New Moras
-
Boning out a pig, gave a slight twist to separate it as I pulled it through and ping!
Cutting through a fish, used my spare hand to hit my knife hand for added pressure and ping!
Gets returned with a slight bend, should be able to tweak that out, ping!Z, were they breaking at the tip, mid blade or at the handle/blade transition?
Between mid blade and the handle transition.
So a full tang would not really help?
Have you tried the Mora robust? It has a thicker blade. -
Boning out a pig, gave a slight twist to separate it as I pulled it through and ping!
Cutting through a fish, used my spare hand to hit my knife hand for added pressure and ping!
Gets returned with a slight bend, should be able to tweak that out, ping!Z, were they breaking at the tip, mid blade or at the handle/blade transition?
Between mid blade and the handle transition.
So a full tang would not really help?
Have you tried the Mora robust? It has a thicker blade.+1 Or a Bushcraft Black. Don't see that one ever snapping under heavy use.
-
[quote author=zoidberg link=topic=56808.msg1208756#msg1208756 date=1452258783]
Boning out a pig, gave a slight twist to separate it as I pulled it through and ping!
Cutting through a fish, used my spare hand to hit my knife hand for added pressure and ping!
Gets returned with a slight bend, should be able to tweak that out, ping!Z, were they breaking at the tip, mid blade or at the handle/blade transition?
Between mid blade and the handle transition.
So a full tang would not really help?
Have you tried the Mora robust? It has a thicker blade.+1 Or a Bushcraft Black. Don't see that one ever snapping under heavy use.
[/quote]I haven't tried either of those, they are hard to find and expensive.
-
[quote author=SAK Guy link=topic=56808.msg1208772#msg1208772 date=1452262948]
[quote author=zoidberg link=topic=56808.msg1208756#msg1208756 date=1452258783]
Boning out a pig, gave a slight twist to separate it as I pulled it through and ping!
Cutting through a fish, used my spare hand to hit my knife hand for added pressure and ping!
Gets returned with a slight bend, should be able to tweak that out, ping!Z, were they breaking at the tip, mid blade or at the handle/blade transition?
Between mid blade and the handle transition.
So a full tang would not really help?
Have you tried the Mora robust? It has a thicker blade.+1 Or a Bushcraft Black. Don't see that one ever snapping under heavy use.
[/quote]I haven't tried either of those, they are hard to find and expensive.
[/quote]The new Robust is about $10 here.
Id be happy to help you get one if you are interested. -
@zoidberg said:
Boning out a pig, gave a slight twist to separate it as I pulled it through and ping!
Cutting through a fish, used my spare hand to hit my knife hand for added pressure and ping!
Gets returned with a slight bend, should be able to tweak that out, ping!Interesting. As the other are implying, I think, it sounds like it might be the lateral torque that's caused the failures. Sound fair?
Another knife to look out for might be the Hultafors Heavy Duty. I've had a play with them a couple of times and though they seemed good, plus Smashie swears by them. Even cheaper than Mora knives as a added bonus.
-
Boning out a pig, gave a slight twist to separate it as I pulled it through and ping!
Cutting through a fish, used my spare hand to hit my knife hand for added pressure and ping!
Gets returned with a slight bend, should be able to tweak that out, ping!Interesting. As the other are implying, I think, it sounds like it might be the lateral torque that's caused the failures. Sound fair?
Another knife to look out for might be the Hultafors Heavy Duty. I've had a play with them a couple of times and though they seemed good, plus Smashie swears by them. Even cheaper than Mora knives as a added bonus.
I just bought a Hultafors craftmans knife for $5. I havent had much time to play with it, but I think the blade is slightly thicker than on a Mora 511. Ill check tomorrow.
-
[quote author=zoidberg link=topic=56808.msg1209041#msg1209041 date=1452300359]
[quote author=SAK Guy link=topic=56808.msg1208772#msg1208772 date=1452262948]
[quote author=zoidberg link=topic=56808.msg1208756#msg1208756 date=1452258783]
Boning out a pig, gave a slight twist to separate it as I pulled it through and ping!
Cutting through a fish, used my spare hand to hit my knife hand for added pressure and ping!
Gets returned with a slight bend, should be able to tweak that out, ping!Z, were they breaking at the tip, mid blade or at the handle/blade transition?
Between mid blade and the handle transition.
So a full tang would not really help?
Have you tried the Mora robust? It has a thicker blade.+1 Or a Bushcraft Black. Don't see that one ever snapping under heavy use.
[/quote]I haven't tried either of those, they are hard to find and expensive.
[/quote]The new Robust is about $10 here.
Id be happy to help you get one if you are interested.
[/quote]Thank you, if I have some spare cash later in the year I'll get back to you.

-
Boning out a pig, gave a slight twist to separate it as I pulled it through and ping!
Cutting through a fish, used my spare hand to hit my knife hand for added pressure and ping!
Gets returned with a slight bend, should be able to tweak that out, ping!Interesting. As the other are implying, I think, it sounds like it might be the lateral torque that's caused the failures. Sound fair?
Another knife to look out for might be the Hultafors Heavy Duty. I've had a play with them a couple of times and though they seemed good, plus Smashie swears by them. Even cheaper than Mora knives as a added bonus.
Yeah completely fair.
Apart from when straightening the blade I wasn't expecting the others to break.
I wasn't trying to wail on Mora but there was talk of driving them into trees and standing on them, I wouldn't recommend doing that. -
Boning out a pig, gave a slight twist to separate it as I pulled it through and ping!
Cutting through a fish, used my spare hand to hit my knife hand for added pressure and ping!
Gets returned with a slight bend, should be able to tweak that out, ping!Interesting. As the other are implying, I think, it sounds like it might be the lateral torque that's caused the failures. Sound fair?
Another knife to look out for might be the Hultafors Heavy Duty. I've had a play with them a couple of times and though they seemed good, plus Smashie swears by them. Even cheaper than Mora knives as a added bonus.
Yeah completely fair.
Apart from when straightening the blade I wasn't expecting the others to break.
I wasn't trying to wail on Mora but there was talk of driving them into trees and standing on them, I wouldn't recommend doing that.The one I read about was the older one...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tIBl_IeATnsThen there's this...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EOBot1-lTtw -
I don't want to offend anyone here but IMO that first video is pretty bad, especially the bs fake standing on the blade part.
The music was okay though.
Second video, like I said, bends one way and not back the other.
Look how little effort it took to break it.
As I didn't make the initial bend I don't personally know how far it goes and I'm not about to waste a good blade to find out. -
@zoidberg said:
I don't want to offend anyone here but IMO that first video is pretty bad, especially the bs fake standing on the blade part.
The music was okay though.
Second video, like I said, bends one way and not back the other.
Look how little effort it took to break it.
As I didn't make the initial bend I don't personally know how far it goes and I'm not about to waste a good blade to find out.None taken!
It was Mors Kochanski that originated the test in his Bushcraft book and there is video of him doing it somewhere. It is a real test that was done using the older Moras of probably 25-30 years ago. The way I first posted about it seemed like I was just pulling that test out of my backside so I just posted the first vid I found. It was a halfa$$ed video search on my part but I've some smurfy health issues going on right now.... -
I just checked, and the Hultafors craftsman does have a thicker blade than the Mora 511.
Mora 511 is the red one, Hultafors the orange one.


(Bottom pic: hultafors on top)According to what I can find online, the 511 has a 2mm blade and the craftsman a 2,5mm blade.
Oh. And I would not recomend standing on a mora either.
-
Come on, do it...you know you want too...nobody's watching....go on, stand on it! >:D >:D >:D
-
You just want to see me do the the knife-dance dont you...
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4nB7CQRni50 -
@Grathr said:
You just want to see me do the the knife-dance dont you...
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4nB7CQRni50
Wow...now how do I un-see that? :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
-
That does have to be one of the weirder things I've seen in a while. :o
-
So after reading thru this thread, and curious to play with the Mora, if I wanted stainless steel for the blade, the Compainion is about the choice?
Or perhaps the black Bushcrafter?
I know "tough" is entirely subjective, but just from the reading, the Bushcrafter seems to be the more hardy of the two?
I'll admit that Laplander is pretty cool looking, but has a cool looking price tag as well. :)
-
@Joe58 said:
So after reading thru this thread, and curious to play with the Mora, if I wanted stainless steel for the blade, the Compainion is about the choice?Or perhaps the black Bushcrafter?
I know "tough" is entirely subjective, but just from the reading, the Bushcrafter seems to be the more hardy of the two?
I'll admit that Laplander is pretty cool looking, but has a cool looking price tag as well. :)
The Bushcraft Black is carbon...super tough construction. The reg Bushcraft is Sandvik Stainless. Very good steel and construction but the carbon one is beefed up for HD use!
-
There's got to be easier ways to ruin a piano

The "flex one way but not the other" video has got me intrigued. That's quite an extreme difference of what the blade can take in different directions, even if the blade was weakened in the initial direction.
I know moras have been used as a beater blade by some people, but I've not used one that hard. I tend to use softer bladed full tang knives for the "ugly" work, as I am confident they will deform rather than break if overworked.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login