Your EDC for a lifetime
-
For my one SAK/multitool I'd probably forego my trusty yellow Compact for something a little more capable. I'd probably end up with a Swiss Tool RS because it's the toughest and most functional tool I can think of.
For a flashlight, I still love the Photon Proton although I am currently without one. They keep disappearing shortly after I show them to someone else!
If I had to choose one knife is probably take a Grohmann Belt Knife as it's big enough for big jobs, small enough for small jobs and not seen as all that threatening to the locals- in fact as they are made here it's more of a mark of pride.
Def
Sent from my smurfing hunk of techno sorcery
-
If it had to be one SAK I'd go back to the Tinker,it's done so much for me over so many years. I'd maybe go Fenix E05 on the torch. Non SAK folder? Hmmm,dunno,maybe my Case Stockman?
-
Multi: Spirit - it has everything I might need and nothing I don't. The serrated butter blade, though locking, is non threatening and actually very useful. The whole thing is beautifully made - I just wish it had a pocket clip.
Torch: I don't know that many. Something that takes one easy to find AA, has a tailcap switch and afew light levels. My Fenix LD09 is very nice but there's probably something 'better' out there. Pocket clip!
Knife: Enzo PK70. Best fit and finish of any tool I own. Nice steel, good blade shape and lovely lovely carbon fibre scales. Pocket clip!
-
The multi part for me is a bit difficult, as I only have 4. Two of which are discontinued and bought because they were no longer available. But I would probably have to go with my Schrade ST-1. It would be a hard choice between Sidekick or ST-1, but the Tough Tool is just a better choice for serious hard work.
Light would be a Coast PX-25- Small enough to not be a hinderance, cheap enough that replacing it isn't a big deal either. It only runs on AAAs, but it gives absolutely more than enough light with it and the run time is very respectable in my usage.
Knife would be my Buck 110- half because of sentimentality and half because it's just a good capable blade, though maybe a bit overkill.
-
I would have to pick an MT over a SAK I think.
The MT I'd choose today would be the ST200. Great tool set, and comfortable to use. I'm kind of surprising myself by not picking a SwissTool. :o They have a better tool set, and are just as comfortable to use, but I really don't like the teeny tiny wire cutters on them.For a flashlight, I'd probably say my Mini Mag LED. Throws pretty good light, and uses two standard AA batteries.
I'm having a hard time deciding between either a fixed blade, or folder.
I think I might have to go folder, and even though I don't have one, I'd have to say a Buck 110. They've been around for ages, and have proven themselves over the years. -
Oh man, not one of these threads again....I could go on for a long time rambling about various factors I would consider for such a choice :ahhh I'll have to come back later when I have more time ;)
-
Definitely my new Spirit as my MT although I'd <u>really </u> miss my SAKs
I'm very happy with the AAA LED Maglite I carry
My MOD knife as the fixed blade because it's heavy for splitting wood, quite easy to sharpen and can be used as a hammer

-
MT: Probably the Rebar as a tough and light allrounder. The Wave has the advantage that it's stronger, has OHO blades and that if a new-fangled fastener comes out and I can't change my MT I could still use the bit driver. I still think I'd choose the Rebar though.
Light: Zebralight H52. It's throwy but can be converted to floody. I think it stands a reasonable chance of lasting a while, I know I keep banging on about it but after a year of daily pocket carry my H52F is still mint. It has to be a headtorch because of the amount of use mine gets currently, the reason I would go for the throwy despite currently owning the floody version is that it's easier to convert throw to flood than the other way round.
Knife: my single most used knife is my C33T so that's tempting, but if I was only allowed to use one knife then I'd want something more substantial. In my current collection of one fixed blade knife, the winner (and in fact last place too) would be the Mora that I won. I don't use it every day but it is tough, dependable and can do things my others can't.
-
@Monrogue said:
Oh man, not one of these thread again........I know eh!
Sak or Mt, gonna be an mt. And that Mt will be the Surge. It is a beast and it was the only multi that caused my CT41 to collect dust. Also has OH blades, replaceable wire cutters, replaceable saw and file and has the blade exchanger.Just a single blade is a toss up. SOG Vulcan or Mora Bushcraft Black. Since I am in the woods and on the farm a lot I would say it is the Mora. Ideally, a blade made by Seved in 1095 would just be sweet!
The torch is easy, Mag-Lite Mag-Tac. Built like a tank. Does not have tons of modes. Has a pocket clip.
-
I've been trying to kill my supertool 300 for like 6 months and still haven't been able to. So I think I'd choose that for my multi.
As for my light Id pick my streamlight microstream. I have 2 but have been using the same one for years and years. Can't kill that either.
And for my knife, I would probably go with one of my spyderco choices. Most likely my tenacious since it's relatively cheap, has a decent (although not amazing) steel, good size and good shape.
It's a good thing we don't have to choose like this, though. Every member here would lose their minds really quickly

-
Sorry, not playing :D
My needs and tastes have changed too frequently for me to choose just one for life. "Urban" tools weren't heavy duty enough for a lot of chores on the boat, and none of the boat tools were legal or appropriate for daily carry. The boat may be gone, but the principal remains. It's like only choosing one pair of shoes and expecting them to be suitable for weddings, jogging, digging the garden, job interviews, hill walking, rock climbing, paddling in the sea, and trudging through snow and ice. No single tool/torch/knife solutions for me ;)
-
Well that is a bit of a tough one, but i'll give it a go.

If I could only choose between a SAK or Multitool I would have to go with a full sized multitool. It would most likely be a Swisstool X or RS. Both the X and RS are very well made, built like a tank, offer a excellent tool selection, and are very rust resistant.
For the flashlight I do not even have to give it a second thought. It would be a Zebralight SC52 (or currently produced equivalent single AA Zebralight). It is easily my favorite and most reliable flashlight I have ever owned. Tiny yet incredibly bright. It runs on a (very common) single AA battery. Build quality is excellent and it offers a pocket clip. I also love the ergonomics of the light. If it was the one and only light I could carry for the rest of my life I would be completely content with it.
As far as fixed blades I honestly do not know enough to make a "life long" carry decision. Around here it is only legal to open carry a fixed blade and if it accidentally gets covered in any way you can get charged with a felony so no one even chances it.
-
I told my exGFs I would EDC them for life, ... until I found something better.
-
Ugh. I can't really answer this. I live a "double life"
-
Hospital pathologist (10-12 hours/day): In this role, my MT would be my Cybertimer 41 (Cybertool 41 with Timekeeper scales). It's a total winner. My light is a small Prometheus Beta QR, which rides on my keys. It's all I need at work and commuting to and from home. Separate knife isn't necessary or wanted. Instead I substitute a OPT, and in this case it would be an Atwood Ghost. This has been my EDC for months now.
-
Horse Farmer/Farm laborer: (The rest of my life): On the farm, I need a real tool. Lately, I've been carrying a Wenger minigrip, which has been extremely good. The only place where the Leatherman Charge has a slight edge, is that the Leatherman has a larger pliers head. If I'm still allowed use of dedicated tools when needed, I would go with the Wenger minigrip BECAUSE it takes standard 1/4 bits and carries 6 bits at a time.
On the farm, my Zebralight headlamp would be my choice. It's bullet proof.
Knife would likely be my Spyderco Captain, although my CRKT stubby Razel has been my goto knife lately.
-
-
Farmer, a machete in the nine or ten inch neighborhood (counts as a knife, right?), and a torch with a fair bit of throw.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Ugh. I can't really answer this. I live a "double life"-
Hospital pathologist (10-12 hours/day): In this role, my MT would be my Cybertimer 41 (Cybertool 41 with Timekeeper scales). It's a total winner. My light is a small Prometheus Beta QR, which rides on my keys. It's all I need at work and commuting to and from home. Separate knife isn't necessary or wanted. Instead I substitute a OPT, and in this case it would be an Atwood Ghost. This has been my EDC for months now.
-
Horse Farmer/Farm laborer: (The rest of my life): On the farm, I need a real tool. Lately, I've been carrying a Wenger minigrip, which has been extremely good. The only place where the Leatherman Charge has a slight edge, is that the Leatherman has a larger pliers head. If I'm still allowed use of dedicated tools when needed, I would go with the Wenger minigrip BECAUSE it takes standard 1/4 bits and carries 6 bits at a time.
On the farm, my Zebralight headlamp would be my choice. It's bullet proof.
Knife would likely be my Spyderco Captain, although my CRKT stubby Razel has been my goto knife lately.
WOW!!! :o :o :o The Minigrip has knocked the ALX off the top spot? How are you choosing to carry it? Found a suitable sheath?
-
-
Multi: New Surge with Accessories
Light: LED Lenser P2
Knife: Grohmann #3 with Resinwood Scales and Flat Grind
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login








