Sharpening, discuss.
-
I think I move to coffee mugs:
Fine sharpeners are hard to find. Example diamond files I have are quite rough. Only really fine one I have is the stone for straight razor. But have not used that with other knives.
-
I have a Lansky Turnbox and a Spyderco Sharpmaker that I use 95% of the time. I also have a smiths pocket stone, but it's quite old and doesn't see a ton of use. Most of the time it's the Sharpmaker.
-
I have a large (roughly 10 inches) soapstone I inherited that is on my workbench. I keep a Smith's pocket oilstone in the knife box, along with a few pocket stones that are coarser for used knives that someone really abused, which resulted in chips and nicks that I'll have to remove before going to the soapstones. Baby oil or WD-40 is used as honing fluid.
The general consensus among me and my knife-owning friends is that pull-throughs and power sharpeners are only for use on cheap knives. And yes, they do wreck blades. The blade on an old Colonial electrician's knife I had as a kid looks like crap from the years I used pull-throughs.
-
@cody6268 said:
I have a large (roughly 10 inches) soapstone I inherited that is on my workbench. I keep a Smith's pocket oilstone in the knife box, along with a few pocket stones that are coarser for used knives that someone really abused, which resulted in chips and nicks that I'll have to remove before going to the soapstones. Baby oil or WD-40 is used as honing fluid.The general consensus among me and my knife-owning friends is that pull-throughs and power sharpeners are only for use on cheap knives. **And yes, they do wreck blades. ** The blade on an old Colonial electrician's knife I had as a kid looks like crap from the years I used pull-throughs.
That they do. Carbide is a fantastic cutter, but it shears material off and tends to micro-scallop when the depth of cut is not consistent. This is especially true of harder blade steels. The carbide pull through sharpeners work fine on really soft blade steel that you just want sharp enough to open a letter or something, but there is no way to put a truly NICE edge on anything with one.
-
@hiraethus said:
I'd like to practice my freehand sharpening. Currently I've got a combination oil stone that's been abused and is no longer flat. Would like something not too expensive to start with for sharpening SAKs and other smaller blades, occasionally kitchen knives. Been looking at combination 1000/6000 grit Japanese waterstones and the Fallkniven DC4. Any pointers as to which direction to go?H,
I have a few spare bench stones I can bring to the meet if thats what you are after?
-
I'm in the same situation as you, would love to get better at freehanding. I do have the Turnbox and it works well for quick touch-ups. I also have the DC4 but it's way to coarse for my liking, great for reshaping or touching up axes or larger knives in the field.
My father has a Japanese combo-stone at 1000-6000 and it's working very well for him.Interesting that you find the DC4 coarse. I've got a Turnbox and it's very good, and a Lansky 3-stone (Standard?) that I find useful but fiddly - in fact I tend to just use the stones freehand anyway.
I do reckon that a bigger working area would work better. Hmmmm.....
Well, when you start comparing it to a 6000 grit waterstone it seems very coarse in comparison and the diamond side is really coarse when new (a common trait when it comes to diamond as I understand it).
-
@Sparky415 said:
H,
I have a few spare bench stones I can bring to the meet if thats what you are after?
Thanks Sparky - it would certainly be good to compare different stones, even if I do end up with something else before the meet. I've added a request to the meet thread for various sharpening solutions.
-
I did oder 6000 grit wet stone online. Don't remember store but price was still on box, 28€. There were also combo stones 1000/6000. In here seems 800-1000grit is about max you find from local hardware stores but that fine one needed some search.
-
I'm in the same situation as you, would love to get better at freehanding. I do have the Turnbox and it works well for quick touch-ups. I also have the DC4 but it's way to coarse for my liking, great for reshaping or touching up axes or larger knives in the field.
My father has a Japanese combo-stone at 1000-6000 and it's working very well for him.Interesting that you find the DC4 coarse. I've got a Turnbox and it's very good, and a Lansky 3-stone (Standard?) that I find useful but fiddly - in fact I tend to just use the stones freehand anyway.
I do reckon that a bigger working area would work better. Hmmmm.....
Well, when you start comparing it to a 6000 grit waterstone it seems very coarse in comparison and the diamond side is really coarse when new (a common trait when it comes to diamond as I understand it).
I still would like to try a DC4
but I just never have pulled the trigger
I own several of the systems that have been mentioned in this thread but I always end up going back to freehand sharpening :D I love my different systems but when I am in more of a hurry it is easier to take a triangle ultra fine sharpmaker stone out of the system and just hold it similar to a steel and with just a few back and forths I am done
I strop some but wished I did more as I know it takes way less material than even very fine stones but never seem to do this steps as often as I should ::) :D Either way I love to sharpen a blade 
-
@Poncho65 said:
I still would like to try a DC4
but I just never have pulled the trigger
I own several of the systems that have been mentioned in this thread but I always end up going back to freehand sharpening :D I love my different systems but when I am in more of a hurry it is easier to take a triangle ultra fine sharpmaker stone out of the system and just hold it similar to a steel and with just a few back and forths I am done
I strop some but wished I did more as I know it takes way less material than even very fine stones but never seem to do this steps as often as I should ::) :D Either way I love to sharpen a blade 
Mind you, standard for knives at my home has always been a full flat grind (or a mix between full flat and Scandi-grind) which means there's lots of area to scratch with a "course" stone. Here every knife has basically been treated as a chefs knife (there are axes or chisels for tasks where such an edge is to fragile). After that a honing steel is usually enough, possibly combined with a strop (no grit, only leather) to remove the micro-burrs.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Have many folks here tried stropping on very fine sandpaper? Like 2000 grit?I ask because I don't have a leather or canvas strop, and i DO have very high grit sandpaper, and thought I might give it a try.
Hey Lynn,
They are very easy to make, an old leather belt and a flat bit of wood
;)
/post/385782 -
@hiraethus said:
I'd like to practice my freehand sharpening. Currently I've got a combination oil stone that's been abused and is no longer flat. Would like something not too expensive to start with for sharpening SAKs and other smaller blades, occasionally kitchen knives. Been looking at combination 1000/6000 grit Japanese waterstones and the Fallkniven DC4. Any pointers as to which direction to go?I got neither in the end.
Found a combination 400/1000 grit diamond stone that's twice the size of the DC4 and bought that instead. Going to give it a go tonight and see if I can get an edge on something blunt. -
I'd like to practice my freehand sharpening. Currently I've got a combination oil stone that's been abused and is no longer flat. Would like something not too expensive to start with for sharpening SAKs and other smaller blades, occasionally kitchen knives. Been looking at combination 1000/6000 grit Japanese waterstones and the Fallkniven DC4. Any pointers as to which direction to go?
I got neither in the end.
Found a combination 400/1000 grit diamond stone that's twice the size of the DC4 and bought that instead. Going to give it a go tonight and see if I can get an edge on something blunt.I picked up a couple cheap double sided diamond stones on ebay that I use for sharpening different things around the house and they are great. I keep my DMT diamond stones for things with finer edges but I don't care what I sharpen with these
They have lasted remarkable well as well 
-
I'd like to practice my freehand sharpening. Currently I've got a combination oil stone that's been abused and is no longer flat. Would like something not too expensive to start with for sharpening SAKs and other smaller blades, occasionally kitchen knives. Been looking at combination 1000/6000 grit Japanese waterstones and the Fallkniven DC4. Any pointers as to which direction to go?
I got neither in the end.
Found a combination 400/1000 grit diamond stone that's twice the size of the DC4 and bought that instead. Going to give it a go tonight and see if I can get an edge on something blunt.You went for the DC8 then H? I've heard it's only half as portable as the classic DC4.
-
I need to make something sharp also.
Hmm.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login