Going smaller...
-
The climber doesn't have the nail file and although I have one on my rambler the slightly larger one will be nice I think. Plus I don't need the parcel hook all the time... Or most of the time.
And the rambler will take care of the scissors. Also looking at the pioneer alox but I like having the tweezers and toothpick. I also like having a corkscrew for knots and holding the tiny screwdriver that I have one extra lying around.
-
These days, that's what my corkscrew gets used for most!

-

I did actually use mine to uncork a wine bottle recently. And I made sure make a little scene and annoy my wife who thinks my new SAK obsession is crazy.

-
@W0ody107 said:
I was thinking of getting a champ but my thinking has started to change.My Climber with plus scales has been handling pretty much all of my needs. So I'm actually looking at a Sportsman for my next sak. I like the toolset better than the Compact and it's about half the price.
Anyone else think similarly? I can't justify spending a bunch for tools I probably won't use. But I also feel like I want them all....

I think the Sportsman is a great knife and you said you have a Rambler so scissors are covered. I have the same thoughts as you as I have switched to a Tinker and Classic SD from my Super Tinker. More is not always better. I would get a Spirit X if you really need more then a 2 or 3 layer SAK anyway.
-
This one of the reasons why so many of us have so many SAKs!

@W0ody107 said:
I can't justify spending a bunch for tools I probably won't use.Sure you can. It just makes you a collector. Nothing wrong with that.

As far as users, only you can really decide what functions are critical for you, which are nice to have, and which don't matter. Sometimes this takes some experimentation. Try carrying something much more basic, and see what you really miss. Try carrying a Swisschamp, and see which tools you actually use.
I would not let cost be a major factor in what SAK you buy, even if you are on a tight budget and need to save up for another month or two. If you get the right SAK for you, you'll be carrying and using it long after you've forgotten how much you paid for it.
-
Trial and error will let you what SAK works best for you. Most days I like carrying a Spartan or a tinker with a pocket hook and a Classic. My secondary carry SAKs are my Supper Climber, Camper, and Explorer.
Mike
-
I can understand the thinking. I do like the 84/85mm having the nail file. My only hesitation is that I really like the larger scissors,but if you are content with the Rambler scissors, then I think you will be good.
-
This is a constant dilemma of mine. I like the idea of the 84mm - it sits in the pocket on a suspension clip a little bit neater than the 91mm. I do miss the scissors though, which is why a Climber Small is something of a holy grail for me. You could try the Delemont 85s: I’ve been tempted by the 14 and recently got the earlier Wenger Evowood 14, but I’ve found it a bit bulky with the wooden wibbly wobbly scales.
If we’re talking combo, i would defo go Manager/Cadet - same toolset as Sportsman (minus Corkscrew and scale tools) but so much slimmer in the pocket. And if I ever get lucky with a Cadet X - hallelujah! -
The Climber with long nail file (a bit uncommon) is an awesome alternative. Nail file instead of hook.
-
@W0ody107 said:
I was thinking of getting a champ but my thinking has started to change.My Climber with plus scales has been handling pretty much all of my needs. So I'm actually looking at a Sportsman for my next sak. I like the toolset better than the Compact and it's about half the price.
Anyone else think similarly? I can't justify spending a bunch for tools I probably won't use. But I also feel like I want them all....

You just picked two of my favourite SAKs. The Climber was my first real one. The Sportsman came later on, but the reasoning was pretty much what you said. Smaller size, for more convenient pocket carry, nail file, not present in the Climber. If you awlso got some scissors, it's a perfect EDC.

-
You got me thinking about the EDC combo options and I came up with this:
- Cadet + Jetsetter (with pen scale) + Nitecore Tiki.
Covers most of the bases (cork extraction excluded) with minimal redundancy.
This could work.

- Cadet + Jetsetter (with pen scale) + Nitecore Tiki.
-
@Jud65 said:
You got me thinking about the EDC combo options and I came up with this:- Cadet + Jetsetter (with pen scale) + Nitecore Tiki.
Covers most of the bases (cork extraction excluded) with minimal redundancy.
This could work.
You do have removing corks covered using the Cadet main blade. Here is the link to the how-to https://youtu.be/IZKu4RDfdjs
Mike
- Cadet + Jetsetter (with pen scale) + Nitecore Tiki.
-
I've gotten to the point I just carry a Pocket Toolchest these days. For non-work EDC, does most of what I need. A tool like the original LKL Innovations SwissTech or the Leatherman Squirt P4 are lightweight options that handle pliers, and the LKL has very heavy-duty 3D drivers.
-
@Mike 56 said:
You do have removing corks covered using the Cadet main blade. Here is the link to the how-to https://youtu.be/IZKu4RDfdjsMike
You gotta love Felix!

-
@cody6268 said:
I've gotten to the point I just carry a Pocket Toolchest these days.I’d give my right arm for a PTC but they’re like gold dust. To be honest I could get by most days with a Manager but the 58mm is not quite enough somehow. I love my Executive but find myself constantly frustrated by the Toolset - reached for beer last night only to curse at the lack of a bottle opener on the 74mm!

-
@Jud65 said:
This is a constant dilemma of mine. I like the idea of the 84mm - it sits in the pocket on a suspension clip a little bit neater than the 91mm. I do miss the scissors though, which is why a Climber Small is something of a holy grail for me. You could try the Delemont 85s: I’ve been tempted by the 14 and recently got the earlier Wenger Evowood 14, but I’ve found it a bit bulky with the wooden wibbly wobbly scales.
If we’re talking combo, i would defo go Manager/Cadet - same toolset as Sportsman (minus Corkscrew and scale tools) but so much slimmer in the pocket. And if I ever get lucky with a Cadet X - hallelujah!I also tried the Evo series, but found it bulky and therefore uncomfortable. I do have a SwissBuck Sidekick (Swiss Advantage), which hits a nice sweet spot and would be a great option if you can find one.
-
@Sos24 said:
I also tried the Evo series, but found it bulky and therefore uncomfortable. I do have a SwissBuck Sidekick (Swiss Advantage), which hits a nice sweet spot and would be a great option if you can find one.I remember reading about and passing over the Swissbuck series before in a deeper dive on the wiki but it’s nice to see another option. The Traveller, that it’s based on, was very much on my radar - that 85mm size and with a nearly perfect toolset.
-
I can completely understand. That said, you need a Swisschamp because its awesome. Ok now that I said that, the 84/85 mm tools are great. I have a 84mm Tinker thats pretty darn awesome and a Salesman thats also terrific. My Cadet 2 is a go to even tho I thought I'd stop carrying a SAK without scissors. I also very much like my Highlander. I find my 58mms scissors can handle quite a lot and if they aren't up to the task then we always have the blade so no real issue
. I always pair any SAK with a 58mm or my PTC. To me its Peanut Butter and Jelly. -
@W0ody107 said:
The climber doesn't have the nail file and although I have one on my rambler the slightly larger one will be nice I think. Plus I don't need the parcel hook all the time... Or most of the time.And the rambler will take care of the scissors. Also looking at the pioneer alox but I like having the tweezers and toothpick. I also like having a corkscrew for knots and holding the tiny screwdriver that I have one extra lying around.
If you already carry a Rambler, may as well get Cadet instead of Sportsman... much thinner and lighter than Pioneer and has the excellent large nail file.
You already have toothpick and tweezers in the Rambler so may as well go alox if you can do without the corkscrew and awl.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login