Which should I choose?
-
I'm a little confused here. I'm kind of stuck between these two retired models both of which are nearly the same price.
The first is a 1993 Soldier, which is well worn on the exterior, but is fine. It has a bail attachment and the old wire-scraper (not exactly sure, based on seller's pics) bottle opener, a feature I greatly desire in an SAK. It's $25 plus around $5 shipping. Since it's already well worn, I wouldn't care about damaging it any more. Another thing is that I'm trying to build my military-issued pocketknife/multitool subcollection.
The other is a Farmer Harvester, another model I greatly desire with the pruner blade. It's $38 brand new with free shipping. Only thing I don't like is that I'd sacrifice the can opener/small flat screwdriver for the pruner blade. I carry a Leatherman PST II often, but sometimes I like to pack a light and thin model. Losing that flat blade/can opener means I won't have a screwdriver for Philips or be able to open cans or strip wires (the other use I have for the can opener) is a minor irritation.
Which should I choose?
-
Personally I would go for the Soldier. It's an absolute classic and the tool set is near perfect for its size. The bail attachment makes it both comfortable in the hand and difficult to lose. My SI is one of my favourite SAK's. I'm excited to hear what others say and what decision you make.
-
I vote for the Soldier too, I get so much use out of the can opener/sd that I have trouble carrying anything without that particular tool. I really prefer to have 2 blades, but sacrificing the opener for it is not a good compromise IMO.

-
Buy both
I think it's a rule

-
Like Kirk said buy both it's a rule here. First I would get the Soldier. Then next payday get the other one unless you can afford both now. Remember it's a rule around here. >:D
-
From what you have described, Soldier has more elements that you want, while Farmer Pruner is a luxury item with missing features. So I'd say Soldier, then Pruner.
Of course, like the choir's singing--when in doubt, buy both. :D
-
Soldier for me,its a classic

-
Thanks for the adivice! I'm going with the Soldier. It's the particular variation I want, with the scraper bottle opener. My '08 Soldier is a '13 model, so it's perfectly 20 years between tang stamps!
The Ebay seller (Central Valley Wholesale) has a couple dozen of the Farmer Harvester in stock, so it can wait.
Now, to make a lanyard bail out of a coat hanger.
-
-
Now, to make a lanyard bail out of a coat hanger.
Use a bicycle spoke, they're stainless so won't rust.
What a great tip!!!!!!!
Thanks!!!!! -
Why not just get a regular Famer, and have EVERYTHING you wanted? Grinding a wire scraper in the crook of the bottle opener isn't hard.
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


