Reviving old threads
-
@Tasky said:
EDC is like anything - There are people who just do it, there are people who get proper geekily into it, and there are people who try to build it into an entire industry, subculture and scene.
I remember when Vaping became a 'scene' and people were showing off their vaper profiles with how long they'd been vaping (usually 2-3 years), what their signature tricks were, who their preferred brand sponsors were, etc... Whole regiments of merchandising freaks and vaping gurus, with the most legendary coil makers and mixologists.Yeah.
PSG is right in that EDC has its own side of that, to the point where there are articles on how to build a colour-coordinated EDC, because "an EDC" is a set list of things that everyone has to carry and you're not an EDCer if you don't have a flashlight, pen, knife, hank, lip balm(!!) and pocket pouch.... colour-matched titanium everythings, which individually cost more than my car, none of which gets carried more often than a couple of days per month at best.
However, while this forum does feature an element of showing stuff off, I've certainly spent my time talking the hind legs off donkeys about the minute details of the ILP or Wenger's scale tools.
You gimme an engaging topic, I'll fill the thread with posts about it. In truth, my biggest regret is that I have so littl etime to take photos and make videos about all this cool smurf that sits in my numerous pockets... and I'll delight in telling you aaaaaaaaaaall about those pockets, too!!For me, three pages of new posts is a good hour or two just to trawl through the bits that sound interesting, and God help you if you get me talking about something. Several members will attest to that!!
Forgot about the vaping! I was doing that for a while myself also. Then I got some coughing and understood to stop it pretty fast :D. Do people still vape? Haven't seen that in a while.
Of the EDC. I feel the pictures are great to give you inspiration. Some color coordinated or expensive stuff is pleasing to the eye and can be interesting. But it has come to repeating the same stuff fast as Tasky pointed out. At least when it comes to pocket dumps or pocket organizers. What to add or innovate to this as "EDC" is quite fixed in some way? I think none as EDC is rooted on interest in carrying and using the gear, not photography.
So what eventually survives is the essence of EDC. Interest in what you feel the need to carry and why. We share a pic, to let like minded people get inspired. But I would like to see the why a bit more. This goes a bit against how the social media works, we have pics and short videos on every platform. Not sure if we as humans want to see just loads of cool stuff fast or is it just the evolution of the algorithms to keep us scrolling?
I feel the fix to all of this is slowing everything down. And that's what I witness on this forum all the time. Discussions. Long threads. Enough time to get a bit off railed and joke a little, then get back on the topic again. Be "human" on a forum and still nobody judges you. And the will to revive even old threads! Many people here are long time members or lurkers like myself. This is what I feel like I can trust. Like minded people who are into SAKs and MTs and have been for years.
Back to the topic. Im loving this idea of resurrecting old threads. When I get more time I will take some time with this myself also. Many great threads deserve some new content. It's also nice for people who might visit the forum after a long time to see how some threads have survived the time and possible trends. And I feel we all have some threads that have been important or inspirational for us in some way.
Lähetetty minun SM-A426B laitteesta Tapatalkilla
-
Besides the Skipper, there aren't any other SAKs I've strongly considering adding to my rotation of Spirit and Super Tinker.
-
@z1913 said:
Simon, I think you hit very deep, almost existential topic here.What is the cause of rise and fall of empires? Why almost every human endeavour goes through the stages of humble beginnings, growth, heydays, stagnation and inevitable decline?
For the forum - is it age related? Maybe the old members already told everything and there is not enough of a new ones to rejuvenate? Of course I do not have exact data, but I guess there are not many members below 40 or 45...
I am still very grateful that this forum exists, I remember my early lurking only days and the excitement reading discussions about the best combos, hours spent contemplating pro and cons of Rambler vs. Classic vs. MC, discusions between users and collectors, stories what sparked interest in SAKs and what SAKs means to people..
But it seems to me that SAKs and pocket knives in general are thing of the past. Beautiful, useful and great, but with limited future...
Well firstly I'm reviving an old thread, but at the top I got a message suggesting that maybe I should start a new topic as this thread has been dormant for at least 90 days. I may do that, I'm a new member so it would be nice to do.
The topic I really want to comment on - and which may be the title of my new post - is whether pocket knives are now outdated. We can certainly all agree that carrying them has declined, whether that was in the mid 60s, 80s, post 9/11, or even more recently (in Europe anyway due to either new legislation or as it is here in the UK, a different perception of knives).
Before the mid 60s at least I think most men carried a pocket knife, and after that most men who'd been born prior to the mid 60s considered it normal to still do so. I was born in 1971 and for the last 4 years have always carried a pocket knife, but I am probably in a minority, at least where I am. Also for about 20 years prior to that I hadn't carried one.
Irrespective of when carrying a pocket knife started to really decline, I think we can all agree that it has been the norm for most of human history though, going right back to sharpened flints like the one Oetzi was found to be carrying, admittedly it was a fixed blade but it was a pocket or pouch knife in today's terms. So I would probably consider the recent move away from carrying pocket knives to just be a blip in human history. Furthermore it may well only be us city dwellers in N. America/Europe seeing this, as people in the country, or in other countries, probably do carry them a lot more than the people in our immediate environment.
-
I have my Boomer theory on this.
In decades past, a higher percentage of people grew up on farms, in rural settings or in remote small town settings. Kids were far more likely to be out on bikes, fishing, hiking or just kicking around. In those settings, having some level of skill troubleshooting/repairing stuff was essential.
Fast forward to a time where most are urban or to some extent suburban dwellers (most of whom do not even maintain their own lawn) and you have a group of people who fix everything with their credit card.
Kids are disadvantaged that their parents and older sibs have no practical skills and therefore they dont either.
With that as an upbringing, why would you carry a knife or MT?
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
I have my Boomer theory on this.In decades past, a higher percentage of people grew up on farms, in rural settings or in remote small town settings. Kids were far more likely to be out on bikes, fishing, hiking or just kicking around. In those settings, having some level of skill troubleshooting/repairing stuff was essential.
Fast forward to a time where most are urban or to some extent suburban dwellers (most of whom do not even maintain their own lawn) and you have a group of people who fix everything with their credit card.
Kids are disadvantaged that their parents and older sibs have no practical skills and therefore they dont either.
With that as an upbringing, why would you carry a knife or MT?
I’m not a boomer. Only a gen X’er by 3 months, but I agree with this.
I grew up in a rural area and was in scouting and tools were a daily part of life, including a pocketknife.
-
Good points from both of you Mr. W and SL.
Yes there us a decline in usage, from my perspective, it just makes me very sad that something so useful and - in my daily life - essential, (I literally use my SAK for something or other every single day) is being squeezed out of use, by legislation and the replace/throw-away, don't fix (yourself) culture of our (urban) society.
I am sad for my son - maybe he will end up carrying a SAK or MT - but at the moment he cannot legally take one to school (if he does I have also committed a crime - by allowing him to do so!!) and is not of the tinkering/fix it mindset, or much of an outdoorsey/bushman type (unlike me!!) - He plays on a screen .... :(
I think the green/recycling political and social movements will help us - and of course also help the planet - So maybe there is hope for my son yet!!
He is into scootering and the scooter does need constant tinkering - So there is also some hope there. -
"I have my Boomer theory on this."
You are absolutely right. Last year I bought a My First Victorinox for my 15 year old nephew. I told him it could be a handy device to spread a sandwich with the rounded tip blade, but he said all knives were forbidden on school, and that at his age he wasn't allowed to carry a pocket knife at all!!
His dad didn't care, but his mom didn't allow him to EDC the pocket knife. Mom and dad are divorced (of course) so his mom won the discussion.
Uncle Boomer was left stupidified... ??? -
As a Gen X, I have to say that carrying a penknife was normal for me, but I grew up in rural areas and no-one ever frowned at carrying a penknife even at school (can’t imagine that now, but we saw them as tools not weapons), and in later life I carried a 91mm Golfer in my suit pocket when I was at work including flying on passenger jets all over the world, but that was before 9/11 and the subsequent clamp downs…. Although I happily still carry a SAK, I would think twice about having one in a pocket in London, and certainly wouldn’t use one in public there for fear of triggering someone into over-reacting…. Just not worth the grief! Ah well, mutatis mutandis…..
-
@Rizio Il Ghiro said:
As a Gen X, I have to say that carrying a penknife was normal for me, but I grew up in rural areas and no-one ever frowned at carrying a penknife even at school (can’t imagine that now, but we saw them as tools not weapons), and in later life I carried a 91mm Golfer in my suit pocket when I was at work including flying on passenger jets all over the world, but that was before 9/11 and the subsequent clamp downs…. Although I happily still carry a SAK, I would think twice about having one in a pocket in London, and certainly wouldn’t use one in public there for fear of triggering someone into over-reacting…. Just not worth the grief! Ah well, mutatis mutandis…..I live in London and do carry a SAK on a daily basis, but I've made sure to memorise Section 139 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988 to quote politely in the extremely unlikely event that I'm ever pulled up for it. I have other UK legal knives like Manly Wasp, Byrd Tern and more which I can legally carry here under the above mentioned legislation, but because this is London I don't usually do so, to err on the side of caution.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
I have my Boomer theory on this.In decades past, a higher percentage of people grew up on farms, in rural settings or in remote small town settings. Kids were far more likely to be out on bikes, fishing, hiking or just kicking around. In those settings, having some level of skill troubleshooting/repairing stuff was essential.
Fast forward to a time where most are urban or to some extent suburban dwellers (most of whom do not even maintain their own lawn) and you have a group of people who fix everything with their credit card.
Kids are disadvantaged that their parents and older sibs have no practical skills and therefore they dont either.
With that as an upbringing, why would you carry a knife or MT?
Here in the UK people use their smartphone to fix everything nowadays, even credit cards are becoming more of a rare sight, most do contactless payments with their phones nowadays, and also many pay on public transport using them, which can be annoying if it takes them a few seconds to do so, for whatever reason.
I'm gen X and smartphones didn't become ubiquitous until I was in my late 30s so I am used to getting by without one, which means I am not 100% dependent on mine. Even for my age I suppose I am unusual in that I will nip out to the shops for groceries or beer without my smartphone, but won't set foot outside without a knife and lighter.
-
Obviously, I personally think it is still worthwhile to carry a pocket knife.
But I do think their popularity overall is in a bit of a long-term decline, for several reasons:
-
Decreased need (or at least decreased perceived need) - lower percentages of Americans hunting, or living on farms; “tear here” and other easy-open packaging; etc.
-
Hoplophobes - portraying knives primarily as dangerous weapons as opposed to useful tools; knives being banned from places they were once permitted, including schools, commercial aircraft, sports stadiums, etc.
-
-
I'm a later Gen-X. When I was in middle and high school, carrying my SAK with me was not a big deal. Sure, it wasn't 100% okay, but I was okay as long as I didn't make a big production out of it. I feel bad for the sprogs in the public school system these days; I'm pretty sure they have to walk through metal detectors, as if they're some sort of criminals. Makes me glad my niece and nephew are home-schooled.
@nate j said:
- Decreased need (or at least decreased perceived need) - lower percentages of Americans hunting, or living on farms; “tear here” and other easy-open packaging; etc.
I see a lot of those evil clamshell packages these days. The worst examples contain knives and other cutting tools. What if you need that tool very badly and you don't have anything to open that damn package?

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login