Plier cutting test
-
Very valuable, thank you!
-
Here comes the remaining pictures. The cheap nose was a bit middle of the road - it cut the stainless steel rod, but failed paper. The fencing tool really only had edges for small somewhat hard stuff, which it did despite rust. The Knipex universal was less precise than its little brother, but did cut a lot too. And the cheap universal cut less than the more expensive ones - something right in this world after all.




-
Final two - finally! This turned into quite the little project.
The Teng tools cut decent enough, and better than I expected actually.While the Henstrong, also rebranded all over cheap town, actually did a bit less then I would have guessed up front.
Now I just hope Grant won't do things of dubious nature to me for posting so many pictures...



-
Most of these would be able to cut soft stuff with enough tries and chewing, and thus function at some level for that. And there are plenty of perfectly valid use cases that wasn't even in this test because I simply assumed they would all do it with ease. Electrical cables, thin braided rope, strings - things like that. And of course a plier is also about much more than just the cutting.
What was disappointing was the issues with the harder stuff and the tools getting damaged. That means that increasing pressure or chewing would be far less helpful as it would just accelerate the damage as well. And there were three samples causing damages: The lawnmower wire, the electroplated nail, and the thin 316 rod.
The lawn mover wire is of unknown hardness, but most fails there was about it getting stuck sideways in between the jaws. Many tools would have made it with another go or two, and few got damaged. It didn't appear especially hard, then again it did prove a challenge.
The 316 rod on the other hand seemed harder than expected. If the way they manufacture these causes work hardening they might be quite hard on the surface at least. (I didn't have a magnet around so I couldn't test). That said I did cut it in the hard wire slot of the tools that had such.
But that tools got damaged cutting the nail was quite a disappointment. And 1.8mm profile nail is quite small. Now I did choose the square ones instead of round ones just because they would be more difficult. But still, at that size? (If you want a bolt cutter proof chain go for a hard and square profile one).
Anyway, I learned a lot - success!

-
Thanks for doing this test Vidar

So sorry to hear this caused damage to your tools. If nothing else it proves to me personally that manufacturers need to listen up and up their game. little point in bringing out silly colour schemes and exotic designs if they cannot be relied upon to perform simple tasks.
Fact is, its not good enough. if they keep insisting that a multitool as a viable substitute...then I think they need to reassess what they deem to be acceptable quality. because a "toolbox in your pocket" is way off mark. -
I would not use ANY pliers on some of those things... rather a hacksaw blade on my Surge.
-
@Syncop8r said:
I would not use ANY pliers on some of those things... rather a hacksaw blade on my Surge.Personally I hesitated adding the 17-4 flat spring. Being a spring in that material it is hardened. I honestly didn't expect anything to go through that one. The 316 flat spring is also a plier nightmare but more because of the shape than the material.
It is worth noting that only the Knipex end cutter and the Ergo side cutter are general cutters. With the exception of the two flat springs I had no second thoughts about cutting into the rest with these two. And they did great too. All the other normal pliers are more universal plier designs or really intended for softer electric work. Some did quite good nevertheless.
For the multitools it seems like using the hacksaw might be a very good idea for some of these samples.
@tosh said:
So sorry to hear this caused damage to your tools.No reason to be sorry about that. This has been one of the more interesting explorations.

-
Good show Vidar. Thank you for putting all the work into not just the tests, but also the reporting and pics 
This sort of information is invaluable on this forum. Please try to save some of the materials in case you get other tools at a later date, so you can rerun the tests and keep this thread updated.
Thanks again

-
@50ft-trad said:
Good show Vidar. Thank you for putting all the work into not just the tests, but also the reporting and pics 
This sort of information is invaluable on this forum. Please try to save some of the materials in case you get other tools at a later date, so you can rerun the tests and keep this thread updated.
Thanks again

Thanks for the heads up. Hopefully someone finds it useful or informative.
Yes, I got plenty of all those materials. And part of my thinking was also to use some kind of standard materials and sizes that many might have around if they want to try themselves. Hence the TIG materials, zip tie, filament and paper. (Just aim for not-too-great hand strength and you should have perfect test replication! :D )
-
I can add some information if this is going to be a repository of testing. I tried cutting bike brake cable with a Skeletool. It both dented the wire cutters and forced them slightly apart. This week I cut a couple of thicker braided clothes lines, about 2mm thick, with my Charge. It did get through it eventually but with plenty of work. No damage. It is a shame they don't have the thicker cable cutters (at the back of the pliers) from the larger LM tools. I can also report that my Skeletool failed rather badly with Cat6a networking cable. Mainly due to the internal plastic dividers. A friend demonstrated that the Skeletool would cut through regular Cat6 cabling without a problem. Regular electrical power cables have never been a problem with the Skeletool.
-
Strong work

-
Thank you very much for all your hard work. This is terrific information and helps us all when facing certain materials.
-
Interesting article! Thanks for your test!!

-
Very nice test, but it needs to include pliers from Victorinox.
Can anyone attest to what they where able cut with the Vic Spirit? Else than electrical cable and a paperclip, I have not cut anything else with it. -
I'm actually waiting for one of those to turn up in this establishments esteemed webshop - will be happy to try that one too when that happens.
-
Well done and very interesting

I'm curious about the failure of the Dime, Did the tool itself break? If the IDL T10 had enough leverage to cut a few of the items, I can't image the Dime has less leverage
-
@theonew said:
Well done and very interesting
I'm curious about the failure of the Dime, Did the tool itself break? If the IDL T10 had enough leverage to cut a few of the items, I can't image the Dime has less leverage
IDK about the IDL T10, but I broke my purple Dime trying to cut copper wire thinking it'd go through it effortlessly


-
IMO the Dime is garbage. I got one of the originals and the pliers failed cutting some thin, soft wire. It appears to be a design flaw as my LM Squirts, IDL T5 and mini True Utility pliers have handled nearly all the hand strength I can muster. It has really put me off of their brand as they haven't redesigned or discontinued a product that wouldn't stand up to the hand strength of a three year old. Leatherman gets taken to task for certain design issues, like the cuticle poking flat drivers on the Juice (which I consider to be largely user error, as it is simple to come at them with the side of your nail) yet Leatherman tools are generally quite rugged. I've almost pulled the trigger on a bladeless MP600 a few times but my experience with the Dime makes me back off each time. A company which knowingly sells a product with a gross design flaw is not one I want to do business with.
-
@theonew said:
I'm curious about the failure of the Dime, Did the tool itself break? If the IDL T10 had enough leverage to cut a few of the items, I can't image the Dime has less leverage
The dime actually slid apart sideways for some things, and like the IDL didn't have the leverage for the harder things. If you look at the picture you can actually see the center of the plier has moved apart and not come all the way back again.
I really like the Dime concept and the compact design as such. (You can tell it has been used regularly). But the cutting action leaves something to be desired.
-
Interesting, thank you

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login