2 Layer SAKs
-
From the list, it is definitely the Compact, because I can’t do without the scissors on my carry SAK. I have a few Compacts that I rotate between.
I would really like to see Vic bring back the 84mm with scissors, the 84mm Voyageur is on my wish list.
-
My first SAK was a Spartan, and I carried it exclusively for many years, so I'll always have a bit of a soft spot for them.
If we're talking about which one I would prefer to carry today, I find I really miss the scissors if I don't have them, so I voted Compact. Really, though, I consider a three-layer (Climber or Pioneer X) to be about my minimum for EDC.
-
@pa_strunk said:
How about this golfer modThat is sweet.
I would love to find a phillips with file. Although, I would be wanting to find a way to put it as an inline phillips with a yeoman.
-
I voted for the Compact, as it was the knife I carried daily for many years, but truth be told I might be just a bit happier if I could be allowed a Pioneer and a Classic.
-
Polls like these don't work for me.
I rotate between different models.
The most popular 2 layer ones are...- Executive
- Cadet
- Pioneer / Soldier
- Spartan
...and I'm missing my Compact that became a Yeoman

-
A tinker with an executive is increasingly my non troubleshooter day carry. They are so thin and light together I could paint them flesh tone, carry them On a dog tag Shaneat a nudist colony, and no one would notice.. 😉
-
I have/had (only one I don't have is a Tinker Small, but only because I gave it away as a gift) every single one of them on the list, and while it was close for Pioneer, Electrician, and Tourist, I had to go with Compact. Has most of the stuff one looks for an in SAK with the weight of a Spartan.
-
@SgtTowser said:
A tinker with an executive is increasingly my non troubleshooter day carry. They are so thin and light together I could paint them flesh tone, carry them On a dog tag Shaneat a nudist colony, and no one would notice.. 😉You could just tell them you feel naked without your SAK. :D
-
The Soldier/Pioneer is my number one SAK.
-
I can't vote, sorry. Not enough options. My choices:
- 97 Soldier for work, most home use, and occasional urban carry. Fantastic sturdiness and awl. One of my favourite SAKs.

- Tourist or Spartan (either plain edge or serrated) for most urban carry. The small blade and corkscrew give them bonus points. Two of my favourite SAKs.

- serrated Recruit for speSmurfpillst cutting duties at work. Another of my favourite SAKs. 8)
- 97 Soldier for work, most home use, and occasional urban carry. Fantastic sturdiness and awl. One of my favourite SAKs.
-
Voted Pioneer because there's no space for the SI. My other fave 2 layer is the fabled BuSchröder of which I own one of the two made ;)


-
Voted Sportsman because for me it's a perfect real world carry. Scissors are a nice to have if we're being serious and 84mm is a very, very, nice pocket carry compared to anything 7mm bigger

-
@magentus said:
Voted Pioneer because there's no space for the SI. My other fave 2 layer is the fabled BuSchröder of which I own one of the two made ;)That is sweet. I have a blade, saw and some nice dark green alox scales from a harvester so next time I have a spare awl that is going to be a project - was literally just toying with ideas for what to try out a bail on too!
-
@Helvetica Bold said:
That is sweet. I have a blade, saw and some nice dark green alox scales from a harvester so next time I have a spare awl that is going to be a project - was literally just toying with ideas for what to try out a bail on too!Go for it - green scales will look amazing

I'm going to try popping a hollow rivet on my Farmer once I've summoned the courage. :D
-
Pioneer at work, Tinker at home /office work for me
-
I voted Tinker, but would have gone with Compact if it had a Philips screwdriver rather than the worthless corkscrew.
-
It's funny, for many years a 2 layer SAK has been the norm and standard with the Soldier/Pioneer/Spartan and other Scout style knives. It's only in more recent times have we 'upsized' to 3 layers or more being the minimum for EDC. I'm typically with my Climber when in town and switching for a Huntsman, Camper or Trekker when outdoors.
I guess the change in attitude has been the SAK has for many years been viewed as a secondary tool to supplement and augment larger main tools like a fixed blade knife or a hatchet. Today, the SAK is the only tool we typically carry in our pockets and thus the desire/need for more options.
-
@nate j said:
My first SAK was a Spartan, and I carried it exclusively for many years, so I'll always have a bit of a soft spot for them.If we're talking about which one I would prefer to carry today, I find I really miss the scissors if I don't have them, so I voted Compact. Really, though, I consider a three-layer (Climber or Pioneer X) to be about my minimum for EDC.
I am with Nate that I typically carry a Climber as my minimum for my day to day SAK but I like the Tinker for 2 layers as I am not willing to give up the opener layer even for the scissors. I also like the small blade so the Compact just doesn't get it done for me. It is interesting to see how popular the Compact is though, it is a very versatile SAK.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
