Off-White
-
@Myron said:
I don't buy Victorinox's cologne or luggage, and I didn't buy their clothing when they made it. This product isn't made for readers of this forum, either, and that's ok.I agree with the general sentiment. However :P
Lugage / perfume came along after 9/11. A way to broaden the product range to be less prone to loose all business overnight. I think that was a good decision that had a positive impact on the company.
Limited edition pieces I can get behind as well. A quick way to make more money in a fairly limited market. After all, profit is what businesses exist for.
I think no-one here opposes that Victorinox broadens its product line beyond tools because at the end of the day, that helps keep the business afloat, even in a crisis.This is however feels little bit different. This required a lot of changes in production to come about. What again was the last change/update Vic gave us (was something after the Marlin Spike in the 111mm line-up? Well, maybe we can count the Swisstool clip with it's poor screws). In that it signifies investments/development towards collectors and not users (this is also the 2nd very expensive limited edition that required a lot of R&D this year). And to make it worse Victorinox writes smurf like this "On-point in its aesthetic DNA, yet functionally flawless". I'm very into Design (fascinating topic on all levels. For me it is of course mostly web-design) and it always bothers me when function gets compromised for looks. This feels a lot like all of those useless one-piece-tools that look like an animal and that, coming from Victorinox, hurts.
-
Whether you like it or not, there's one thing we all have to admit: They managed to make the least ergonomic SAK of all times... I know it's made as a very expensive decoration and not meant to be used but it's still a SAK (according to the definition)... IMHO they could have made a perfume shaped that way, it would've been much better for all....
-
-
Question is do we put it into the Wiki? ???

I really don't want to - But I suppose we should as we need to create an accurate database and chronicle
We could hide it there as a variation of the Camper and just have a hyperink to a photo!?? >:DIt will be hard to be objective in that update!! :o ;)
-
@Huntsman said:
Question is do we put it into the Wiki? ???
I really don't want to - But I suppose we should as we need to create an accurate database and chronicle
We could hide it there as a variation of the Camper and just have a hyperink to a photo!?? >:DIt will be hard to be objective in that update!! :o ;)
Not sure if it would be fair on the Camper :)
I think a nice shiny page all on its own with the full press release text ..... it would be awful if this break through knife was ever forgotten :)
I think if the Wenger Swiss Business Tool gets a page then this should as well two questionable design decisions .... at least this one wont cause long term harm to the company
-
A full listing of its own so that this gets preserved for posterity….. Interesting to note that it hasn’t sold out yet…. Maybe there aren’t 3000 fans out there after all! 
-
I vote ( are we voting? ) it gets its own page with the wonderful description offered by the mothership ;).
-
@Aloha said:
I vote ( are we voting? ) it gets its own page with the wonderful description offered by the mothership ;).Me too.
It's an iconic art-knife. Like it or not. Please take a look at the painting called "Who’s Afraid of Red, Yellow and Blue III" made by the famous painter Barnett Newman (1905-1970). To me this painting is nothing, it's stupid and I don't see any meaning in it. However, millions of dollars were paid for this piece of art, and it has many, many admirers all over the world.
Barnett Newman tried somethinh very daring, very differently and he was admired for that. I think the same thing could happen to this ugly SAK: admiration for stepping out of the conventional way of knife manufacturing. -
@marlowe221 said:
I agree. I think a good wiki should be as objective as possible, warts and all, if it is to have the kind of credibility we would like it to have in the collector community.
I love an objective information source. -
@Grand_Banana said:
I was hoping someone would start a thread by the time I got on the forum today. Reddit is also up in arms. Come on Vic
Never a better use of this:

Couldn’t agree more with all the tooling comments… if only victorinox knew how much I would spend on 84mm models with scissors, electrician blade, file. Or, an electrician X , or etc. I missed out on many of the so called “unpopular” or poor selling models with these features or limited releases in past decades.
This community alone would turn a profit for them on some rereleases. Pay attention Vic


-
I hold one today in my hands - the scales feel very good, the tools feel as bizarre as in the pictures.
-
Did you buy one, or are you in a Vic shop?
-
I realize that different people have different levels of wealth and we all get to choose how to spend our disposable income. Far be it from me to criticize anyone for buying the things they like and that bring some joy to their lives.
That said, $500 is way too much money for me to spend on any knife, whether for actual use or to be a display piece. But that’s just me!
-
I see this with a lot of companies, they lack the courage to introduce a new "usable" for fear of it damaging existing models, so instead produce limited editions which will never see use outside a display case or bank vault.
I don't agree with the practice but can't condemn it as there's plenty of "whales" out there that can afford these luxuries. I guess it makes good business sense (if it sells)
-
@marlowe221 said:
$500 is way too much money for me to spend on any knife, whether for actual use or to be a display piece.I'd pay that kind of money for a Randall (the five or six-year wait could justify that expense), or maybe a very old and desirable SAK...but never for a brand-new SAK!
-
@marlowe221 said:
I realize that different people have different levels of wealth and we all get to choose how to spend our disposable income. Far be it from me to criticize anyone for buying the things they like and that bring some joy to their lives.That said, $500 is way too much money for me to spend on any knife, whether for actual use or to be a display piece. But that’s just me!
For me it is almost the other way round. Not gonna buy a knife just because it is cheap (good value). E.g. I don't own an Elementum because it is simply not appealing to me.
I have started out buying a lot of cheaper knives. This also helped me to figure out what I like and what are deal breakers. Now, I'm a lot more picky and I have gone to buying far less knives and with that the budget for individual pieces has gone up. As such I'm not held back by the price.
I honestly think it fails to be an art-piece and if fails to be a knife. Considering it is still available from Victorinox it even seems to fail as collectible item.Competition has gotten stiffer. To sell a knife for $400+ you need to deliver more than an oddly shaped SAK. IMHO the Replica 1897 was that more. It was a fully functional knife with a lot of heritage and emotions attached to it (I sometimes carry mine, just feels so special). I do like the Brilliant series (Despite wishing they had T&T and thinking they should have been Ramblers), they bridge the gap between bling and utility. I think there is a market for "higher end" SAKs (CF scales, better steels etc., maybe even more exotic design). I can even see a designer SAK being a success but it would have to be somewhat related to the knife/edc world (maybe a watch collab? Or do it like Boker and make some out of an old Tank*, Castle or an old Swiss Submarine**).
- Now that would be a good use of those tanks that have been forgotten (yeah, we have so many tanks that we forgot 400 M-113 APC) in a bunker and rotted away.
** No, the Swiss Navy does not have submarines, only patrol-boats, which is already quite off the charts for a land-locked nation (But then we also have the largest Merchant Marine of all the land-locked Nations) :P, oh and while we are at it. We are getting new fighter jets, so they could turn our old FA-18 Hornets into SAKs... I would buy that for a dollar :D
- Now that would be a good use of those tanks that have been forgotten (yeah, we have so many tanks that we forgot 400 M-113 APC) in a bunker and rotted away.
-
Yeah, that's fair. And I agree that there is room in the market for high end SAKs. I agree that the 1897 replica was a good example. I still didn't buy one - $500 is still too rich for my blood, not because I didn't think it was worth the money, but because I'm the parent of young children who basically pays daycare costs that are as high as the mortgage on a second house!
Hopefully, my budget will allow the purchase of some special, collectible SAKs in the future but it's not in the cards for me at the moment.
But the SAK that's the subject of this thread? Despite my love for the Camper as a model, even if I had the money sitting around, I wouldn't be buying this one! :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


