firearms
-
The military has been looking for a replacement for the Beretta for EVER.
I got so sick of following the rumors that I'm ignoring it all until something concrete comes out.
I LIKE the S&W M&P Poly pistols, and would love to see it adopted. It SEEMS like the 40 cal and 10mm have both passed their 'new hotness' phase and are on the decline. It's been pretty well proven that they don't really offer anything over 9mm. My guess, if I HAD to make one is that the next pistol will be 9mm, but that a .45 will be kept for 'elite' groups. But I really don't know.
I find shooting a 1911 to be physically punishing, and get no pleasure from them whatsoever. So, obviously, I'd prefer to see a 9mm make the cut. Everyone I know who likes 1911s are either BIG dudes, or dudes who like BIG bangs from their guns. I'm sure there are folks that aren't like that, but not among my shooting friends.
-
Ducttapetech will pretent that he didn't read that Lynn does not like the 1911 .45cal.
;D -
Do I get any redemption if I say I like .357?
LOVE me some .357 in a big, heavy revolver.
Better? :D
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Do I get any redemption if I say I like .357?LOVE me some .357 in a big, heavy revolver.
Better? :D
It helps somewhat. I prefer the K-frame, medium frame S&W personally. I've got a Model 19 Combat Magnum. It can be a bit of a handful with full-power loads though.
As to the .45 - The M1911 was designed for a reason that can be put very simply, but which is not exactly politically correct and I won't post it here. ;) In the Philippines, the .38 Long Colt revolvers used by the US military weren't stopping their targets. One Filipino prisoner was shot SIX TIMES at point blank range while trying to escape and was still fighting when someone clubbed him over the head with a Krag. The prisoner walked out of the hospital a week later. As a stopgap before the new pistol was adopted, the US used the Colt M1909 New Service revolver, which was chambered in what was basically a magnum loading of the old .45 Long Colt cartridge. Plenty of Colt Single Action Armys saw service in the Philippines as well. The M1909 is the most powerful sidearm ever to be adopted as standard issue by any army in history. The rim of the new loading was larger than the old army loadings for the SAA, so it couldn't fit in the older revolvers and blow them up. When the new pistol was going to be adopted, there wasn't a thought of a cartridge smaller than a .45. The US and the British saw pistols as legitimate combat weapons, and they used them heavily in colonial wars. The .455 Webley is a result of this as well.
-
I am with Lynn on this one.
Every couple of years there is a atricle about the coming change away from the M9 but it never actually happens.
If it does at some point I can almost bet it will be 9mm.
Had a Model 19 Smith about ten or so years ago that was stolen from my apartment. Sigh, I loved that pistol.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Do I get any redemption if I say I like .357?
LOVE me some .357 in a big, heavy revolver.
Better? :D
Ok. Ducttapetech will love Lynn some because she likes big beefy .357 revolver.
;DHarley wonders about the Sidekick situation though?
-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
I am with Lynn on this one.Every couple of years there is a atricle about the coming change away from the M9 but it never actually happens.
If it does at some point I can almost bet it will be 9mm.
Had a Model 19 Smith about ten or so years ago that was stolen from my apartment. Sigh, I loved that pistol.
:( Sorry to hear about your Model 19. I agree that if a new pistol is adopted, it will be in 9mm Parabellum. Special forces will continue to use the .45 I'm sure though. And you're right, pretty much from the get-go in 1985 there has been a call to replace the M9. Even if a new pistol is selected soon, you won't see it issued for several years anyway. For example, the competition that the M1911 won was actually held in 1907. The Beretta wasn't in widespread use with US forces until 1990-91 or so.
-
They just need to pick the G19 and be done with it already. :D
-
@captain spaulding said:
They just need to pick the G19 and be done with it already. :DI consider the Springfields and S&W M&Ps both better than Glocks.
However, I don't think the Glock is a terrible choice. There are now U.S. made Glocks, which while it doesn't make any difference in performance, it means work for U.S. workers to fill those contracts.
Oh... hey... look what I found...
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I consider the Springfields and S&W M&Ps both better than Glocks.Yeah, while I respect your opinion and your given right to have one.
How do I say this?
Poppycock!
Carried a S&W M&P for almost three years when I was a Police Officer and while it is a fine weapon it is not as good as a Glock.
Springfield Armory makes good weapons but which Springfield pistol do you say is better then Glocks? Maybe one of there high end 1911's? I stipulate that if you pay a couple grand then yes they are very nice.
Anyhow I am off to drink my Glock kool aid have a nice day.
-
Interesting. According to that article, it's a total platform replacement, including cartridge. We just might see the .45 adopted as standard again. Would it mess up NATO standardization? Not like we cared in 1965 when the M16 was adopted. After the big push by the US to force other member states to adopt the 7.62x51, we dropped it within ten years. To be fair, there was a big push because the main contender in that competition was the .280 British round, and there was a big "Not Invented Here" feeling. That's the same reason the M14 was adopted over the FN FAL.
-
I am with Lynn on this one.
Every couple of years there is a atricle about the coming change away from the M9 but it never actually happens.
If it does at some point I can almost bet it will be 9mm.
Had a Model 19 Smith about ten or so years ago that was stolen from my apartment. Sigh, I loved that pistol.
:( Sorry to hear about your Model 19. I agree that if a new pistol is adopted, it will be in 9mm Parabellum. Special forces will continue to use the .45 I'm sure though. And you're right, pretty much from the get-go in 1985 there has been a call to replace the M9. Even if a new pistol is selected soon, you won't see it issued for several years anyway. For example, the competition that the M1911 won was actually held in 1907. The Beretta wasn't in widespread use with US forces until 1990-91 or so.
Funny story.
Since getting to Afghanistan in June I have not seen one SF type person with any sidearm other then a M-9.
No idea why that is but there you go. Small sample that may mean nothing but strange none the less.
-
I am with Lynn on this one.
Every couple of years there is a atricle about the coming change away from the M9 but it never actually happens.
If it does at some point I can almost bet it will be 9mm.
Had a Model 19 Smith about ten or so years ago that was stolen from my apartment. Sigh, I loved that pistol.
:( Sorry to hear about your Model 19. I agree that if a new pistol is adopted, it will be in 9mm Parabellum. Special forces will continue to use the .45 I'm sure though. And you're right, pretty much from the get-go in 1985 there has been a call to replace the M9. Even if a new pistol is selected soon, you won't see it issued for several years anyway. For example, the competition that the M1911 won was actually held in 1907. The Beretta wasn't in widespread use with US forces until 1990-91 or so.
Funny story.
Since getting to Afghanistan in June I have not seen one SF type person with any sidearm other then a M-9.
No idea why that is but there you go. Small sample that may mean nothing but strange none the less.
Huh, that is interesting. My stepbrother is a HM2 in the Navy, and has spent time on the ground attached to Marine units. Though he trained with the M9, he is now issued an M4 carbine, which the Marine Corps uses in place of a pistol for anyone with a rank of O-5 and below that is authorized a sidearm.
I made a mistake in an earlier post about the M1911. Although the initial trials were held in 1907, the actual troop trials between the Colt and the Savage 1907 were held in 1910 and resulted in John Browning's design being adopted. The Savage went on to be a very popular civilian pistol in smaller calibers such as .380 ACP.
-
Glock 21 (the full size .45) would give a 13 round capacity? (Lynn looks up capacity)
The M&P would be 10.
I have a REALLY hard time believing the military is going to switch back to .45.
And I, personally, would still prefer 17 rounds of 9mm over 10 or even 13 rounds of .45
I wrote out a long response to the 'poppycock' comment. I deleted it. I just don't feel like wading through that fight. Gun folks have opinions more entrenched than MT people. And that's saying something.
-
@captain spaulding said:
They just need to pick the G19 and be done with it already. :DAs a shooter who actively dislikes the Glock, forget that!
I'd choose the Beretta, several HKs, and several Sigs over it. Not that it really matters, pistol use in combat is pretty rare. The Marines' decision to issue M4 carbines to everyone makes a lot of sense. Same reason we issued M1 carbines instead of pistols to support troops in WWII; give them something they can hit with.
As a side note, the Savage pistol was adopted by the Portugese Army in .32 ACP, with the result that it is one of the most common pistols you're likely to encounter in southern Africa.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Glock 21 (the full size .45) would give a 13 round capacity? (Lynn looks up capacity)The M&P would be 10.
I have a REALLY hard time believing the military is going to switch back to .45.
And I, personally, would still prefer 17 rounds of 9mm over 10 or even 13 rounds of .45
I wrote out a long response to the 'poppycock' comment. I deleted it. I just don't feel like wading through that fight. Gun folks have opinions more entrenched than MT people. And that's saying something.
Yeah in the end all the firearms you brought up are more then capable. You have my permission to use any of them to defend the life of you and yours.
That said Glock is better.

-
@captain spaulding said:
They just need to pick the G19 and be done with it already. :D
As a shooter who actively dislikes the Glock, forget that!
I'd choose the Beretta, several HKs, and several Sigs over it. Not that it really matters, pistol use in combat is pretty rare. The Marines' decision to issue M4 carbines to everyone makes a lot of sense. Same reason we issued M1 carbines instead of pistols to support troops in WWII; give them something they can hit with.
As a side note, the Savage pistol was adopted by the Portugese Army in .32 ACP, with the result that it is one of the most common pistols you're likely to encounter in southern Africa.
Work computer would not let me put two quotes in one reply.
"Actively dislikes the Glock" Yeah I feel you. I also dislike effective, easy to use, reliable and inexpensive things. I also hate when the company that makes these products has excellent customer service and supports the the use of there products in both law enforcement and shooting games.
Makes sense to me.

"Not that it really matters, pistol use in combat is pretty rare." Agree with this. Well that part of it where use is rare. I would like to say that I think it does matter. While rare it does happen and why not have the most effective pistol and caliber? it is your life on the line.
-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
Yeah in the end all the firearms you brought up are more then capable.That said Glock is better.



Sigs are too expensive for my blood. I've shot a number of them and they're nice, but not worth the price, IMO. I mean, if I were rich... But I don't expect the military is going to adopt something that expensive. Also, I wasn't all that impressed with the p226. MASSIVE barrel flip for a pistol its size.
I'm not sure what the ammo stockpiles are like in the military, but that might also strongly influence staying with 9mm.
While carbines are great, and get you a lot more out of pistol caliber rounds, they're not all that handy for having on you in a lot of situations. Tank crew comes to mind. I think there's likely always going to be a role for pistols.
Now... see... you knuckleheads got me back on this stupid speculation. Grrrr.... :D
-
The Glock has a great reputation. However I grew up with 1911s and Browning HiPowers and it feels totally wrong in my hand. Also don't like the mushy trigger pull. Will stick with my HK USP and CZ 75 Shadow.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login