Unprepared with a Multitool
-
On Saturday morning, as I drove my wife to work, I noticed that one of the signal lights in my Jeep started clicking faster than usual- a sign that one of the bulbs is burned out. As someone who always uses signal lights, this bugs the crap out of me, so I figured on the way home I'd stop at Canadian Tire and get a new bulb. No problem...
I get to CT and I look up the year make and model of my Jeep and find they have a 3157 bulb listed as the replacement. So, I look through the billions of tiny replacement bulbs on the shelf until finally locating a two-pack of orange colored bulbs (I always buy them in pairs, since when one goes, the other side usually isn't far behind), go to the cash and $10 later I am on my way. It's raining out, but only lightly, so I'm not too concerned about changing a bulb- it's just wet enough that I don't want to be out for too long. I get to the truck in the parking lot, reach for my trusty Crunch and wouldn't you know it? The signal light is held in with Torx head screws, something few if any multis (without a bit set) wouldn't be able to help with. So I head home to see if the one Torx head screwdriver I know the location of is anywhere close to the right size. I hope that if it isn't, then at least maybe one of the Charge bit sets with Torx heads will fit, as I have a regular set of Torx headed bits, but I'll never find them- haven't seen them in years!
I get home, and pull the screwdriver out of the Sunfire- I used it last to pull apart the dash to replace the stereo a while back. It's a good solid Craftsman screwdriver, and since I found it with no fuss whatsoever, I know in my heart that there's no way it could be the right size. But, I try it anyway, and by some strange stroke of luck, it's the right size! For anyone else, this would be good news, but I figure that just means that something else about this simple job is about to get messed up even worse.
I unscrew the signal light, pull the socket from the housing and guess what? The bulb is clear, not orange. Not a big deal- it's the same bulb, just the wrong tint, but I make a mental note to buy the 3057 bulbs in the future, not the 3157. It's not a significant enough difference to go back to the store and exchange them, so I swap the bulbs, re-assemble the signal, climb into the truck, turn the key and put the signal on, and no go. Indicator is still clicking at super speeds, so I get out, take apart the assembly again, and notice that there doesn't seem to be anything wrong with the original bulb. The socket has seen better days though, being all corroded. I try to clean up the contacts a bit, but no go. The good news is, the socket is actually removable, so it's an easy fix to get a new socket and plug it into the cable. So, I put everything back together again, and head back out.
While trying to decide whether to go back to Canadian Tire or go to the dealer's for the part, I remember there's a UAP/NAPA closer, so I figure I'll go there. They supply body shops and garages with parts, so they'll have it, right? I pull into the parking lot, hop out of the Jeep, take apart the signal light and go in. I always try to take the part I need with me to make sure I'm getting the right thing. Well, UAP doesn't carry those, so I end up going back out to the Jeep, re-assembling the light again and head off to the dealer's which is only a few blocks away.
I get to the dealer, park, and hop out, and disassemble the signal light again so I can take the socket into the parts department, where the parts guy tells me he sold the last one the day before. Great. He checks the computer and says there are two in stock at the Dodge dealership across town. Well, I've played that game before, so I ask if we can call the other dealership, because I don't want to drive to the other end of the city to find out the computer hasn't been updated. The parts guy insists that isn't necessary, but I call anyway- luckily I have a friend who used to work there, so I have the number saved in my phone! Good thing I did call, because they only had one in stock, which I was certain would be sold before I could get there, so I asked them to put my name on it and not let anyone else take it before I got there. So, back out to the Jeep to re-assemble the signal light again, then a drive to the opposite side of the city, only to disassemble the signal light yet again to get the socket to compare with the new one, and make sure I am getting the right piece. Needless to say, I am getting pretty damned sick of this signal light at this point, and the incessant high speed clicking every time I need to turn right.
Fortunately they had the right part, and to my amazement, it was reasonably priced at only about $20. I would have figured it would have run at least $35! Anyways, triumphant, I return to my Jeep, and put the signal light together again and hopefully for the last time. I get in, fire it up, put the signal on and it works! I was happy as a pig in poo- a simple part and a 5 minute job that has now cost two and a half hours and almost a quarter of a tank of gas, but it was finally done!
On the ride home it occurred to me how things are getting so specialized these days, and how much of a pain in the butt Torx head screws are. No multitool manufacturer really makes a tool with Torx heads, and there is such a variety of them you'd need a dedicated Torx bit set anyway. And, while you can use different sized flathead and phillips head screwdrivers in different sized screws, that's not a possibility with Torx. Torx is either the right size, or it's wrong- no gray area at all.
The thing that bothered me the most was that in this instance, it was a simple job that any multitool should have been able to do- in fact, this is the kind of job that we carry multitools for in the first place, and yet it was virtually useless to me. This isn't the tool's fault- there are very few tools with built in Torx heads, and of the few that do, the odds of having the right size are pretty slim. It's just frustrating to be prepared, and yet still not be prepared, if that makes any sense. Maybe it was the whole situation, but it annoyed the crap out of me that a vehicle that's designed to have it's parts easily accessible, and a tool that's designed for just about any job, still couldn't find any common ground. I could understand if I was trying to do something complex, or with specialized equipment, but come on, this is a signal light on a Jeep!
I guess this was more of a rant than anything else... and it certainly hasn't turned me off the Crunch, as any multitool would have been useless....
Anyone else ever have this kind of thing happen?
Def
-
I have a similar one of those in my toolbox in the house, but it was in the house and I don't think it has any Torx bits in it anyway. I think I may pick one of those ones up tomorrow to keep in the truck.
Def
-
Having a decent set of odd bits (Torx, Hex, etc) in your Jeep could be of use...the Crunch has a bit driver after all 8)
And Leatherman has a few Torx bits in their sets, although you'd need a new Wave, Charge, Surge, Skeletool to use them.
-
I can't remember if it came with any torx, but I have a cheap jobmate kit that I pick and choose my own set to store in the handle.
-
Actually, that just about sounds like an average day in my life... :D
The drivers on most MTs are a big letdown. I currently carry a multi-driver like jzmtl in my bag because I need it very often.
I'd actually prefer a nice compact separate bit driver accessory to an integrated MT solution. No ratcheting required. Just a decent long shaft and some double-sided bits.
But let's face it - there are a LOT of mundane tasks that even the best MT can't handle. You can't even hammer a nail with one (though I am sure many have tried). At the end of the day, you are bound to run into situations like this and just need to prepare for them as best you can.
-
Victorinox Cybertools have 3 sizes of Torx bits in them.
-
Yeah they do. But, the black paint comes off within the first use and I used a torx bit ONCE and it showed signs of stripping!
-
yeah that's happen to me to many times! I was a trade show carpenter for 16 years
and I had to also do a lot of millwright work, so I needed all kinds of bits and sizes
and types. I found this one year and it has served me well (especially for 12 bucks!)standard, phillips, torx, allen, even square! plus some nut drivers and extensions
and an adoptor for sockets;

also shown with a screwdriver I have that has a reversible/magnetic (small/large)
bit holder that I put an apex in to use the various bits.Of course it's not carry-able (easily) but for so many different screws and fasteners
out there, it's a must. No MT can have it all but it's sure nice to think we can try!
-
@Defender said:
It's a good solid Craftsman screwdriver, and since I found it with no fuss whatsoever, I know in my heart that there's no way it could be the right size. But, I try it anyway, and by some strange stroke of luck, it's the right size!This is the attitude with which I approach every new task that involves screws, bolts, nuts, etc. Unless I've done that specific task before and can remember exactly what was needed toolwise, I sort of expect some complication will arise to make completing the task impossible with the tools at hand.
When I am able to accomplish a task with just a multi or a multi and a pocket screwdriver, I am grateful that the Gods of Hardware were in a merciful mood.
@Defender said:
I could understand if I was trying to do something complex, or with specialized equipment, but come on, this is a signal light on a Jeep!...Anyone else ever have this kind of thing happen?I first regularly encountered Torx screws while working on Compaq computers sometime back in the late 80s IIRC.
Everyone knew Torx screws were just a gimmick to make Compaqs harder for the owner to disassemble and change out parts. Nobody else in the personal computer industry was using them at that time, only Compaq.
Since then, Torx screws seem to have spread far and wide.
I can see their superiority in certain applications with small screws requiring a lot of torque, like screws for multis, knives, pocket clips, etc.
However, the tail lights on a Jeep is a ridiculous, absurd application! It's so predictable that people will have to change burnt out tail lights while out on the road.
.
-
Torx heads are always a pain. I switch them out on sight if I have a philips or flathead of similar dimensions and threading. Might be worth doing on the Jeep as well.
-
@Leatherman123 said:
Yeah they do. But, the black paint comes off within the first use and I used a torx bit ONCE and it showed signs of stripping!You must be applying a lot more torque on your torx than I do.
What is on the bits looks like a BO coating, not paint, but it does tend to wear off easily.
-
Great story boss :)
I know all screw types have a pupose, but I really miss the simplicity of a decent flathead screw :(
-
I'm confident a variable hex driver isn't far off. Take three pairs of tweezers, insert them into a socket one at a time, support the rig with a solid core - voila! It'll take some tough steel, though.
-
I was working on my sister's Pontiac two weeks ago. Since I was an tech at work, I smugly bring over my specialty bits collection only to find that the ignition switch is secured with REVERSE torx! They look like bolts with a torx driver head on them. I've never had a bolt like that. Luckily, I had a miniature set of pliers that worked.
-
All Jeep owners: Let's give a hearty cheer to Chrysler for spec'ing specialized fasteners on what used to be a nice, simple design.
::) -
The taillights on my Saturn are Torx!
I've noticed that with Torx the smallest ones are especially hard to come by in those "multi bit kits". But that said, if you are depending on your multi to handle all of your driving and screwing tasks, then you are wishing for a multi with nothing but screwdrivers. Especially with the Torx head, where you NEED the right size, unlike a phillips or flat.
An adjustable Torx would be the awesome.
I keep with my kit a Klein 10-1 screwdriver. I have had the other styles, with bit storage in the handle, but for me, those bits always get lost/misplaced/fall out. Or, when I'm up on a lift, juggling items, it's very hard to unscrew a cap and find the bit I need. With the klein, its all in the handle, so its just sliding and flipping to find the tool you want. AND it has common Torx and Robertson, and will handle 5/16" and 1/4" hex . Along with this I have a mini multi head Torx driver. Covers all my bases.
Now, the one thing I really would like to see more common on multi's, is a Robertson driver. And not necessarily in bit changer form. -
The only in-body, permanent mount type Robertson driver you can get on a multi is with SOG. You have to purchase it separately, but thanks to SOG's modular design, you can put it in just abotu any SOG tool you like.
Def
-
Today's automated assembly equipment is ideally suited for Torx screws. I'm sure we'll be seeing more and more of them. :-\
Seems like the best way for the multitool user to deal with torx drive screws is with a bit kit and driver. Leatherman would appear to have the edge with their flattened bit system.
-
I use my Cybertool for Torx, though my new LM can get into the game now with the bit kit.
The modular nature of the SOGs is the one thing that interests me about them.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



