Back to the beginning.
-
When I was a kid, a very long time ago, my dad gave me a boy scout knife. The occasion was my joining the boy scouts at age 11ish. I think it set a trend.
I carried that knife all through school and up to my joining the army just after high school. It was a trusty companion on many camping trips both with the scouts, and after I let the scouting thing go after discovering girls and internal combustion engines that powered vehicles. I was handy having a pocket knife with a screw driver when you drive old cheap higher milage cars like Ford Falcons and VW bugs. Add in an adjustable wrench and you could fix darn near anything on those old cars.
Joining the army, I left the old scout knife home, as it had developed sentimental value and memories, and I was warned not to bring a knife to boot camp. So it went until I got out of boot camp and sent to Ft. Leonard Wood Missouri for AIT in combat engineers. Lo and behold, they added me a nice all stainless steel scout knife as part of my engineer tool kit, so I continued to just carry that. Kind of a cruder version of a SAK pioneer. Then sent to Germany, I was walking down the street in the medieval walled city of Rothenburg on a weekend off duty, and there it was; a big shiny red moving SAK in the window of a knife shop. I ended up buying my first SAK's A Huntsman, and a small tinker. They became daily companions for the next few years. Other SAK's came and went.
Time went on and after the service I became a knife nut for a while. The SAK's took a back seat to others, like some Randall's, Buck's, and others that came and went. Mostly went. But no matter what new toy of cutlery I was carrying, a SAK wasn't far away. In another pocket, in the daypack/backpack, car glove e box. They were always there if needed. Then it happened. It was like coming out of a fevered nightmare, or a period of temporary insanity. I started wondering what was I doing with all this other crap in my life. There was the huge downsizing of selling off and giving away all that I didn't really need. What I kept was the SAk's. I guess I never got fully used to a pocket knife that didn't have a few tools on it. Now, I don't even own anything but SAKs now, with them being the sole EDC I am carrying for the day. For several years I was a Case peanut fanatic, but that faded away along with my knife nut fever. Eventually, as I got "older" even the SAK's got trimmed down. The humble little classic is my daily EDC, and on some occasions if I think I need, it gets augmented by my old Wenger SI that I've had for a lot of years. If I think the classic might not do well with food duty that is on the schedule, or it I need something a bit more heavy duty, the old war horse Wenger goes along in a nice high ride nylon seat that goes on the belt behind my right hip. Not long ago, it was used at a BBQ where the disposable plastic knives were not quite up to cutting the racks of ribs apart. It got cleaned up later with hot water and Dawn dish soap. A little mineral oil on the joints the next day and all was good.So I started with a Boy Scout knife as a kid, went to SAK's, became a knife nut and spent all kinds of money silly knives that were all one trick ponies, then came back to a SAK that is like the boy scout knife I had as a kid. The classic and Wengeer SI are my only pocket knives anymore. I find they are all I need in my lifestyle. The circle got completed.
-
Thanks for sharing! Cool story and progression. I have also thought about trimming down the collection, as I am sure many have. However, I don’t think I would want to go without owning a locking OHO folder of some sort personally. So convenient when you only have one hand.
The SI is a great knife, as is the classic in its own right. Have any photos?
-
:D
:D -
Interesting read as always, Carl. Good to see you on the forum again!

Although I did not take the detour of being interested in other knives prior to becoming focused on SAKs, I have also discovered that more is less in recent years. When I got serious about SAKs a few years ago, I first started carrying rather large models like the Cybertool Lite, SC, CT41 and CT34. I was amazed by their promise and had the feeling to be prepared for everything when carrying them in my pocket.
However, I realized that in everyday life, size and weight matter more than that last ounce of versatility. So the SAKs I carried became smaller and smaller until I ended up with a Companion as my everyday, well, companion. I still reach for larger SAKs when travelling or hiking, but even then I rarely go for anything bigger than a Huntsman Lite.
I am not quite at the stage where I would solely rely on a 58 mm in everyday life, but I might get there eventually. Or rather I might get there again, because when I wasn't into the hobby yet, I had nothing but a Rambler on my keychain for years. And that was just fine
Cheers,
Simon
-
Rothenburg is a great town, incidentally I met my wife there. And I think I know exactly what shop you are talking about. :D
-
Awesome story about the awesome SAK!! Thanks for sharing

-
@Simon_Templar said:
However, I realized that in everyday life, size and weight matter more than that last ounce of versatility. So the SAKs I carried became smaller and smaller until I ended up with a Companion as my everyday, well, companion. I still reach for larger SAKs when travelling or hiking, but even then I rarely go for anything bigger than a Huntsman Lite.I am not quite at the stage where I would solely rely on a 58 mm in everyday life, but I might get there eventually. Or rather I might get there again, because when I wasn't into the hobby yet, I had nothing but a Rambler on my keychain for years. And that was just fine
Cheers,
Simon
That's what I had to find out the hard way. Or the longer and more expensive way! That not every day, or even every week did I need all the tools that are on the 'bigger' SAK's. I thought about that old boy scout knife that I used and the army issue demo knife that was just an all steel scout knife, and I got it all done with just the more minimal tool set. Life in modern urban environments is not that hard, and most of are not the star of a TV action show facing a life and death crisis every week. I'm not a hunter, I'm not a secret squirrel operator, just a retired machine shop guy living in Texas who like to hike and fish. Lots of fishing.
Now as a genuine old guy, I find that less is sometimes more. And sometimes when I feel the 58mm is not enough, I put the Wenger SI on my belt, but then after a day or two of not having needed it, I take it off and just go with the classic. So far today, I've used the classic to breakdown a cardboard box to fit in the recycle bin. cut down a waxed cardboard milk carton, opened my mail, cut two pieces of jute twine for the pepper plants out back in the garden, and filed a rough finger nail. And it's only 9AM here.
-

Thanks for sharing!
-
CBL51, from your story it seems like a Classic SD in Alox may be something that you would really enjoy. Have you looked at those? Depending on how often you need a toothpick/tweezers, you may even like it better than the standard classic.
-
@G-Dizzle said:
CBL51, from your story it seems like a Classic SD in Alox may be something that you would really enjoy. Have you looked at those? Depending on how often you need a toothpick/tweezers, you may even like it better than the standard classic.I love alox, but on a daily carry, I need the tweezers. Very often walking my dog here in Texas, she gets those pointy grass burrs in a paw, or up between the paw pads. The SAK tweezers do a great job of getting them out without any of the points sticking in my fingers. I've also plucked a few cactus stickers out of her as well. No, we need the tweezers here in Texas. When we travel to California, we have rubber soled nylon booties for her, and toward the end of summer when things get real dry here, we'll use the booties on her then too.
-
Love the story, but what is this "trimming down" that you speak of?

-
@cbl51 said:
So far today, I've used the classic to breakdown a cardboard box to fit in the recycle bin. cut down a waxed cardboard milk carton, opened my mail, cut two pieces of jute twine for the pepper plants out back in the garden, and filed a rough finger nail. And it's only 9AM here.Well, if ever you want to do all that with a 91mm SAK, the Companion might be a perfect, er, companion for you ;)
-
A Classic every day. SI for heavy reinforcements. Pepper plants in the garden. Catching some fish. Sounds like you have it all figured out to me. Best wishes. Gary

-
@PitCarver said:
what is this "trimming down" that you speak of?
I’m pretty sure it means “to get rid of knives and MTs one no longer needs”. I’ve yet to experience the urge to do this, however. In fact, I think I need all the MTs and knives I presently have, plus others I’ve yet to acquire.

-
Was just wondering where you'd gone, Carl! Glad you are posting, and, as usual, your contributions continue to inspire. Your Alox Forever thread will never die, I suspect!
Best,
Myron
-
^^^ Hear, hear !! :D

-
@nate j said:

I’m pretty sure it means “to get rid of knives and MTs one no longer needs”. *** I’ve yet to experience the urge to do this,*** however.
In fact, I think I need all the MTs and knives I presently have, plus others I’ve yet to acquire.Yes

And it's nice to have options for your EDC/work throughout the week depending on what you are doing.
Plus: I am a hoarder/collector .... and *also *get very attached to my possessions - So nothing is ever leaving me!
..... Although the acquisitions are slowing down quite dramatically -
Like others have said, good to see you back!

@cbl51 said:
I love alox, but on a daily carry, I need the tweezers. Very often walking my dog here in Texas, she gets those pointy grass burrs in a paw, or up between the paw pads.What kind of dog?
As for the lack of scale tools on Alox SAKs, pair an Alox Classic SD with a Cellidor Bantan, or vice versa.

-
@nate j said:

I’m pretty sure it means “to get rid of knives and MTs one no longer needs”. I’ve yet to experience the urge to do this, however. In fact, I think I need all the MTs and knives I presently have, plus others I’ve yet to acquire.

I had recently reached the point in EDC where I just wanted consistency and quality until I started mixing it up with challenges the past two months. I carried a CRK Sebenza, a Microstream or other small light, and a small MT like a Juice or a SAK. I actually sold several nice knives that I liked a lot just to get the CRK. I could see the appeal of paring the collection down to just what is sentimental, and just a few pieces of high quality user gear other than that.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
