Tinker or Tinker Small?
-
The can opener SD doesn't fit down into a recessed hole. My most common use for phillips driver is bicycle derailleur adjustment and guitar strap buttons. I use either the inline phillips on an Explorer or the can opener tip for the bikes (since its right up against the bike frame and a backside tool would be a hassle to turn), and either the IL phillips or backside phillips on the guitars so it can get down into the hole of the strap button (maybe 1.5cm depth). So I would have a use for both.
For small electronics, battery covers, control panels I usually use a smaller driver, as found on 58mm bottle opener, cybertool, 111mm scissors layer. (I'm just using a regular screwdriver usually)
I've got a tinker small, an old vintage 84mm one with the "squared" driver as well as a transparent topaz 91mm one. Both are good. Do you want a longer main blade? Do you prefer smaller size in your pocket?
My Tinker Small has no keyring tab, so its good to slip in and out of pockets. (Being a vintage one I dont actually carry it though). For use I'd prefer the modern rounded driver anyway.
The other difference is the size of the openners. Sometimes I prefer the slightly smaller ones actually. Still a 2 layer 91mm is plenty small for pocket carry.
Both are pretty good in this case I'd say.
I'm such a fan of the scissors that I'm more into the Super Tinker or a custom/vintage 84mm with scissors.
-
@powernoodle said:
The best of all worlds for me is an inline phillips plus the tiny phillips found on the Manager.+1 I really wish the smaller phillips was available on 91mm aside from the Cybertool. I like the 111mm one, plenty of reach with that one.
-
The longer large blade of the 91mm knives is a little more useful than that on the 84mm, and the slightly beefier screwdrivers feel a bit more robust. But I love 'em both.
-
I have the Tinker, but after carrying the Wenger Highlander I really think a Tinker Small would be awesome. I just like the way the 84's carry.
-
I'm a fan of the 84mm format so my vote is for the Small. In fact that's exactly what I did when I faced the same choice. :D
-
I'd pick a small one too.
As for the idea of trying to turn philips screws with a tin opener... this may be possible but it's a pretty terrible idea. The best way to turn a philips head screw is to use a philips head screwdriver - and generally speaking a real screwdriver is going to be a better bet than anything you can find on a SAK. But the backside philips is a great thing to have in your pocket when the occasion arises. Just don't try to build an entire kitchen with it...
-
-
Just don't try to build an entire kitchen with it...
Or do try!
Correct me if i'm wrong but that knife doesn't look Swiss to me

-
Incredible!
"He laid bricks by troweling mortar with the knife’s largest blade, he cut lumber with its mini-saw and hammered nails with the butt of the handle…”
If he can do all that with a $2 Chinese knockoff, imagine what he could do with the real thing!

-
@Thunderpants said:
Incredible!"He laid bricks by troweling mortar with the knife’s largest blade, he cut lumber with its mini-saw and hammered nails with the butt of the handle…”
If he can do all that with a $2 Chinese knockoff, imagine what he could do with the real thing!


I feel like anything built in the desert requires the safari or desert camo SAK.
I'd like to see this knife of his after hammering all the nails with it. Those poor liners.
-
Interesting question because I've had a Tinker Small for 25 years or do and it's never occurred to me that the larger version might be more useful.
I wouldn't dream of using the can opener blade on a Phillips or Pozi screw unless the need was urgent. The Tinker Phillips works well with the stubby, lean in, torquey grip you can get on an open screw. So for me it adds a Phillips - not improve the other one.
While looking at knives for a project this week I struggled to find a Tinker at a good price, but a Hiker (with wood saw) showed up at a very reasonable price, and if you think you might ever want a saw on there then that may be a good value choice.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
