Fx & Px
-
Recently bought the farmer x
More out of curiosity than need
It arrived a few days ago As per usual Victorinox standards it is very well made, but the damn Keyring, it is so uncomfortable. Decided to compare to the pioneer x. It arrived today.
Again the Keyring is uncomfortable, obviously slimmer than the farmer. But neither would be my first choice to edc.Sorry about the pics...(old phone)




-
It's no big deal to grind it off [emoji106]
Sendt fra min moto g(8) power med Tapatalk
-
@Thomas DK said:
It's no big deal to grind it off [emoji106]Sendt fra min moto g(8) power med Tapatalk
I did think about that, but I don’t think I’d carry it. Don’t know why, but the Alox line never seems to feel right.
I have a few of the normal silver versions. From the MiniChamp upto the Farmer. Yet none hits the spot
-
Have you ever held a 93mm alox without a keyring and nub?
For many of us, the improvement in comfort is staggering. A 93mm with nothing digging into the heel of your palm is an absolute joy to hold and use. To me it's the difference between heaven and hell. And there's no sharp protrusion to wear a hole in your pockets either. Honestly, it's what alox was always meant to be.
If you're daring and file off your keyrings, your feelings towards your PX and FX could be transformed. :) (A different matter of course if you don't get on with their toolsets or whatever else.)
-
@Sawl Goodman said:
Have you ever held a 93mm alox without a keyring and nub?For many of us, the improvement in comfort is staggering. A 93mm with nothing digging into the heel of your palm is an absolute joy to hold and use. To me it's the difference between heaven and hell. And there's no sharp protrusion to wear a hole in your pockets either. Honestly, it's what alox was always meant to be.
If you're daring and file off your keyrings, your feelings towards your PX and FX could be transformed. :) (A different matter of course if you don't get on with their toolsets or whatever else.)
Especially as they dont seem to do any chamfering on the keyring nub(as opposed to the 91mm line which does have a meeting with the file/sandpaper)
-
I don't find the nubs on the Px or Fx uncomfortable, but I get it. I have a Px with the nub filed off (it was easy), and have used it on those odd occasions in which I don't want a lanyard at all. It works fine, and the spot I did the filing is barely noticeable.
-
On the contrary, if you attached a P7 suspension clip to your Px for Fx, you may be more inclined to EDC it.
-
I love the pioneer, it’s my favorite pocket knife. But, the first thing I do when I get one is eliminate the key ring nub.
Another alternative, unless you’re specifically looking for the Px/Fx toolset could be a Wenger SI with a bail.

-
@Sawl Goodman said:
Have you ever held a 93mm alox without a keyring and nub?For many of us, the improvement in comfort is staggering. A 93mm with nothing digging into the heel of your palm is an absolute joy to hold and use. To me it's the difference between heaven and hell. And there's no sharp protrusion to wear a hole in your pockets either. Honestly, it's what alox was always meant to be...
I always find it interesting how different individual experiences are. I have knives with and without the key ring, and I prefer the former. It doesn’t bother me at all in use, and it gives me immediate tactile feedback as to which end is which as I fish it from my pocket and prepare to open it.
I am by no means trying to invalidate your opinion; I’m just musing about how tastes differ...which makes the world a more interesting place.
-
I guess we are all different in the way we handle our knives.. And size/shape of our hands play into it also.. The key ring does not bother me one bit on my Pioneer.. I have lg hands and seems to disappear in my grip.. Just sayin..

-
@gustophersmob said:
I love the pioneer, it’s my favorite pocket knife. But, the first thing I do when I get one is eliminate the key ring nub.Another alternative, unless you’re specifically looking for the Px/Fx toolset could be a Wenger SI with a bail.
Banish such thoughts
Blasphemous !! :ahhh -
@Frailer said:
I always find it interesting how different individual experiences are. I have knives with and without the key ring, and I prefer the former. It doesn’t bother me at all in use, and it gives me immediate tactile feedback as to which end is which as I fish it from my pocket and prepare to open it.I am by no means trying to invalidate your opinion; I’m just musing about how tastes differ...which makes the world a more interesting place.
That's totally OK: my opinion is absolutely just an opinion! Everyone has their preferences, definitely.
I really don't like the keyring nubs on any SAK. For some time the Sportsman was my favourite 84mm and I bought several backups. One though instantly felt different and more comfortable in my hand, which mystified me until I saw it had no keyring nub. I hadn't noticed when I bought it. Guess which became my favourite?
Possibly it's because of the shape of my hand? Anyway, I know I'm not the only one with keyring dislike!
-
@Frailer said:
I always find it interesting how different individual experiences are. I have knives with and without the key ring, and I prefer the former. It doesn’t bother me at all in use, and it gives me immediate tactile feedback as to which end is which as I fish it from my pocket and prepare to open it.I am by no means trying to invalidate your opinion; I’m just musing about how tastes differ...which makes the world a more interesting place.
Agreed. The keyring quickly orients me to which end of the tool I'm on, so I can find particular tools quickly. That's slightly more important to me with the Pioneer X, compared to the Soldier. I also grab the keyring if I'm pulling the tool out of my watch pocket. I also prefer it aesthetically. .. I think it adds something in the way of character.
-
Without keyring I wouldn‘t even know how to carry my SAKs :D
-
I'm also on the "grind that darn key ring tab OFF
**" **camp... :DI have a love/hate relationship with the key ring on SAK's, but on the 93mm i just can't stand it. unfortunately it's also the worst to file/grind off.
It's placed right against the backspring, and if one's not careful can nick the spring, liner or scale when filing. That's the reason i haven't file it on my PX yet. But i'll eventually will. The ring itself came right off as soon as i toke it out of the box though... >:DOn the 91/84mm it's a breeze to file off

-
@MacGyver said:
I'm also on the "grind that darn key ring tab OFF
**" **camp... :DI have a love/hate relationship with the key ring on SAK's, but on the 93mm i just can't stand it. unfortunately it's also the worst to file/grind off.
It's placed right against the backspring, and if one's not careful can nick the spring, liner or scale when filing. That's the reason i haven't file it on my PX yet. But i'll eventually will. The ring itself came right off as soon as i toke it out of the box though... >:DOn the 91/84mm it's a breeze to file off

I think all of us have a love hate relationship with the keyring. I dare say... more than the corkscrew vs. Phillips debate... this is the most polarizing aspect of SAKs... its not even a debate. I can't even suggest "MacGuyver, old pal... I reckon if you put a P7, or a lanyard on your keyring you'll find it quite useful indeed"
No, it's nothing like that. Either you use it in one way or another, or its a dangly pain in the hand. -
@ElevenBlade said:
I think all of us have a love hate relationship with the keyring. I dare say... more than the corkscrew vs. Phillips debate... this is the most polarizing aspect of SAKs... its not even a debate. I can't even suggest "MacGuyver, old pal... I reckon if you put a P7, or a lanyard on your keyring you'll find it quite useful indeed"
No, it's nothing like that. Either you use it in one way or another, or its a dangly pain in the hand.Yup, that's sums it...
I like the look of it on the cellidors on one side cause it's a pert of the classical SAK look, but on the other hand it just gets in the way and dangles most of the time, not to mention it's uncomfortable in the hand.
Since i don't use lanyards or clips or danglers in SAK's the function is near irrelevant to me.
The Pioneer line has such a great symmetry to the design that the key ring just spoils the look and feel IMO -
@MacGyver said:
I'm also on the "grind that darn key ring tab OFF
**" **camp... :DI have a love/hate relationship with the key ring on SAK's, but on the 93mm i just can't stand it. unfortunately it's also the worst to file/grind off.
It's placed right against the backspring, and if one's not careful can nick the spring, liner or scale when filing. That's the reason i haven't file it on my PX yet. But i'll eventually will. The ring itself came right off as soon as i toke it out of the box though... >:DOn the 91/84mm it's a breeze to file off

Interesting. I think it’s the easiest since it’s still aluminum. Since they switched the 91mm to be part of the back spring, it takes some work to grind one off.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login