smith pocket pal
-
So I bought this yesterday at REI
http://www.rei.com/product/780741/smiths-pocket-pal-knife-sharpener

is this bad?
Not opened yet, dont want to damage my stuff
Im mainly looking to use it on leathermans and the occasional Vic -
I think it would be okay for in the field touch up but for a few bucks more I would get a Lansky turnbox for more regular sharpening.
-
I have one and use it frequently. However, it's only good to get the blade to 'reasonably sharp'. After I use it, if i want something sharper, I have to switch to ceramic rods.
I have 4 methods of sharpening. This, and a kitchen knife sharpener are the easiest, but this one is MUCH more portable. Then the next in difficulty are the ceramic rods, and finally a Lansky stone.
It's 'not bad'. And it's a good place to start, particularly with blades that might be a little banged up.
-
In my opinion it is bad. Yes it will damage your edge. I would never sharpen any knives with this sort of sharpener unless out in the field and I had no other option.
I'm not trying to be rude, but you asked and this is my opinion.
-
IIRC, the carbide side is sharpening at 40 deg inclusive and ceramic side is at 45 deg inclusive. LM blades are sharpened at around 30-35 deg inclusive, and Vic recommends sharpening at 30-40 deg.
If I were you, unless I rolled and chipped my Vic blade and do need to bring it back in shape to continue, then I would use the carbide side. If my blade is getting fairly dull(cannot slice printer paper), then I think the ceramic side is a fair option to use out on the field.
-
I went for the smaller victorinox handheld knife sharpener for my "field sharpener". I'd like to view it as a Victorinox product made for Victorinox SAKs. It's not "Made in China".
-
I carried and used the Pocket Pal with reasonable results. It is truly an emergency use item though, as it will not put an edge on a Vic or Leatherman that is anything more than serviceable.
I have since binned it in favor of these:
http://www.amazon.com/DMT-D3EFC-Dia-Sharp-Extra-Fine-Diamond/dp/B00006IIO3
For field use, the fine and coarse will do it all. The coarse alone will get you a useful edge. Extra fine you can leave at home or in the vehicle for later.
They are small, and can be a touch difficult to get used to, but.. Size is also what makes them suitable for the field.
Add hook Velcro to the back side and you can work hands free by attaching it to a bag or jacket or sheath that has loop. Or add loop to your boot, belt, hat, whatever. I stuck some on my rigid plastic Mora sheath.
I carry a small strip of loop too and use it as a handle.



-
If you're going to use this, then at least get the version with the ceramic insert meant for serrations. V-type sharpeners do sharpen, but they sharpen in the wrong direction and leave you with a very weak edge.
The one I'm talking about is pretty much identical, but is made by LANSKY and it's called the "Lansky blade medic". The ceramic stone is very fine and can be used to put the final edge on the blade, an edge that isn't weak and easy to dull again.
http://images.knifecenter.com/knifecenter/lansky/images/LSPSMED01.jpg
-
The only maintenance I do in the "field" for my EDC stuff is a small smooth steel rod I have to restore the edge when it rolls. Doing this frequently means I can go a long time without really sharpening the blade.
That saves the steel in the blade very, very much. Sometimes I also strop on my wallet or something when I make some delicate cuts.The real sharpening I never do in the field but at home.
When purchasing sharpening device It´s better to bite the bullet and buy proper equipment. It is expensive but beeing able to really maintain the tools is almost half the fun for me.As a beginner I would advice the Spyderco Tri-Angle sharpmaker since it is a really easy and fool-proof way of getting good results. It costs probable 70-75USD but I´ve had mine for 20 years and it can take care of all your knives, scissors and other sharp stuff.
If you then get "hooked" you may want to get ultra fine rods, diamond rods for the sharpmaker maybe also stropping leather, paste and steel and maybe even stuff for freehand sharpening. It is a really great skill to have to sharpen stuff.
When friends visit me they always bring their blunt kitchen knives and work knivesfor me to sharpen.
I even have a chef friend who brings his knives to me since I know exactly how he wants them.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login