Help me decide
-
Having just got some doner SAKs in (thanks again Neil) I want to either make myself a Scientist or a Yeoman.
The Yeoman is a better stand alone SAK but the Scientist is a great minimal SAK and I can always put a classic in my pocket if I really think I'm going to need Scissors. Your thoughts please.PS I not promising to make the one with the biggest vote but it sure will help me make up my mind.

-
I vote for the scientist, great 2-layer sak if there ever was one. :D
-
like the tool selection of the yeoman

-
Scientist, though I always feel its not quite right building existing models (that is just me though).
How about doing a Scientist but with something different in place of the combo tool?
Neil
-
I'll go with a Yeoman, as like you say it's a better stand alone tool :)
-
If you are really torn, make a Yeoman and carry it around for a while. If you find yourself regretting the decision later, then you can just do a quick layer removal and have a Scientist. ;)
-
I'll throw another kink in your plans. Add a saw to the Scientist and make a Spudman.But since you asked to pick between a Scientist and Yeoman..I'll go Scientist
-
Good idea. Or what about a file, more suited for urban use and adds next to nothing to the thickness.
Neil
-
Naarrgh! :ahhh This was ment to cut down my options not add more. ;)
-
YEO!
If you want to make it distinguishable from a "real" Yeoman (or Scientist)
use a new-style magnifier, since all the real ones have old mags. -
I would say build the Scientist! I have one, and if it wasn't for you guys; I wouldn't have know that it's a rare SAK! Nevertheless, it is still an excellent model, and I am looking to buy another to use..
-
@NKB said:
Scientist, though I always feel its not quite right building existing models (that is just me though).How about doing a Scientist but with something different in place of the combo tool?
Neil
I feel the same. Modding as I see it is where you make something your own. Re-creating a model just doesn't seem right.

How about a Scientist with a phillips?
-
...
How about a Scientist with a phillips?Eh, two phillips drivers

Neil
What, you don't like that idea? You can be sooooooooooooo picky sometimes Neil! :D
Sorry, didn't think that through, was just trying to think of the easiest way to make the Scientist his own without adding any layers.
-
just when you think scissors are not that necesary...bam! you may be missing them, I vote for Yeoman.

-
I vote for the Scientist plus one additional item to make it unique.
I suggest a fish scaler. Then you will have an Ichthyologist.
:D
-
OK I think you have convinced me to try and do something more than the Scientist. I quite like the idea of adding a saw and making a Spudman, I think I might use a back tool to add a little extra.
I'm not promising that it won't be pulled apart again to bring it down to two layers though. :)
-
Make two Scientists (clone em if ya have to :P) one for ya self and one for me to buy of of ya :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login