlight because it's an essential tool. If I'm coming across as an indiscriminate user, that's not what I mean, and I'm obviously not communicating that clearly enough. But in terms of my safety, a powerful headlamp is a necessary tool and I will NOT ride without one at night.
-
@derekmac said:
Properly aimed car headlights will not blind oncoming drivers.Please actually read what I posted above about car headlights. Perhaps you have the luxury of perfectly smooth roads where you live, and everyone drives exactly the same car so no one ever gets headlights in the face, but where I live, in the real world, it happens all the time.
@derekmac said:
A head lamp, even at half the power shining right at you will.Again, please read what I posted above about how I use my headlamp while riding.
-
The law for bicycle lighting hereabouts is that from one hour after sunset to one hour before sunrise, I need one or two white lights on the front (but no more than two; headlamps are permitted), one red light on the back, and a red reflector on the back.
On my road bike, I use a Blackburn Super Flea on the front, and a red Blackburn Flea on the back. These lights are very bright, and are USB rechargeable. The Super Flea isn't Super Cheap (normally $45-ish in my area), but I didn't pay MSRP on it.
On my winterized mountain bike, I'm using a Black Diamond Storm headlamp permanently zip-tied to the centre of my handlebar, and an old MEC Dazzle Clip Mount permanently attached to the mounting arm of my rear filth prophylactic. Both of these lights were cheap like borscht, take easily sourced AA or AAA batteries, and make me highly visible while illuminating the road before me.
Just for the whynots, both bikes have wheel reflectors. I have some shame somewhere, but it isn't on my bicycles.
I'm not going to rant about it, but at my height, on my required road bike size, in my truck-and-SUV-heavy corner of the world, it is all headlights in my eyes all the time. This is no-one's fault, but it is a definite fact.
-
OK Heniz, it's obvious we're never going to agree on this and I don't want this to turn into an argument, but I will say that a horn is exactly what a car has to alert other drivers to your presence and it seems to work well for them. I'm not sure I agree that sound is somehow directionless either.

-
I think headlights as well as a fixed forward light are a good idea, as long as they're not too bright and shone in other road users' eyes.
There is nothing in our road code (mind you I haven't looked at it in 20 years) about flashing lights, but I think most would agree these are a great option for being visible. -
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
Properly aimed car headlights will not blind oncoming drivers.
Please actually read what I posted above about car headlights. Perhaps you have the luxury of perfectly smooth roads where you live, and everyone drives exactly the same car so no one ever gets headlights in the face, but where I live, in the real world, it happens all the time.
@derekmac said:
A head lamp, even at half the power shining right at you will.Again, please read what I posted above about how I use my headlamp while riding.
I did read what you wrote, and I happen to live in the province that invented horrible roads. That is why I said properly aimed lights. Yes cars bounce going over bumps, which will cause the lights to momentarily shine higher than normal, but you can't compare lights designed to be operated and constantly directed at oncoming people to a headlight that probably isn't.
You also stated that if you had to blind someone, you would. That's why I said the car would only feel a bump.
I'm not directing this at you, this is from 16 years experience of driving on back roads that are heavily populated by bikes. The vast majority of bikers I see think they own the road, and can make up the rules of the road as they please. I can't count the amount of idiot bikers I've almost hit because of this mentality.
The road should be shared, respectfully by all parties.
-
I also want to apologize if what I'm saying is offensive or makes me sound like an ass. I still have a killer cold, and my head is still a bit fuzzy. I just don't want anyone to get hurt from something that could possibly be prevented, that's all.

-
@Gareth said:
OK Heniz, it's obvious we're never going to agree on this and I don't want this to turn into an argument, but I will say that a horn is exactly what a car has to alert other drivers to your presence and it seems to work well for them. I'm not sure I agree that sound is somehow directionless either.
In general, no, it's not directionless. We actually have pretty good sound localization outside of the medial plane of the body because there's a strong crossover differential in the primary auditory nerve starting at the superior olivary nucleus and going up into the primary auditory pathway from there. It's actually because of the high level of cross over and signal integration at that level that allows the brain to extrapolate direction of a sound. Unless of course it's directly on the medial bilateral symmetric plane of the body. However, such localization is based on the differential amplitude of the sound wave between the two ears. Binaural auditory perception creates a "sound shadow" where the sound received by the distal ear is at reduced amplitude compared to the proximal ear. However, this creates other problems (more on that in a minute).
Our visual localization ability is much more robust than our auditory localization ability. This is not only because of the greater amount of separation in the precortical processing of the visual signal (full binocular processing doesn't happen until V5 in the anterior occipital lobe) compared to auditory processing (which begins crossover processing in the precortical auditory nuclei as I mention above) but also because a structure in the middle of the brain, called the superior colliculus, functions to create a map of visual space that is used specifically for visual object localization. It receives direct input from the spatiotopic mapping of the retina and visual field corresponding to the three dimensional spatial layout received by the eyes. In fact, the superior colliculus plays a central role in the brain's construction of our internal representation of three dimensional visual space.
Now, the inferior colliculus does the same thing for auditory localization, but the problem is it does so after the binaural auditory signal has already been integrated in the early steps of auditory processing such as in the vestibular nucleus and the superior olivary nucleus. So the inferior colliculus has to actually re-separate the auditory signals it receives, and it relies on cross-modal input from the superior colliculus to do that.
The problem is, aside from the fact that most people using their horns are directly in back of us (on the medial plane of the body where there is no interaural volume differences, rendering localization practically useless), in a crowded urban environment, there is a tremendous amount of echo and other distortions in the sound signal. That complicates the localization process in the subcortical processing centers in the brain. Add in all the other ambient/white noise, and it can be almost impossible to localize a sound, particularly when the sound is being diffused/muffled by passing through the barrier of the body of the car. Thousands of cars produce a lot of noise, and downtown SF traffic is VERY noisy. While my specialization is the cognitive neurophysiology of visual spatial localization, particularly with respect to attentionally guided visual spatial perception, I do know of many psychophysical studies on auditory localization that demonstrate that the more muddied the auditory stimulus is, and the more noise there is in the environment, the more difficult it becomes to localize a sound. What's more, these physical acoustic factors interact; white noise and/or other noise further degrades the signal and reduces the amplitude differences between the proximal and distal ear, which is the primary basis of auditory signal localization.
All that said, again, let me reiterate; I do not deliberately flash people unless I feel they are putting me at risk. And contrary to appearances, that's not all the time, even in downtown San Francisco traffic. :D Additionally, I don't run my headlamp all the time while riding. I recognize that in an urban environment it can be detrimental, and in fact it's often not necessary. I tend to use it less in heavy traffic which is moving slowly, where I'm doing a lot more lane splitting, than in lighter traffic that's moving more quickly and I'm more a part of the flow of traffic rather than moving through stationary cars. There's enough ambient light in those situations that my lighting needs are typically limited to being visible rather than needing to see. Even on the back roads and dedicated bike paths I make extensive use of on my recreational riding home at night, I turn my head to the side to divert the center of the beam off the trail so I don't flash people coming in the opposite direction. And yes, I wish other cyclists would afford me the same courtesy, but they usually don't.
My headlamp is a tool and I actively work to use it appropriately and respectfully as much as I can. Yes, I do deliberately flash people some times; it's a matter of safety. But in general, I'm not some crazed zealot who speeds through traffic deliberately trying to blind people I come across. Using a headlamp tremendously increases my safety and is much more of a benefit than any potential drawbacks. Yeah, once in a while someone gets PO'd even when I'm using my lights responsibly, but that's their reaction, and some people are gonna hate no matter what. For my needs, a headlamp keeps me much, much safer, and I'm not going to compromise on that.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



