Spirit/swisstool philips overrated?
-
Just did some work at home hanging some new paintings and a small shelf to the walls. After ten or so screws using swisstool the phillips screwdriver started giving up twisting almost 45 degrees. I know the steel is on the softer side, but the work was pretty light too. How long will it take to lose its integrity as whole? Seems pretty weak to me as on my other, even cheaper tools this hasnt been this bad even after harsh use, not even SOG Paratools driver. Maybe my swisstools steel is somehow weaker than it should be?
-
@Padre said:
Just did some work at home hanging some new paintings and a small shelf to the walls. After ten or so screws using swisstool the phillips screwdriver started giving up twisting almost 45 degrees. I know the steel is on the softer side, but the work was pretty light too. How long will it take to lose its integrity as whole? Seems pretty weak to me as on my other, even cheaper tools this hasnt been this bad even after harsh use, not even SOG Paratools driver. Maybe my swisstools steel is somehow weaker than it should be?Do you have pics of that almost 45 degree twist? That is unusual and you should notify Victorinox for Warranty Repair/Replacement.

-
Light work should not deform the Swisstool (or Spirit) phillips. I have the strength of 10 normal men, and don't think I could deform the phillips if I tried. As a general rule, the screw will strip out first.
-
Even if they had somehow completely skipped the heat treatment, I expect you'd still twist the head off the screw before twisting the Phillips. What if the rivet failed though? Maybe the Phillips could twist within the body of the tool. Pictures needed I think.
-
that is very unusual. i've used the one on my spirit to disassemble a car
-
@powernoodle said:
Light work should not deform the Swisstool (or Spirit) phillips. I have the strength of 10 normal men, and don't think I could deform the phillips if I tried. As a general rule, the screw will strip out first.Speak for you.
With only one of my hands strength I can twist and untwist my SwissTool phillips driver easiliy...
-
I made the same experience with the Swisstool and the Spirit philips. Not a fan of that part of the tool anymore. They really seem to be on the softer side. When did you buy your tool? Maybe we have got the bad ones as not every tool user is reporting about that problem.
But it was as it has been and I was asking Vic for warranty and described the problem. They told me it would cost me 17.00 € just for some spa treatment and replacing defect parts. That was enough and my Spirit didn´t leave the drawer since then.
I recommend LM tools - on the soft side as well. But their warranty is for free and they do a great job.
On the other hand - no 91mm or 93mm SAK let me ever down. So Vic is still one of best cutleries, IMO.
-
Think of the reaction we would have shown if this had been some unknown tool made in China... I hope you contact Vic and see what they say, Padre.

-
Light work should not deform the Swisstool (or Spirit) phillips. I have the strength of 10 normal men, and don't think I could deform the phillips if I tried. As a general rule, the screw will strip out first.
Speak for you.
With only one of my hands strength I can twist and untwist my SwissTool phillips driver easiliy...
-edited-
Geeze, what was I thinking? I can't do that anymore....:D
-
Light work should not deform the Swisstool (or Spirit) phillips. I have the strength of 10 normal men, and don't think I could deform the phillips if I tried. As a general rule, the screw will strip out first.
Speak for you.
With only one of my hands strength I can twist and untwist my SwissTool phillips driver easiliy...
-edited-
Geeze, what was I thinking? I can't do that anymore....:D
lol, you truly are faster than speeding BS!

lightning editing, very impressive

and as for what you edited, I'm willing to bet real money that you still can!

-
Honestly SG, I deleted a whole post the other day, my droll sense of humor...


-
This definitely has never happened to me. The screw would strip before the driver bent. There must be some defect in your tool, I hope Vic will honor the warranty and send you a new one!
-
I personally never want to use the original drivers on the tool if I have something else. Such as the MP600 bit kit and so on. I know I can be really hard on that and just get new bits for 1-2 bucks when they wear out. Wear out the tools original drivers and you're SOL.
-
My Spirit RT has been used HARD over the years, and has never given me a hint of trouble.
-
I remember one guy back from my roadie days saying that his Swisstool also bent so he switched to a Powerlock. On the other hand I shouldn't start with LM experiences in those days
-
Maybe it's possible to give a slite twist to the side of the flat blade but I highly doubt you could twist the Phillips iv undone 50mm wood screws several times at work with mine and even ( don't read Swiss tool lovers ) hit my Swiss tool with another set of pliers to start the head of the screw before turning it in
Sent from my XT1092 using Tapatalk
-
@ljnoble said:
Maybe it's possible to give a slite twist to the side of the flat blade but I highly doubt you could twist the Phillips iv undone 50mm wood screws several times at work with mine and even ( don't read Swiss tool lovers ) hit my Swiss tool with another set of pliers to start the head of the screw before turning it inSent from my XT1092 using Tapatalk
My RT has been used as a hammer too many times to count, with barely a blemish. :)
-
Light work should not deform the Swisstool (or Spirit) phillips. I have the strength of 10 normal men, and don't think I could deform the phillips if I tried. As a general rule, the screw will strip out first.
Speak for you.
With only one of my hands strength I can twist and untwist my SwissTool phillips driver easiliy...
-edited-
Geeze, what was I thinking? I can't do that anymore....:D
lol, you truly are faster than speeding BS!

lightning editing, very impressive

and as for what you edited, I'm willing to bet real money that you still can!

It was clever when I wrote it but then it dawned on me...not only was it sexist but I was lying as well..

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

