Which El DC?
-
I gotta say I don't understand what seems like a fanatical devotion to scissors exhibited by so many here. The overlap in functionality with a knife is so wide. Sure they can be handy to trim an errant hair or thread but that is easily accomplished with the scissors on your 58mm Vic. Whereas a saw expands your capabilities tremendously. Go with the Farmer

-
@theonew said:
I gotta say I don't understand what seems like a fanatical devotion to scissors exhibited by so many here. The overlap in functionality with a knife is so wide. Sure they can be handy to trim an errant hair or thread but that is easily accomplished with the scissors on your 58mm Vic. Whereas a saw expands your capabilities tremendously. Go with the Farmer
I struggle to understand the almost fanatical devotion to the saw ... :P >:D
Point taken, but for me the scissors are probably the most used tool. Yes, on some of the tasks I could probably get by with a knife, but I don't have to - I've got scissors :D
I very rarely have need for a saw, and most of my Swiss knives don't have them, whereas I'll use scissors several times a week.
-
It all comes back to a dream I had when I was EDCing a Climber. I was drugged and kidnapped and placed in a plywood box and as I was trying to cut my way out with the knife, rather than a saw, I didn't make it in time and got shipped overseas :D
-
@theonew said:
It all comes back to a dream I had when I was EDCing a Climber. I was drugged and kidnapped and placed in a plywood box and as I was trying to cut my way out with the knife, rather than a saw, I didn't make it in time and got shipped overseas :DWell... if the plywood box had some fireworks pyro in it too you would be ok. Mac got in a situation like that once, all he needed was a bit of gunpowder from a firecracker, the can opener from hid trusty Tinker to pry his watch crystal in order to ignite the gunpowder using it as a mag glass with sunlight though a whole on the box and blow up the side of the box. He got out in time before he got shipped overseas :D no saw requierd...


-
Climber Plus has most things covered most of the time for me, if I absolutely had to choose only one, that would be it (even though I have several of those to choose from ;) ), that's my vote.

-
Thank you all for the input! This list of SAKs raises all kinds of points, arguments, and philosophies... I hope some more people vote.
-
Inspired by true events:
-
So what you're saying is that for you there is no wrong answer ... in which case it doesn't matter. Pick any one at random, and carry it for a couple of weeks. Make note of what annoys you, or times when you needed something that the tool didn't offer. If life does chuck such a lesson at you, heed it and switch to a knife that reflects the lessons learned so far.
When you eventually end up torn between just the Compact or Climber Plus, remember to say "you were right, Al" :D
-
@50ft-trad said:
So what you're saying is that for you there is no wrong answer ... in which case it doesn't matter. Pick any one at random, and carry it for a couple of weeks. Make note of what annoys you, or times when you needed something that the tool didn't offer. If life does chuck such a lesson at you, heed it and switch to a knife that reflects the lessons learned so far.When you eventually end up torn between just the Compact or Climber Plus, remember to say "you were right, Al" :D
Or you could just start carrying the Climber and be done wih it. ;)
-
@50ft-trad said:
So what you're saying is that for you there is no wrong answer ... in which case it doesn't matter. Pick any one at random, and carry it for a couple of weeks. Make note of what annoys you, or times when you needed something that the tool didn't offer. If life does chuck such a lesson at you, heed it and switch to a knife that reflects the lessons learned so far.
When you eventually end up torn between just the Compact or Climber Plus, remember to say "you were right, Al" :D
Or you could just start carrying the Climber and be done wih it. ;)
That works too

:D
-
You just might find yourself coming full circle so in the mean time experiment a little. I say carry the Climber for a month as you say. Take mental notes during that month. Next up carry the Explorer and so on.
What you might find is surprising.
Early on I carried a Wenger S10. I was really partial to the corkscrew at that time. Later I was lured into getting an Explorer and scored a Plus version. I carried it for quite some time till my Swisschamp came along. The SC and Explorer fought it out for pocket time for months. I had somewhat of a "system" in deciding which I'd carry but whimsy usually made the decision.
I then got my first Alox ( Farmer I think ) and understood what this Alox Pox was all about. I carried that for a little bit.
When I got "into" SAKs like many I had to try as many as I could all the while noting my likes and perceived needs. Let me also say it was early on that I attached a 58mm Manager onto my keys. I did have a short but wonderful relationship with a Minichamp but the Manager made more sense.
Ok fast forward to now. I now carry a 84mm Tinker plus my trusty 58mm Manager. I went thru a lot of turmoil about SAK scissors. I knew having them was better than not having them. I thought I had to have them on my 91mm or 84mm ( I have a Golfer ) but I was wrong. My trusty 58mm Manager is more than capable.
The only tool I lost in this journey is the corkscrew. I took a while to rationalize not having it but for my purposes it made sense.
Does this all mean I have abandoned my Explorer Plus? Or my Swisschamp? Not in the least. As a matter of fact I make it a point to carry either as well as a Cadet 2 whenever I fancy. What I don't do anymore is debate what I carry as I am leaving for the day. My 84mm Tinker and 58mm Manager have me covered.
Good luck and enjoy the journey.
-
@50ft-trad said:
@50ft-trad said:
So what you're saying is that for you there is no wrong answer ... in which case it doesn't matter. Pick any one at random, and carry it for a couple of weeks. Make note of what annoys you, or times when you needed something that the tool didn't offer. If life does chuck such a lesson at you, heed it and switch to a knife that reflects the lessons learned so far.
When you eventually end up torn between just the Compact or Climber Plus, remember to say "you were right, Al" :D
Or you could just start carrying the Climber and be done wih it. ;)
That works too

:D
but but but... alox... saw ....... magnifying glass .... yellow .... birth year.... :D
Yawl are probably right, I went with the SI/manager today and feel good about it being Wenger Wednesday and awl... I hope you guys don't feel like you wasted your time. :D
I
.jpg)
-
New page space pirate banana dance
<a href="http://www.sherv.net/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://www.sherv.net/cm/emo/funny/2/space-pirate-banana-smiley-emoticon.gif" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a><a href="http://www.sherv.net/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://www.sherv.net/cm/emo/funny/2/space-pirate-banana-smiley-emoticon.gif" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a><a href="http://www.sherv.net/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://www.sherv.net/cm/emo/funny/2/space-pirate-banana-smiley-emoticon.gif" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a><a href="http://www.sherv.net/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://www.sherv.net/cm/emo/funny/2/space-pirate-banana-smiley-emoticon.gif" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a><a href="http://www.sherv.net/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://www.sherv.net/cm/emo/funny/2/space-pirate-banana-smiley-emoticon.gif" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
-
Us? :ahhh Waste time wondering what to carry? :ahhh
Seriously though, I find it comes back to the individual tools. In my case, having 2 blades, full size Vic scissors, and proper openers ( the combo tool sucks, lets face it), is not negotiable for any extended carry. The Pioneer X doesn't have the small blade, so I compromise using the awl. The Compact doesn't have the very versatile opener layer, so I swear at the combo tool. The combo carry with a 58mm works, but I often find the tiny scissors and blade lacking. The 4th layers, even the Fisherman feel bulky to me anymore, so while the Explorer Plus is a sweet carry, how often do I need that bulky 4th layer. It's really a no brainer for me anymore, but there has been some experimenting and excessive thought that has gone into it. In the end, if I don't have time to think about it, the Climber is an easy choice (boring perhaps, but easy), and the extra tools the Climber has only enhance it's versatility.

Again, this is just me, YMMV.

-
@twiliter said:
Us? :ahhh Waste time wondering what to carry? :ahhhSeriously though, I find it comes back to the individual tools. In my case, having 2 blades, full size Vic scissors, and proper openers ( the combo tool sucks, lets face it), is not negotiable for any extended carry. The Pioneer X doesn't have the small blade, so I compromise using the awl. The Compact doesn't have the very versatile opener layer, so I swear at the combo tool. The combo carry with a 58mm works, but I often find the tiny scissors and blade lacking. The 4th layers, even the Fisherman feel bulky to me anymore, so while the Explorer Plus is a sweet carry, how often do I need that bulky 4th layer. It's really a no brainer for me anymore, but there has been some experimenting and excessive thought that has gone into it. In the end, if I don't have time to think about it, the Climber is an easy choice (boring perhaps, but easy), and the extra tools the Climber has only enhance it's versatility.

Again, this is just me, YMMV.

Awl you said makes sense.

@50ft-trad said:
So what you're saying is that for you there is no wrong answer ... in which case it doesn't matter. Pick any one at random, and carry it for a couple of weeks. Make note of what annoys you, or times when you needed something that the tool didn't offer. If life does chuck such a lesson at you, heed it and switch to a knife that reflects the lessons learned so far.When you eventually end up torn between just the Compact or Climber Plus, remember to say "you were right, Al" :D
Yes, No, it doesn't matter. But it means everything. I like your suggestion and I think it will be helpful. Numbers from a hat type of sitch so I don't psych myself out... Don't know if I've mentioned, but I work in psychology so, I probably spend too much time thinking about the psychological constructs and implications of my daily SAK choice
. Cutting out this daily process could allow me to have more free time, less stress/indecision, and give me a better perspective of what I truly want to carry with me each day.The Compact is currently winning... with the BY SAK, Climber Plus, and Pikachu close behind.
Keep the votes coming!

-
@El Corkscrew said:
Us? :ahhh Waste time wondering what to carry? :ahhh
Seriously though, I find it comes back to the individual tools. In my case, having 2 blades, full size Vic scissors, and proper openers ( the combo tool sucks, lets face it), is not negotiable for any extended carry. The Pioneer X doesn't have the small blade, so I compromise using the awl. The Compact doesn't have the very versatile opener layer, so I swear at the combo tool. The combo carry with a 58mm works, but I often find the tiny scissors and blade lacking. The 4th layers, even the Fisherman feel bulky to me anymore, so while the Explorer Plus is a sweet carry, how often do I need that bulky 4th layer. It's really a no brainer for me anymore, but there has been some experimenting and excessive thought that has gone into it. In the end, if I don't have time to think about it, the Climber is an easy choice (boring perhaps, but easy), and the extra tools the Climber has only enhance it's versatility.

Again, this is just me, YMMV.

Awl you said makes sense.

@50ft-trad said:
So what you're saying is that for you there is no wrong answer ... in which case it doesn't matter. Pick any one at random, and carry it for a couple of weeks. Make note of what annoys you, or times when you needed something that the tool didn't offer. If life does chuck such a lesson at you, heed it and switch to a knife that reflects the lessons learned so far.When you eventually end up torn between just the Compact or Climber Plus, remember to say "you were right, Al" :D
Yes, No, it doesn't matter. But it means everything. I like your suggestion and I think it will be helpful. Numbers from a hat type of sitch so I don't psych myself out... Don't know if I've mentioned, but I work in psychology so, I probably spend too much time thinking about the psychological constructs and implications of my daily SAK choice
. Cutting out this daily process could allow me to have more free time, less stress/indecision, and give me a better perspective of what I truly want to carry with me each day.The Compact is currently winning... with the BY SAK, Climber Plus, and Pikachu close behind.
Keep the votes coming!

What type of psychology? I did two years training in hypnopsychotherapy, and while it was very interesting, the client work I did taught me that I wasn't ready to have people bringing their problems to me everyday, so I never pursued the other three years ::) I wasn't very Rogerian in my methods either :P Person Centered was a bit timid for me (I disagree that everyone knows what the underlying problem is), and I preferred the more dynamic approaches. I may revisit it again at some point in the future.
There's only so much worthwhile analysis that you can do before you put your theories to trial, and that's where the fun lies. I would suggest keeping the Manager as a constant companion throughout the journey, but wherever possible, don't use it. For many people the Manager would handle the bulk of their needs, so it's a good back up to have while you're exploring what works best for you on the larger knives. Try to get by with just the "main" knife, and make note of how many times you have to fall back on the Manager, what the reason was, and how much of a PITA it would have been if you didn't have anything to get you out of the mire.
You may well end up with a different conclusion to me, because we walk different paths in life, but having the Manager there as back up will take a lot of headache out of the journey.
Above all, enjoy it - Swiss knives are supposed to make your life easier. If you're getting all stressed out and flustered about the "what ifs", you're doing it wrong :D
Good luck, and keep us informed

-
I could squeak by with a Signature to be honest. There, I said it. :P
I think it comes down to what I want to carry vs. what dedicated tools I want to have laying around. I have a flashlight laying around, pens, MT's with openers closeby, etc., so what would be handy to have in my pocket depends on that cutoff point. I have also flown with a Jetsetter, and also with no tools on me, so there's that too. Lots of guys carry only a small traditional peanut or folder with nothing but a small blade or 2, but I don't care to hunt around for everything I need when I could have it all in one tool. Also I think a good stand alone works better for me than 2 or more because it cuts out that decision too.

-
I honestly don't mind the combo tool in the urban environment so as far as a stand alone I'm gonna stick by the compact as making the most sense.
I'll tell you what the compact lacks tho... The wicked snap of the OC Pioneer and Soldier. The farmer & soldat have a nice snap, too, but not like those older models.
Snap.
-
@El Corkscrew said:
I honestly don't mind the combo tool in the urban environment so as far as a stand alone I'm gonna stick by the compact as making the most sense.I'll tell you what the compact lacks tho... The wicked snap of the OC Pioneer and Soldier. The farmer & soldat have a nice snap, too, but not like those older models.
Snap.
I use the can opener a lot, and the minimalist challenge showed me that I need to stick with the Pioneer or Spartan because of that. Also, the Spartan was better for me because of the small blade which I use a lot also, but I know not everyone does. Sounds to me like you might try a Pioneer X for EDC, nice scissors, rugged, and very, very snappy.

I did try the Compact during the minimalist challenge, and I agree it's great for urban carry if all you need the combo tool for is a caplifter, and you don't use a small blade often. There again this is why the Climber wins for me on a daily basis.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login