SAK or Multitool...?
-
In my opinion (and needs):
I currently double-carry a Swisstool RS and Spirit in the bag. Let's just say that I needed a 2-pliers combo in a couple of situations.
With that being said, I would like to EDC a 111mm Hercules once I get around to getting one. Part of me is saying that I'll live with an Outrider but it's kindda not available in my country for some reason. Plus I'm sure I'm going to have some use for its pliers.
My bottom line would be budget -- a Leatherman (and Gerber and SOG) costs 30%-40% more here while a SAK costs 30%-40% lower based on a USD1:PHP45 exchange rate. (cost example is Rebar vs. Hercules purchased in a brick and mortar store). I'd like to try the Hercules because I feel I'll get more value for my money.
-
Yes!
Oh,sorry,hadn't read the question

Serious answer is buy both. A small SAK,say a Tinker,and a medium multi,say a PST or a MP400.
Or buy a Juice

-
I say don't stress over not having 'proper' pliers.
-
At work i carry both,usualy a explorer or craftsman pairedcwith a spirit,general day to day a sak,
it all depends on your needs realy 
-
I used to be an MT only guy. Tried going the SAK only route and found I missed the MT. Now I carry both and find I can choose my SAK to complement the tools on my MT and get a good set of bases covered. Options are good. Carry both!
-
But I want to be complete but light.
Difficult balance! :D
-
Wich tools do you use most often?
Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
-
I EDC a Vic Handyman-Spirit combo in my bag that has worked for me so far.
As much as I like that combo, I don't think I'd like carrying just the Spirit or the Handyman.
Anyway, I consider my true EDC to be the Pioneer-Rambler combo I carry in my pants pockets. Go figure.
@alexTOOL said:
But I want to be complete but light.Difficult balance! :D
91mm Ranger covers a lot of bases.
-
I'm going to jump on the "Both" bandwagon here. I like to combine a smaller sized tool with a mid size tool, one SAK, one LM usually. This is the balance point I've found that works for me. I also keep an MT or two nearby in my car/bag.
Most often carried for me would be Skeletool CX with Vic Manager or modded Cadet. Or Vic Pioneer or Farmer with LM Style PS or Squirt.
-
SAK or Multitool?
BothMy first carry is always a slip joint, then what ever multitool I need or feel like that day.
The Pioneer would be a classic you could carry with a multitool. -
Generally, multiplier and a good knife.
Just a thought, would the SOG Switchpler be an option. Small and has nice pliers and you can trade the tools. If it is a SAK that you are dead set on, then I say a CT34 or 41 and get a good pair of pliers to carry with you when you think you might need one.
That's us mobile.
Nate -
I've carried a multi-tool in the past and it didn't work for me. I've carried a knife based mt for awhile now and always have standalone pliers near by if needed.
-
A Leatherman multitool with outside opening blade. I used to carry a swiss army knife and I'm still fond of them but I can't imagine not carrying a Leatherman by choice.
-
That is a tough call/choice!
For me I like both. I carry a sak as my EDC normally the Explorer but I have recently been trying to carry the Swisschamp or Champ Plus. if I know I am going outdoors for a certain amount of time, then I will add a MT so I have my bases covered with pliers, locking blades and extra tools not on my Explorer in case I may need them.
The MT doesn't have to be on my belt though, it might be just carried in a pack.
-
Just for the record, I think SAK is a multitool in every right, just not plier-based.

As for whether to carry a Plier-based vs Non-Plier based MT, I think it all boils down to whether you need the plier for your EDC and how you plan to carry that tool. If you are a pocket carry person, then probably a non-plier based MT is easier to fit in a pocket.
-
I carry a combo of SAK (either Super Tinker or Explorer) and small keychain size plier based MT (Currently IDL T-10 but I also like the Leatherman Style PS in this role)
I like ALMOST everything about the 91mm SAK line... except their pliers. I tried a Deluxe Tinker and didn't like it. I own a Handyman, but it was inherited. For only fractionally more weight than adding a plier layer to a 91mm SAK, you can get the Leatherman Style PS. And for just a little more than that, you can get the IDL T-10. And the pliers on the T-10 are REALLY solid for being a keychain tool. I'd go so far as to say more robust than the pliers on a Juice. I tuck the T-10 away. It's not 'easy access' but available if I need it. The T-10 also has some smaller scale drivers and such that pair pretty well with a SAK, but I honestly just carry it for the pliers.
Also, as I don't pocket carry, the number of layers on any SAK I might carry is somewhat less important than to some, but I still find 3 to 4 layers about as comfortable as they get.
I, personally, don't find a need for more full-scale pliers on a day to day (or even weekly or monthly) basis. I carry a Wave in a bag in my car, which I'm usually not that far from.
On-person, the smaller pliers suit me fine. Understand, that's FOR MY NEEDS. YMMV
-
@Grathr said:
Wich tools do you use most often?Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
Knife (small), scissors (small)... perhaps some screwdriver or plier task (rarely)
Normally I carry a Manager / Minichamp in the keyring and a LM Sidekick clipped to belt
Today changed to Vic Tinker Small and LM Mini Tool
This is a never ending story...!!!

-
Wich tools do you use most often?
Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
Knife (small), scissors (small)... perhaps some screwdriver or plier task (rarely)
Normally I carry a Manager / Minichamp in the keyring and a LM Sidekick clipped to belt
Today changed to Vic Tinker Small and LM Mini Tool
This is a never ending story...!!!


Finding the perfect EDC combo is a never ending story alright. There is always something new or different to try out. :DSent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
-
To me it's like asking shorts, jeans, cargo pants, or suit. It depends on the day.
I have different clothes and footwear options for different days, and I have different pocket tool options too. I go with the circumstances and the mood.
Options are good
-
I also combine.
Vic Explorer and Squirt PS4 for example.
Or Leatherman Juice S2 and Victorinox Midnite Manager are combos I like.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login