Slide lock Strength?
-
The only 111mm knife I have owned is the Soldier 2008, which has a linerlock. I have, however, been looking it other 111mm models that have the older slide lock, such as the Hercules and Helmsman. I have heard that these are prone to the locking bolt of the slide lock failing, resulting in the knife closing and causing injury. I do know that the Rescue Tool and all military issued models are equipped with linerlocks because the slide lock was not up to the standards required.
How is the strength on the slide lock?
-
The liner lock is much stronger than the slide lock.
I dont have numbers on it, but just by design alone its obvious. The slide lock, locks by a little metal tab stuck into that plastic thumb button, mounted on plastic scales. No way that is anywhere near as strong as a thick liner lock.

-
Thanks for the insight, Syph... :)
I haven´t known about the mechanism how it works exactely.But I have carried a Vic Rucksack frequently as my EDC knife. It never failed or let me down.
It makes sense that the liner lock is stronger as the locking bar itself is a massive sheet of metal that is in front of the tang. While the slide lock is just a little metal notch. But on usual uses, i. e. no abusement of the tool I doubt you will see a big difference. Only thing I could imagina is when the slide lock gets very dirty it could faile due to this. On linerlocks this problem will just hardly appear.
I´m a tool user and no abuser - so I can handle all these little things with the right tool. A knife blade is for cutting and not for prying or choping or batoning or things (nonsense?) like this.
-
Vic has given us the rating of the slide lock:
To stay in the elastic region a torque of maximum 10,8Nm should not be exceeded.
Copied from http://sakwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Locking+Systems
So, translating to force applied approx 10 cm from the axis, we get: 10.8 Nm / .1 m = 108 N, or the force exerted by a mass of (108 / 9.81 = ...) 11 kg at 1 G. Critical failure would require quite a lot more.
In other words, it's safety measure, not something meant for batoning or stuff like that. Which is what it says on the box. :)
-
Under normal use no properly made lock should fail anyways. You never apply pressure to the spine of any blade when it's used for its intended purpose. Batoning a SAK might work for a little while, but sooner rather than later, the backspring will bend and fail. I've seen it happen in videos when people try to do this. In some cases, the backspring failed on the very first piece of wood.
-
@Humppa said:
Thanks for the insight, Syph... :)
I haven´t known about the mechanism how it works exactely.But I have carried a Vic Rucksack frequently as my EDC knife. It never failed or let me down.
It makes sense that the liner lock is stronger as the locking bar itself is a massive sheet of metal that is in front of the tang. While the slide lock is just a little metal notch. But on usual uses, i. e. no abusement of the tool I doubt you will see a big difference. Only thing I could imagina is when the slide lock gets very dirty it could faile due to this. On linerlocks this problem will just hardly appear.
I´m a tool user and no abuser - so I can handle all these little things with the right tool. A knife blade is for cutting and not for prying or choping or batoning or things (nonsense?) like this.
+1 I've not had a problem with a side lock.
-
For me, any folding blade locking mechanism is just an added safety - I never depend on them even though I've never had a linerlock or lockback fail on me. IMHO, when in doubt about a blade lock, use a fixed blade - it will never close on your fingers.
Rich -
The sliding lock works great, and I even removed it on my Picknicker, and it still works great as a slipjoint. I understand that 111mm is a larger sized blade but I would never apply excessive force on it
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login