Multitool help
-
ST300 is probably a good choice for you!
Do you have a chance to try one before buying?
Just hold it for a while and see if its too heavy.I think that for heavy duty Leatherman ST300 overlaps every other tool right now and also better for wallet.
You can get the "removable bit driver" for ST300 also and its really handy.Victorinox has Swisstool in its lineup, it has better construction than ST300, but is much more expensive too.
Also if ST300 feels too heavy (shouldnt be with belt carry, unless you have small frame), consider Leatherman Rebar, it is basically the same than ST300, but in a shrinking machine. Takes the same removable bit driver too.
About Surge: It is even heavier than ST300 and its main point is outside tools, but it doesn't feel as manly as ST300. Not a bad choice either, but swapping blades and such are just finicky.
-
I love my ST300, and it's a very tough MT! It has a great tool set, and the tools pull out easily.
I also love my MP600. It's a tank, and will take any abuse you throw at it. I just don't like how it's a bit more difficult to access the inside tools.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Welcome to the forum. ST300 is a great choice. I prefer the Swisstool. You get the same capability with better fit and finish in a lighter package and outside accessible tools. After having both, I would always go for the Swisstool. Neither is bad, so to solve the dilemma.....get both
seriously once you get them both in hand it will all make sense. Good hunting 
-
I use the Phillips tip often and the added length of the tool helps in many situations with out need for the bit adapter (which I have got yet[emoji39])
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Man so many great responses. It's actually making my decision that much harder ha.
I may buy a surge off amazon because someone is offering a ST300 on offer up for 20 dollars which seems hard to pass up.
-
You really can't go wrong with either of them.
Is the Surge worth more money? I feel it is, at least some more money. Lots more? Well, maybe not. If the ST300 is significantly cheaper then that's great too, and a serious factor in its benefit.
Years ago I was buying a VW and the salesman kept pushing me, as they do. I pushed back because I'm not an idiot, and I kept saying things like "Mazda was going to do this for that parice" to which I think I finally annoyed him enough that he responded with "Yes, but don't you agree this is a better car than the Mazda? Isn't that worth the extra money?"
I responded "Indeed it is, but at the end of the day there's only so many dollars to go around, and a Mercedes would be an even better car if money wasn't an issue."
Keeping that in mind, the Surge might be worth about $20 extra over the ST300, but probably not much more.
Def
-
Get both. Then do a review[emoji106]
-
G'Day
I had both for a while. I got the ST300 as a warranty replacement. I found that with average size paws it was a little to wide for my liking when the pliers were deployed. I got a Surge not long after and love it. I fact I have two Surges. The ST300 got gifted to a mate who like and use it a lot.
For my requirements I find the Surge a better tool. It can take a lot of punishment. Plus the outside scissors are fantastic.Both are good tools.
Pete
-
I personally use the wave at work. No need to carry bit cards and extensions when I got a toolbox full of tools.
At home I use a ST 300 or Wave or whatever I grab. In and around town I use a SAK. When I go camping or to the beach or fishing its the Old surge. They all got theire place.
-
Ok. That was bit reckless
-
If budget is a concern, the ST300 is indeed usually a lot cheaper than the Surge. I don't have a ST300, but a lot of guys swear by them, and I definitely like my Rebar, which is roughly the same in form.
I have a Surge, and it's really an exceptional tool. It has pretty much everything you could need, and the build quality on mine is stellar. However, it is huge and pretty expensive. It's such a heavy duty tool, I am considering selling mine to someone with more hardcore MT needs than myself.I would also vouch for the Gerber MP600. Either the Pro Scout or the blunt nose, if you don't have a specific need for needle nose pliers.
-
I should have also mentioned my SwissTool. For fit and finish, you will not find a better MT, I guarantee it!!
All the tools are top notch, and it has what I consider to be the best tool load out. The only problem I have with it is the small cutters on the pliers. They cut very well, but they're too small. The ST300 has perfect sized cutters.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
So I found a way to get both

I picked up a brand new surge today with a gift card and sale.
And I'm in the process of getting a used ST300 for 20 dollars.
I will try and do a write up onorth both and comparison but gotta say if the ST feels similar ( or better as said by some) I'm gonna love both.
Initial playing around tho and I realize the scissors on the surge don't cut much.. barely touched the package it came in... ?
-
Everyone has the right idea. St3 or the Surge. Both have their own advantages. You can't go wrong with either.
But, one thing to note is the surge you can't carry (on the tool) both the file and saw simultaneous, which is a drawback imo.
-
@35se said:
So I found a way to get both
I picked up a brand new surge today with a gift card and sale.
And I'm in the process of getting a used ST300 for 20 dollars.
I will try and do a write up onorth both and comparison but gotta say if the ST feels similar ( or better as said by some) I'm gonna love both.
Initial playing around tho and I realize the scissors on the surge don't cut much.. barely touched the package it came in... ?
My experience with the Surge's scissors has been entirely positive. They're sharp, precise, and very strong. Hopefully you didn't get a lemon... Are you a lefty by any chance?
-
@WoodsDuck said:
My experience with the Surge's scissors has been entirely positive. They're sharp, precise, and very strong. Hopefully you didn't get a lemon... Are you a lefty by any chance?Mine too, I have never had any issues with a Surge scissors, and I use mine a lot. Best cutter for cable ties. I am a lefty too.

Pete
-
Not a lefty. And hopefully I didn't get a bad one. I will continue to test it out and hopefully do a video review soon.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
:D