Monoculars?
-
@gregozedobe said:
This thread is a good start, but a search of this site for monoculars will find heaps more threads that will probably be worth researching ..../post/1385410
Oops - should have searched before posting! Thanks for this, will check it out.
@Steinar said:
Some benevolent highjacking for my own purposes. ;) I assume original poster is able to highjack it back, and I hope kkokkolis can answer for both sets of requirements. :):D
Same answers for me, except that I'd be interested in short focus too...
-
I'll try to post my opinion, but, plese, give me time, I'm in the middle of a workweek.
-
@kkokkolis said:
I'll try to post my opinion, but, plese, give me time, I'm in the middle of a workweek.No problem, no rush for answers! Thanks for your help kkokkolis

-
I'll try to post my opinion, but, plese, give me time, I'm in the middle of a workweek.
No problem, no rush for answers! Thanks for your help kkokkolis


-
Note that most cheap monoculars CAN'T be used with glasses (or can be used only with flat lenses wich are close to the eye).
Good eye relief costs.
That restricts options a lot.
BUT, if you only have myopia or hypermetriopia, or presbyopia and NO ASTIGMATISM, you can take off (or move a bit) your glasses and observe with medium/short eye relief monoculars.
THAT SAVES MONEY!
And I know of (and heavily use) a smallish Nikon binocular that has lots of eye relief and costs (from the Netherlands) less than the best binoculars from Zeiss, Leica, Nikon and Vixen.
If you aren't one eyed or a cyclops, you probably can use a binocular.
-
Thanks for the tips! The two sets binoculars I've used in the recent past have not been good for me - I cannot seem to focus with or without my glasses (note - I am extremely short sighted - if i lost/broke my glasses when out of the house i would be without a hope!) and after using the second set for a few minutes a couple of weeks ago, i started to get a tremendous headache.
I tried a cheap monocular recently and after shifting/moving my glasses closer to my eye than normal, i could see much better than the binoculars I have used previously. That's the reason I was after a monoc instead of a binoc... but maybe i've just had bad luck with binoculars.
-
I'll start from the tops. When you see a price you can pay, stop there.
Leica Monocular Monovid 8x20
405 euros
I used it as a binocular (Leica Ultravid 8x20). It is essentialy half that binocular.
Just excellent. It has short focus with an additional lens. Lovelly but pricey. Lots of eye relief, you can use it even with the thickest eyeglasses. Apparent field of view is 50 degrees (call it medium). Quality is too of the tops.
http://www.astroshop.eu/leica-monocular-monovid-8x20/p,16489

-
Vixen 6x21 ED
399€
Equal to the Leica in every respect, but easier to stabilize, because of less magnification, 6x vs 8x. Better at night because of greater exit pupil. Equal apparent field of view, greater true FOV. For the money I would get the Leica. Haven't used it yet (a friend of mine has it, so I will eventually).
http://www.astroshop.eu/vixen-monocular-6x21-ed-monokular/p,44035#tab_bar_1_select

-
Nikon High Grade 7x15
314€
Nikon High Grade 5x15
296€
We are talking about ease of use here. Easy focusing. Less AFOV, 44 degrees. Less aperture. I wouldn't use it for birding or astronomy, but it is great for the urban explorer (roadsigns, museums, monuments etc). Good close focus. They are more of a gadget than traditional monoculars. Expensive.
http://www.astroshop.eu/nikon-monocular-high-grade-7x15/p,13588#tab_bar_1_select
http://www.astroshop.eu/nikon-monocular-high-grade-5x15/p,5292

-
Zeiss 8x20 T*
297€
Great in every respect, equal or better to all of the above. Similar to the Leica but 100€ cheaper. I wouldn't buy any of the above because this exists. Smaller Zeiss (that follow) add gadgetry factor, but this is the overall best buy monocular.
http://www.astroshop.eu/zeiss-monocular-mono-8x20-t*/p,5244#tab_bar_1_select

-
Zeiss 6x18 T*
279€
Zeiss 4x12 T*
266€
These are similar to the Nikon High Grades, but better (and cheaper). Used the 6x18 and loved it. It has less AFOV, 40 degrees, but a very easy focusing (telescopic, push in/out) and great short focus, 30cm for the big one and 50cm for the small one (a reall spy monocular). You can look your SAKs, museum excibits, insects etc with short focus, like a microscope from a distance. Great eye relief (as all of the above).
That's the one I would buy.
http://www.astroshop.eu/zeiss-monocular-mono-6x18-t*/p,5243#tab_bar_1_select
http://www.astroshop.eu/zeiss-binoculars-mono-4x12-t*/p,5242#tab_bar_1_select
-
Zeiss MiniQuick 5x10 T*
179€
That's not a full monocular. It's short of a toy for somebody who has 2-3 other optics and wants something to play with. An expensive toy which is darker than the above and with claustrophobic AFOV (less than 30 degrees). Bad short focus. I would skip it.
http://www.astroshop.eu/zeiss-monocular-miniquick-5x10-t*/p,5241#tab_bar_1_select

-
These where the Alphas. We will discuss the second market segment tomorrow (I call them Betas, because I'm a Greek and I know the second letter of our Alphabet), where we will find those that mortals can afford and they are still very good.
-
Minox Macroscope MS 8x25
179€
The first porro after many roofs, this monocular has equal optics quality at a lower price, because it costs less to build a porro and you avoid the need for expensive phase coatings. Minox is the maker of the famous spy camera. This one has excellent short focus, 30cm as the Zeiss 6x18,and an equal exit pupil. But it is brighter (aperture 25mm). Also bigger, without being really big. Eye relief is OK, but not that great. I would buy that (in fact I think I will).
http://www.astroshop.eu/m.../p,12597#tab_bar_1_select

-
I mis read the title. Oh man I was really wanting this thread to be about monocles!

carry on :D -
Docter Mono 8x21 C
170€
Now, this is a legend. It was first sold by Zeiss, a whole century ago, as Zeiss Turmon. There are many copies (some at a ridiculus price, Russians are better than Chinese, but none as good as the German thing), but this is the real thing, since Docter is the former Carl Zeiss Jenna (the Zeiss of East Germany). So it costs. But it delivers. I have it and love it.
It is a porro. It is incredibly small. It fits inside your hand, so you may observe stealthy (Stasi agents used it to spy). It uses additional lenses that make it a really powerful microscope (Turmon had a stand, but you can make one from a plastic container). It unfolds to a flat piece that fits everywhere.Inly drawback: bad eye relief. One should use it without eyeglasses. If you don't have astigmatism, you can do it.
http://www.astroshop.eu/d...-mono-8x21-c-grey/p,11532

-
Vixen 8x20
157 €
Vixen 6x16
150€
Vixen 4x12
139€
The "cheap" Vixens (Vixen is reknown Japanese maker of excellent optics) are similar to the Zeiss monoculars, but lack the ED glass and phase coatings (I'm not sure about that, that's an assumption from their price). They also use cheaper Bk 7 glass. They use a 3x acrylic stand that triples their magnification and adds shortfocus. Very good overall, the small one is incredibly small. At this price I chose the Docter (or would go with the Minix Macroscope otherwise) because it sure has better optics. Still they are better from what follows.
All Vixens are 50% cheaper in the US, something not always true for German Optics (Leica, Zeiss, Minox).
http://www.astroshop.eu/vixen-monocular-monokular-8x20/p,5603#tab_bar_1_select
http://www.astroshop.eu/vixen-monocular-monokular-6x16/p,5602
http://www.astroshop.eu/vixen-monocular-monokular-4x12/p,5600

-
The 42s
Minox MD 7x42
149€
Celestron Cavalry 8x42
129€
Celestron Oceana 8x42
109€
Bresser Nautic 8x42
109€
And others of lesser quality.
These are BIG. They also have special use. Most have integrated compass/rangefinder, for nautical and shooting sports. OK quality for most of them over 100€. I won't cover them since they aren't intended for country or urban hiking. Just see how they look.

-
The spy monoculars
Eschenbach Club M 8x16
129€
Minox MD 8x16
109€
Minox MD 6x16
99€
Vixen 6x16
79€
These are "spy" monoculars of small size. Most have small eye relief, easy focusing, short focus of 1-1.5 meters. Similar to the Nikons High Grades, which are better. But these are still far better than many Chinese copies. For a spy Monocular I would choose the Docter for better quality but these gadgets are easier to use. Better for indoor use (museums, opera etc). I trust Minox more than Eschenbach.
http://www.astroshop.eu/eschenbach-monocular-club-m-8x16/p,1797#tab_bar_1_select
http://www.astroshop.eu/minox-monocular-md-8x16/p,5140#tab_bar_1_select

-
Opticron 8x20 & 4x12 Macrofocus
89€
The bottom monocular pricewise I would choose. Very good shortfocus. Mediocre eye relief, but usable. Some reflections. I have mine in the car permanently. There is a boisting stand, similar to the Vixen's, that I don't have.
http://www.opticron.co.uk/Pages/gallery_scope.htm

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login