Age and Maximum Minimalism.
-
Maximum minimalism.
The ability to carry the absolute minimum of stuff and perform the maximum amount of jobs you can with just that stuff in your pockets. It's something I've been an aficionado of for most of my life. When I was a kid in the Boy Scouts, we had this scout master, Mr. Van. He was an old career Marine that has seen a lot of service in the war in the south Pacific and had some very iron clad beliefs that he passed on to the scouts in his troop. We looked up to him with reverence, and what Mr.Van said was taken as gospel. One was the mantra of minimalism.
Being in the Boy Scouts, and of course carrying a Boy Scout knife that had the usual tools like the Vic pioneer, it was very very easy to get used to having a screw driver and awl and can opener on hand. This set a dangerous habit for the rest of my life in knife carrying. Out of high school I enlisted in the army engineers, and was issued of course, the army version of a scout knife. The habit got ingrained deeper. As life went on and I had to discover ultra light back packing because an old army injury left me with a limp and a bum right foot and ankle, my drive for maximum minimalism kicked into high gear. Small single AAA pocket flashlights instead of the AA mini mag, monoculars instead of compact binoculars, mini Bic lighter instead of the old Zippo, and so on. I wanted the smallest, lightest object that old still do the job, even if it was a bit slower or a little inconvenient. With a 25 pound pack I could still get out on the Appellation Trail for a weekend of quiet.
I went through a period of being a knife nut and trying every new thing that came down the road. But it was always for a while and my default was always back to the scout knife patterns and later SAK's with a few tools. But it had to be small. As I went on in life and had kids, and then even grandkids, I noticed pocket space getting hard to come by. With kids, there always seems a need for clean up, so some crumpled up clean paper towels and small bottle of hand sanitizer was needed. Small emergencies need a bandaid so they were in the wallet. Rubber bands for little girls pony tails, some string for trying up loose ends, Chapstick, all added onto my own stuff like Bic lighter, tobacco pouch and pipe, pocket knife, eye drops for allergy in season, and other stuff that seemed to accumulate as I got older. In late middle age a small inherited cardiac problem became known and a small Bison capsule with some aspirin was needed. Arthritis came to be a fact of life so the aspirin was needed on two counts.
All during knife nut years, which was the 80's and 90's, a lot of knives came and went. Mostly went. I'd try a stockman and carried that for the longest time period, but it too went. Some sodbusters came and went, as did some other stuff. For a few years I even tried the balisongs. A Pacific Cutlery Company all stainless steel one was used and sold of, as was a Hackman balisong. Some Opinels came and went. My Case peanut stage lasted the longest, as I was trying to follow in my dad's footsteps. I grew up watching him carry the the lone little pocket knife and learned a lot of lessons from him. Most of which was, you don't really need much knife to get by in the modern society. I remember him telling me more than a few times, "It doesn't have be big, just sharp."
I noticed after enough years that I was very often carrying two pocket knives. One was my knife nut knife of the month, be it a stockman, sodbuster, peanut, two blade jackknife or something more exotic. The other was a SAK. I'd got my very first SAK in 1969 at a little knife shop in Rothenburg Germany, where I was stationed while serving in the army engineers. A huntsman. It was a great knife and had a very wide mission capability. It could saw, cut, snip, screw, pluck, and more. But it was bulky. It gave way to he tinker, and later a recruit. And somehow a classic joined in the fray. A classic became part of my keyring. After watching my better half torture one for a few months, and it failing to implode, I tried one and found it to be a much more rugged little cutter than I would have thought. And being mounted on the keyring, it freed up a tiny bit of pocket space. And it did 98%of what was needed. I like playing percentages. If theres a 2% chance I'll need a wood chisel, fish scaler, wood saw, metal file, I'll take my chances without.
It was about this period I stopped carrying all the "Other" pocket knives. I did a huge down sizing and after a few downsizes all my pocket knives that were kept were SAK's. Having a SAK as a pocketknife made life a bit easier in a few respects. No more "other" lives taking up space in the pocket and now I could even carry a RONCO pocket defibrillator in case of a real vapor lock. :o I can't count the number of times I've had to fixe something out somewhere to get home. Most times just having a screw driver did the trick to get into it and fiddle something until it worked. The SD tip of the Victorinox can opener makes a darn good Phillips screw driver. I fixed/replaced the clothes dryer door latch with just the SD tip of the classic nail file. Two small Phillips screws on each side of the dryer door and the door came part to get access to the snap in latch.
For about 20 years I was a huge fan of the 58mm SAK's and the basic classic in particular. It was minimalism at it's best. I could open bags of mulch, plastic packaging of all kinds, deal with small Phillips screws, snip work with the scissors and nail file kept things in trim. The tweezers plucked a thorn from between he paw pads of our Welsh Corgi on a woods walk, and splinters from grandkids fingers. The SD tip of the nail file opened many cold brews at the end of the day by using the SD tip of the nail file to just loosen the cap so it could be popped off with thumb. If Needed to deal with real screws or open a can, my old army P-38 was in the zip compartment of my wallet along with a Victorinox quarto 4 way keychain screw driver. These flat little tools take up no space in a wallet.
Now, thanks the Chuck Yeager challenge and Nix, I am a new enthusiastic owner and EDC'er of the Executive. It fits into the life of an old retired man of leisure who loves to fish and kill a fair amount of time on the shooting range. It's compact, light weight, and has enough mission capacity to snip fishing line, trim bait, tighten loose screws on a fishing real, and adjust sights on a firearm. It's been a long strange trip, going from the 93mm, to 91mm, to 84mm to 58mm, and then back up a little to the 74mm as a daily carry. But it's been a lot of fun along the way.
-
I´m glad you had a lot of fun. I´m more of a maximalist, but I can see myself dropping a few items over the next thirty years or so.

-

This should be required reading. :D
Carl, you've inspired me to continue to assess my actual needs and to try to go lighter. I think in the Army they call that "High speed, Low drag." A solid philospohy.

Thanks for the insights. Boy, I'm glad you agreed to join us in the CYC2!

-
Interesting thread title!
I carried the 58mm Classic SD on my keychain for the last 30+ years of my work life. After retirement, I was reminiscing about my grandfather (born in 1880) and how he used his pocket knife for various daily tasks. My mother and I stayed on his 54' boat one summer while she recuperated after caring for my uncle and his two young daughters (his wife/their mother had just died). I loved his boat and he had all he could do to keep me out of the engine room. Unfortunately, the boat was destroyed in a 1954 hurricane (East coast). My mother, new brother and I went to live with my Grandfather while my father was in Korea. In those days, console sized radios were a center for news and entertainment. Happily my grandfather bought a television shortly after we moved in. He was my name-sake and I followed him around constantly, imitating him in his routine. My mom wasn't too happy when he gave me my first knife and she made sure that I didn't get to use it outside of his supervision. In the late 1950s after we moved to California (via Route 66), my grandfather came to live with us and stayed until he died in 1968. He was quite a role model and taught me so much. I am very nostalgic and many of my fond memories are centered around his daily pocket knife routines.
I suppose the Executive qualifies for the minimalist part of this topic title and my status as a pensioner meets the age portion. I do enjoy using my Executive, MiniChamp (attached to car keys) and other SAKs for daily tasks and as I do so I am aware at some level of my grandfather's routines and that I am still very much in touch with the past.
Jim
-
That was a fantastic read, thank you for posting it! I have to wonder if I will go through similar stages in my SAK/pocket knife of choice as I get older. I just turned 30 and have recently switched from carrying my Cadet, to a Pioneer, to a Super Tinker and now to a Pioneer X that is currently in my pocket. I am enjoying the larger sizes with more and more robust tools too much to downsize at the moment. But as always its an ebb and flow with these things. I am sure some day it will swing back the other way.
-
@GoatDragon said:
That was a fantastic read, thank you for posting it! I have to wonder if I will go through similar stages in my SAK/pocket knife of choice as I get older. I just turned 30 and have recently switched from carrying my Cadet, to a Pioneer, to a Super Tinker and now to a Pioneer X that is currently in my pocket. I am enjoying the larger sizes with more and more robust tools too much to downsize at the moment. But as always its an ebb and flow with these things. I am sure some day it will swing back the other way.What fits today may not fit tomorrow! There is an old axiom that the only constant is change and you can certainly count on change being a constant companion through the years.
Jim
-
Change...the one true constant! But I do find that we usually come full circle on some things. My first knife was a US military demo knife. Then SAK. Then everything by everyone! Now that I am retired, I have come back to SAK. Of all the knives I have kept it is the SAK. I never got rid of them, and never realized it until I was packing and moving that I had them.
-
I love this thread, and this about sums me up as well. I like to carry the smallest amount of kit to get the job done.
-
Thank you for sharing your time-won wisdom. I've worn out several Classics over the last decades, and still rely on one here, and one there, and... Well, I've stashed them in strategic places.
What was my minimalist goto before the Classics? P38s, of course! To be honest, I could probably get by with just that. I still keep one in my wallet along with a Sears 4way screw driver.
CheersSent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
I've kind of always circled around minimalism and SAKs. I had a SAK in boy scouts, and carried a knife through all of high school (I'd be in prison for that these days
) and college.However, I've always hated stuff in my pockets to the point that I went for a few years without carrying a knife of any kind :o

I then got back into knives and started off with more "tactical" single blades before finally rediscovering SAKs. Then alox. then the pioneer. Now, it seems like I've arrived at my perfect carry, at least until circumstances change.
-
I reduce my EDC a lot. I started carrying SAKs and LMs (for the pliers, mostly) and flashlights and OPTs.
Then I began to see that most of the time they didn't get any use. Well, most of them didn't. So, I started leaving some stuff at home. Then I started carrying SAKs with fewer and fewer layers/functions.
I got to a point where it was just my Nitecore Tube + Midnite Manager (base EDC) plus any SAK/knife with a longer blade for food prep.
Recently, Nix got me to test the Executive/Director. My EDC got even smaller. For the last weeks, it's just the Director and the Tube. I probably will still carry another pocket knife, from time to time. Mostly because I have some I like to handle/use/look at, even if they don't add any fucntionality to my base EDC.
-
-
@GoatDragon said:
That was a fantastic read, thank you for posting it! I have to wonder if I will go through similar stages in my SAK/pocket knife of choice as I get older. I just turned 30 and have recently switched from carrying my Cadet, to a Pioneer, to a Super Tinker and now to a Pioneer X that is currently in my pocket. I am enjoying the larger sizes with more and more robust tools too much to downsize at the moment. But as always its an ebb and flow with these things. I am sure some day it will swing back the other way.At 30 I was still collecting full size stockman and 4 layer SAK's that I thought I needed. Toss in a few large folders like the Case two blade folding hunter and the Mercator K55 lockable and that's a good idea of what I was carrying.
It was only when I got into middle age that I started looking at my stuff and thought 'when was the last time I really needed that?" that I started to cut way back. It was in my early 40's that I sold off the custom Randall's and other stuff that was Safe queens. Gave away lottos my large pocketknives to family and friends, and did give aways on forums. Same with my firearms.
Time and life will tell you when it's time to downsize.
-
That was a fantastic read, thank you for posting it! I have to wonder if I will go through similar stages in my SAK/pocket knife of choice as I get older. I just turned 30 and have recently switched from carrying my Cadet, to a Pioneer, to a Super Tinker and now to a Pioneer X that is currently in my pocket. I am enjoying the larger sizes with more and more robust tools too much to downsize at the moment. But as always its an ebb and flow with these things. I am sure some day it will swing back the other way.
At 30 I was still collecting full size stockman and 4 layer SAK's that I thought I needed. Toss in a few large folders like the Case two blade folding hunter and the Mercator K55 lockable and that's a good idea of what I was carrying.
It was only when I got into middle age that I started looking at my stuff and thought 'when was the last time I really needed that?" that I started to cut way back. It was in my early 40's that I sold off the custom Randall's and other stuff that was Safe queens. Gave away lottos my large pocketknives to family and friends, and did give aways on forums. Same with my firearms.
Time and life will tell you when it's time to downsize.
In my 20's I collected a lot of SAKs and modern folders, and so far I have just been acquiring them and collecting them. At some point I am sure I will begin the process of selling or giving away some of my collection and downsizing that as well, but today is not that day.
And I have been noticing what tools I actually use on a regular basis. Yesterday, with my PX, I used the main blade, the scissors, and the bottle opener as a screwdriver. The only way I could get those tools in a smaller package would be the Compact, but I am not a fan of the combo tool. (It's just too flimsy and doesn't work very well on Phillips. Full opener layer for life!)
The one thing I have really been struggling with is my desire to carry a modern folder as well as my SAK. The minimalist in me says that the SAK's blade is more than enough for my needs, especially if I am carrying a beefy 93mm. (And that would be the truth, I don't do anything that requires a one handed opening, locking blade in some modern super steel.) But I'll be damned if another part of me doesn't desperately look for an excuse to slip one of my sexy Spyderco or Kershaw knives in my pocket next to my SAK. (I wouldn't even think of only carrying the modern folder. They don't have any extra tools!)
-
- I know I'll need to cut something.
- I know I'll open a can.
- I know I'll need to turn flat and phillips screws.
- I know I'll need to scrape or pry something.
- I know I prefer scissors to a blade for some tasks.
- I know I'll need to grasp something my fingers aren't strong enough to.
I can live within certain limits. I have no problem not being able to perform every task with my off day carry. I don't have to solve every problem I encounter with the tools I am carrying. I'm handy enough to use the tool at hand to its fullest capacity. I don't require one tool to do it all.
What I'm not trying to do is limit myself to size and weight just for that sake. I'm not trying to test myself by carrying around the least to see if I can get by. This is not about what I can live without in so much as what I can manage with within reason. I like to carry and will carry certain tools because I like them and they are fun to carry. I only need to please me and don't have to justify what I carry or why.
If you feel like carrying a fixed blade cause you can then go for it. Same goes for any such tool you want to carry for the heck of it.
Needs change as we go through life. We all have stages we'll go through. Our carry items will also change as a result. I'm still working so my requirements for work carry is stable. What I've carried for my off day however has changed, become more finely tuned.
Leatherman Squirt P4. This tool has been bomb proof. Has limits but within those I am capable.
Victorinox Manager. I am impressed to say the least. Do not think for a moment that the 58mm SAKs are back ups. or keychain jewelry. Please don't fool yourself. I have related a story about my experience on a job where I pushed mine to its limit. Had every intention to sacrifice this tool to get the job done. It performed spectacularly.
Victorinox Salesman 84mm. Got one? No need to express how awesome this tool is. Don't have one? Let me tell you how awesome this tool is. Ever wonder why the Tinker is so well regarded? Imagine adding scissors to it and then placing it all in 84mm frame :ahhh RIGHT! I like opening layers vs combo tool. I like a phillps. I would love a nail file vs small blade but I wont complain. The size of this tool is exceptional. I get the T&T and an awl.
Prytool. You can use your blade if you want. You can use your Vics bottle open if you want. Heck you can use your keys but give me a real pry tool thank you.
AAA Light. My Fenix LD02 has been a staple. Simple straight forward light. I do have other AAA lights and 3 AA lights that I like. I add a AA light when I leave the house at night and in winter when the days are shorter.
My Manager and Fenix LD02 ride on my keychain. My Salesman and Squirt in a pocket sheath. I add my pry tool to my keychain and have also carried it rubber band to my pocket sheath. Nothing obtrusive and everything I like.
If I want to carry something else for the heck of it then I do. Fixed blade, extra light, MT, small folder, or anything I feel would be fun for the day.


-
That was a fantastic read, thank you for posting it! I have to wonder if I will go through similar stages in my SAK/pocket knife of choice as I get older. I just turned 30 and have recently switched from carrying my Cadet, to a Pioneer, to a Super Tinker and now to a Pioneer X that is currently in my pocket. I am enjoying the larger sizes with more and more robust tools too much to downsize at the moment. But as always its an ebb and flow with these things. I am sure some day it will swing back the other way.
At 30 I was still collecting full size stockman and 4 layer SAK's that I thought I needed. Toss in a few large folders like the Case two blade folding hunter and the Mercator K55 lockable and that's a good idea of what I was carrying.
It was only when I got into middle age that I started looking at my stuff and thought 'when was the last time I really needed that?" that I started to cut way back. It was in my early 40's that I sold off the custom Randall's and other stuff that was Safe queens. Gave away lottos my large pocketknives to family and friends, and did give aways on forums. Same with my firearms.
Time and life will tell you when it's time to downsize.
Wow, Carl! Really?! Hope I don't get to feel like that until I reach 70 (if I do at awll...).

:D :D :D :D
-
That was a fantastic read, thank you for posting it! I have to wonder if I will go through similar stages in my SAK/pocket knife of choice as I get older. I just turned 30 and have recently switched from carrying my Cadet, to a Pioneer, to a Super Tinker and now to a Pioneer X that is currently in my pocket. I am enjoying the larger sizes with more and more robust tools too much to downsize at the moment. But as always its an ebb and flow with these things. I am sure some day it will swing back the other way.
At 30 I was still collecting full size stockman and 4 layer SAK's that I thought I needed. Toss in a few large folders like the Case two blade folding hunter and the Mercator K55 lockable and that's a good idea of what I was carrying.
It was only when I got into middle age that I started looking at my stuff and thought 'when was the last time I really needed that?" that I started to cut way back. It was in my early 40's that I sold off the custom Randall's and other stuff that was Safe queens. Gave away lottos my large pocketknives to family and friends, and did give aways on forums. Same with my firearms.
Time and life will tell you when it's time to downsize.
In my 20's I collected a lot of SAKs and modern folders, and so far I have just been acquiring them and collecting them. At some point I am sure I will begin the process of selling or giving away some of my collection and downsizing that as well, but today is not that day.
And I have been noticing what tools I actually use on a regular basis. Yesterday, with my PX, I used the main blade, the scissors, and the bottle opener as a screwdriver. The only way I could get those tools in a smaller package would be the Compact, but I am not a fan of the combo tool. (It's just too flimsy and doesn't work very well on Phillips. Full opener layer for life!)
The one thing I have really been struggling with is my desire to carry a modern folder as well as my SAK. The minimalist in me says that the SAK's blade is more than enough for my needs, especially if I am carrying a beefy 93mm. (And that would be the truth, I don't do anything that requires a one handed opening, locking blade in some modern super steel.) But I'll be damned if another part of me doesn't desperately look for an excuse to slip one of my sexy Spyderco or Kershaw knives in my pocket next to my SAK. (I wouldn't even think of only carrying the modern folder. They don't have any extra tools!)
+1

It's not 'cause we need it, it's 'cause we like it!
:D :D :D :D
-
Excellent point about being prepared for 98%. That’s a good lesson for all.
-
@cbl51 said:
Maximum minimalism.The ability to carry the absolute minimum of stuff and perform the maximum amount of jobs you can with just that stuff in your pockets. it did 98%of what was needed. I like playing percentages. If theres a 2% chance I'll need a wood chisel, fish scaler, wood saw, metal file, I'll take my chances without.
It's been a long strange trip, going from the 93mm, to 91mm, to 84mm to 58mm, and then back up a little to the 74mm as a daily carry. But it's been a lot of fun along the way.
I played a little fast and loose with the quote
. I'm still having one heck a time so the ride continues. We've all got our journeys and there is no right path to follow. My carry has again changed and lily will again since my last post here. There are some tools that just feel right while others are fun.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


