Axe Handles
-
Maybe they are not very sharp?

Not to criticise a bloke in a checked shirt but I would have the log to be split on the far (to him) side of the block

(I think I learnt that watching Rey Mears
)

Checkmate.
-
I know hickory is meant to be the bee's knees for handles, but could it be possible that the spotted gum is thinner because in can be? Perhaps the hickory is better being a bit thicker, but the SG can get away with it because of its characteristics.
I don't know, just a thought.
-
When you look at guys like Steven from Skillcult (I think that is his name) hickory handles can also be thinned down. There were a good number of pics on the net showing the difference between handle thickness from 60ish years ago and today
-
@Syncop8r said:
I know hickory is meant to be the bee's knees for handles, but could it be possible that the spotted gum is thinner because in can be? Perhaps the hickory is better being a bit thicker, but the SG can get away with it because of its characteristics.
I don't know, just a thought.
Very possible that this is true, I get the impression that an equivalent thickness hickory handle would have more flex than a spotted gum. No idea if this is true. It may also be weaker, but with proper use shouldn't break
-
@styx said:
When you look at guys like Steven from Skillcult (I think that is his name) hickory handles can also be thinned down. There were a good number of pics on the net showing the difference between handle thickness from 60ish years ago and todayI have ordered The Ax Book by Dudley Cook that Steven Edholm says is good. I'm interested to know more. From reviews of axes like the GB SFA, they seem to have thinner handles, but I've never seen one in the flesh. I can understand a handle manufacturer making their handles thicker for sale. There's many benefits I can see for them. Less work, they can make a more rubbish piece of wood into a useable handle with less chance of breaking, less warranty claims from broken handles, and if a customer thins it down and it breaks well that's down to modification and user error, not the handle manufacturer's fault. All equates to more profit but not necessarily a better product
-
When you look at guys like Steven from Skillcult (I think that is his name) hickory handles can also be thinned down. There were a good number of pics on the net showing the difference between handle thickness from 60ish years ago and today
I have ordered The Ax Book by Dudley Cook that Steven Edholm says is good. I'm interested to know more. From reviews of axes like the GB SFA, they seem to have thinner handles, but I've never seen one in the flesh. I can understand a handle manufacturer making their handles thicker for sale. There's many benefits I can see for them. Less work, they can make a more rubbish piece of wood into a useable handle with less chance of breaking, less warranty claims from broken handles, and if a customer thins it down and it breaks well that's down to modification and user error, not the handle manufacturer's fault. All equates to more profit but not necessarily a better product
Well that is very true.
Here is a thought - how much would thinning down a handle change the balance of an axe towards the head. Handles are lighter in comparison to the head, but which amount would be significant enough to change the performance -
When you look at guys like Steven from Skillcult (I think that is his name) hickory handles can also be thinned down. There were a good number of pics on the net showing the difference between handle thickness from 60ish years ago and today
I have ordered The Ax Book by Dudley Cook that Steven Edholm says is good. I'm interested to know more. From reviews of axes like the GB SFA, they seem to have thinner handles, but I've never seen one in the flesh. I can understand a handle manufacturer making their handles thicker for sale. There's many benefits I can see for them. Less work, they can make a more rubbish piece of wood into a useable handle with less chance of breaking, less warranty claims from broken handles, and if a customer thins it down and it breaks well that's down to modification and user error, not the handle manufacturer's fault. All equates to more profit but not necessarily a better product
Well that is very true.
Here is a thought - how much would thinning down a handle change the balance of an axe towards the head. Handles are lighter in comparison to the head, but which amount would be significant enough to change the performanceDepends where you remove most material from. If you took most from closer to the head it would have less effect than taking more from the end, due to the total moment of the handle. Like any lever, the longer it is, the thinner it can be for the same effect of balance vs the head
-
well normally you thin the entire handle down
-
That's where a bigger palm swell / fawns foot or whatever you want to call it can help. It keeps a bit of a lump as far from the head as possible. I think on my Husky the balance point is still back from the head a ways, so can still thin out more material before it becomes head heavy
-
That should be helpful. I wonder where the balance is on the Fiskars
-
Guys I do think too many people overthink this axe thing
So long as one end is heavy and sharp
And the other end is comfortable for as long as we need it to be, we should be good to go
But I do like a slim handle

-
@Sparky415 said:
Guys I do think too many people overthink this axe thing
So long as one end is heavy and sharp
And the other end is comfortable for as long as we need it to be, we should be good to go
But I do like a slim handle

Yeah, ultimately it comes down to individual preference. Take care of anything and it will last a long time
-
A handle for my hatchet will cost about $30NZD and my 3/4 about $34NZD - probably about $21USD and $24USD respectively. >:(
-
I think it's all hickory so I guess that's why.
-
@Syncop8r said:
I think it's all hickory so I guess that's why.Yeah, sounds like it. Two 800mm handles of Hickory, one was $34.50 I think, the other was $28.
I would have preferred a spotted gum at $16.50 but none of them were really decent, unfortunately.
Do you know what NZ rules on wood imports are like? I could probably help you out but shipping might be the killer on cost -
I think it's all hickory so I guess that's why.
Yeah, sounds like it. Two 800mm handles of Hickory, one was $34.50 I think, the other was $28.
I would have preferred a spotted gum at $16.50 but none of them were really decent, unfortunately.
Do you know what NZ rules on wood imports are like? I could probably help you out but shipping might be the killer on costThanks for the offer but yeah I don't think it would be worth it. I don't know if customs would have an issue or not.

I'm keen to try to make my own handles but would need a template for a handle to suit my 2¾ Elwell head. -
@Sparky415 said:
Guys I do think too many people overthink this axe thing
So long as one end is heavy and sharp
And the other end is comfortable for as long as we need it to be, we should be good to go
But I do like a slim handle

Overthinking is a part of the fun. Like thinking which knife is the best or what shelter do you absolutely need or which multitool can do it all. Just so you can go out and figure out that 99% of your hard tasks can be accomplished with a Mora #1 or some other inexpensive equivalent, your basic tarp is ample shelter and a Vic Classic or LM Micra is pretty much overkill for your daily needs
-
Yep I do find these threads very interesting


Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login