Corkscrew lateral play
-
Hello, fellow SAKers !

Yesterday, while cracking open a bottle of Gamay, I realized the cork was hella hard to get out.
So instead of forcing like hercule on it, I quickly switched to a lever style corkscrew (even this one struggled ! And I open at least a bottle a day, so no, it wasn't me
)
But after that, I looked at my dear (new) swisschamp's corkscrew, and I noticed a not so subtle lateral play ! :ahhh
No idea if it was like that when new, but I doubt it, as the other champ I have doesn't have it, nor my other saks (besides my camper, which is one of my first sak's, and its not as pronounced).
It stills open and close fine, but heck, I'm quite surprised. Could it be a defect ?
Can it be fixed by hammering pins ?
It's hard to show a picture of it, let's say if I hold the base of the corkscrew in open position, it moves half a mm from left to right.I'm waiting on your insight, broders and sisders !

-
It's difficult to respond precisely without holding it, but based on your description this should be fixable by hammering the pin. Good luck
-
Thanks a lot for your answer, CT !

I will try to make a small video, but that's not that easy !
Now, I'm tempted to not use a SAK to open bottles anymore... the champ is quite unwieldy for that use, I think. -
By the way, can I leave it as is ? Or will I risk to damage it even more by using it the next time like this ?
-
A few taps on the pin should sort it, remember to check as you go to ensure it doesn’t become too tight.
Bonne chance! 
-
The thing is, its brand new, maybe 2 weeks ! So the scale is rather hard to remove. And I have no hair dryer !
Can I leave it like this ? Will it go worse ? -
Ok, I managed to remove both scales ! I'm trying to hammer the corkscrew pin, but it doesn't change anything. Should I go harder ? :ahhh
-
Sorry for the triple post, so I hammered it using some pb swiss pin removers, a mallet, and then a regular hammer, it seems it helped a tiny bit but its not perfect. I will leave it like this, maybe it came like that and I never realised ! I always want everything perfect, but sometimes, as my father would say, "better is the enemy of good" (poor translation, probably).

-
I'm doing a field test of SAK corkscrews to see what technique results in a bent corkscrew.
Long story short: The SAK corkscrew doesn't seem tolerant of using a levering technique. So I would guess torquing it from side-to-side would also bend things a bit.
The liners and pins in a SAK are soft metals: aluminum and brass. Leveraging against them will most likely bend things.
Conclusion: when using a SAK corkscrew, pull absolutely straight up.
-
It’s easy to introduce play in the corkscrew and difficult to remove it once it’s there. I would have recommended sending it to Victorinox before taking it apart.
I say that as I have received countless used knives with damaged corkscrews and the adjacent liners. Unless it’s an otherwise valuable or antique knife, I wouldn’t bother fixing it myself, aside from replacing the damaged parts or re-bending the corkscrew itself. Bent or tweaked liners never are the same functionally, even if repaired cosmetically. The exception being antiques with nickel silver liners. Those can be reshaped or re-flattened and work like they originally did.
That said, if your fix is now good enough for you to tolerate…just be proud that you did do it yourself, and continue enjoying your knife.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login