Combo Tool Fail
-
I've opened a fair few cans with a Bantam's combo tool. Getting through the lid can be a struggle, but it works well enough once that hole is made...on smaller cans, anyway. It does tend to chew up the can pretty good, though. And it can always be worse: opening a can with the first iteration of the combo tool (with the blunted cutting tip) can really be a struggle.
-
I never tried a Bantam combo tool. I have tried the Wenger combo tool. The one I have won't make it through the top of a can at all. I gave it a good old pull and thought to myself, "Why are you doing this? You are going to break your cute little Wenger Picnic." It would be easy to put a bevel on the combo, but not worth the effort. The combo on a 108mm is very blunt.
I don't think too highly of Victorinox can openers either. The Wenger claw is much better. Leatherman openers are good too. Best wishes. G

-
I never carry my Scientist due to my disdain for the combo tool. That's why I bought an Explorer.
-
re@IMR4198 said:
I don't think too highly of Victorinox can openers either. The Wenger claw is much better. Leatherman openers are good too. Best wishes. G

Wenger CO > Vic CO >> Vic combo tool
when it comes to cans. But the screwdriver tip on the Vic CO gives it a lot of extra utility that I guess most people use more often.
-
@fullbreakfast said:
re
Wenger CO > Vic CO >> Vic combo toolwhen it comes to cans. But the screwdriver tip on the Vic CO gives it a lot of extra utility that I guess most people use more often.
I’d tend to agree.
I also use the Vic CO for opening split rings and prying things where there isn’t enough clearance for the cap lifter.
-
@nate j said:
I’d tend to agree.I also use the Vic CO for opening split rings and prying things where there isn’t enough clearance for the cap lifter.
Me too. Prying open battery compartments, then getting out button batteries; or getting under the lid of a jar to let some air in. It's quite handy for that sort of thing.
-
I carried a Gerber folding Magnum Hunter and a P38 in the latter '70s and early '80s. That was before I got into SOSAK. Used the P38 as a screwdriver. Don't tell Gary the P38 is multitool-ular.
-
My lips are sealed. I won't tell that nutjob nothing. Are you going to sign up for the Tool Box Challenge? There is still one opening. Maybe a couple of openings. The challenge might never be held again. It would make a very handsome first badge. Best wishes. G

-
If anyone isn't familiar with the Wenger combo-tool. Just to be safe. Best wishes. G
[attach id=0 msg=2553969]
-
Now I can't unsee that.

-
I'm somewhat fascinated by people who open cans in places other than their home kitchen. Where, you know, most people have real can openers.
But I know it happens, because I read about it here.
I've just never done it. And despite my vivid imagination, I'm hard-pressed to conjure up a situation where I would actually need a SAK can opener or combo tool.

-
@IMR4198 said:
I have tried the Wenger combo tool. The one I have won't make it through the top of a can at all.The Wenger combo tool definitely takes some effort if your aim is to bust into a can. Though I must admit I am rather fond of my Wenger Picnic.
@powernoodle said:
I'm somewhat fascinated by people who open cans in places other than their home kitchen. Where, you know, most people have real can openers.I am not most people. Why
invest inwaste my money on an electric can opener or a crank type when I have a few P-51s and a whole slew of multis? I have never used a multi can opener outside the kitchen, but that may change someday. -
@powernoodle said:
I'm somewhat fascinated by people who open cans in places other than their home kitchen. Where, you know, most people have real can openers.
But I know it happens, because I read about it here.
I've just never done it. And despite my vivid imagination, I'm hard-pressed to conjure up a situation where I would actually need a SAK can opener or combo tool.Camping trips

-
@fullbreakfast said:
It looks like a tired old basset hound yawning.My first thought was always Batman but old basset hound is very good!
-
I'm not a fan of the combo tool either. Too many compromises. Standard opening layer for the win.
-
@powernoodle said:
I'm somewhat fascinated by people who open cans in places other than their home kitchen. Where, you know, most people have real can openers.But I know it happens, because I read about it here.
I've just never done it. And despite my vivid imagination, I'm hard-pressed to conjure up a situation where I would actually need a SAK can opener or combo tool.
It’s certainly possible none of these apply to you, but here are a few scenarios (some already mentioned by others):
Camping - Did you (or someone) remember to pack a can opener? Where is it? Is it in working order? It’s easier and quicker IMO to have something in your pocket that will do the job.
Short-term rentals (e.g. Airbnb) - Similar questions to camping: Do they have a can opener? Can you find it? Does it work?
Large group - Lots of cans to open, lots of hands to help, but maybe only one or a few can openers
-
@powernoodle said:
I'm somewhat fascinated by people who open cans in places other than their home kitchen. Where, you know, most people have real can openers.But I know it happens, because I read about it here.
I've just never done it. And despite my vivid imagination, I'm hard-pressed to conjure up a situation where I would actually need a SAK can opener or combo tool.

As the wife and I got 'older', we gave up on the backpacking and kept on with our canoe camping, car camping, motorcycle camping. its common for us to be roasting hot dogs on a stick over a small fire while a can of chili is heating by the coals. The chilly comes in a can that has to be opened. chill dogs on a cool night is a nice thing. Many a can of chili has been opened by us by a camp fire.
Also at a air B&B we couldn't find a can opener for the ingredients of the spaghetti sauce I was making to go over the linguini, so the Wenger SI's can opener was needed for the diced tomatoes and tomato sauce.
And, not the least, is when the can that does have a pull tab, and I go to pull the tab and it breaks off, a can opener is a nice thing to have.
-
All good points, Mr. Carl. I have always appreciated your perspective on things.

I'm not saying that SAK can openers have never been used in the history of humanity. Rather, I've never needed one and never will.
The corkscrew comes in a very close second on my pointless SAK tool list, but I did loan one out one time for emergency cork popping. So my score is 1 corkscrew use in 6.3 decades, and zero can opener uses.
Hardly worth carrying around every day. For me, anywayz.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
